Marriage Equality Research Paper

Submitted By Captivefreedumb
Words: 1055
Pages: 5
Open Document
Marriage Equality
The United States has been a country for over 230 years. In that time, the laws of the nation have been evolving to meet their original intent of equality. Slavery, abolished. Women, granted suffrage. Segregation by race, color, and creed, deemed unacceptable. However, the American people have another hurdle to clear before they can claim to be members of a just society. Voters in multiple states have seen fit to restrict the ability of same-sex couples to seek equal rights and protections under the law, by passing bills to ban or otherwise prevent their marriage (Hatzenbuehler, PhD, O’Cleirigh, PhD, Grasso, MPH, Mayer, MD, Safren, PhD, & Bradford, PhD, 2012). Even though many religious institutions consider same-sex marriage immoral, it is necessary for a civil society because laws should treat everyone equally and there is no financial or societal benefit in banning it.
The right or privilege of same-sex couples to marry has been a highly publicized topic in the past several years with the passage and subsequent challenge of Proposition 8 in California, the passage of Amendment 1 in North Carolina and the constitutional challenge of the Defense of Marriage Act. These modifications to the constitutions of the respective states violate the intent of the 14th amendment to the United States Constitution, which directs "no State … shall deprive any person of life, liberty or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person … the equal protection of the laws" (U.S. Const. amend. XIV). The sexual orientation of an individual does not nullify their need for protection under the law. In Perry v Schwarzenneger, the US District Court found Prop. 8 to be unconstitutional (2010). However, Amend. 1 has not yet entered the court system and the idea that the majority of people can vote to restrict the rights of a minority is a very dangerous precedent, if it is allowed to be enacted. Aside from this, the passages of these laws have negative financial ramifications.
Depriving a group of people equal rights does not have any financial or societal benefit. Aside from the indirect costs of fighting these unconstitutional laws in the court system, keeping gay marriage illegal costs U.S. taxpayers nearly $1 billion dollars annually. A study by the Congressional Budget Office in 2004 found that the impact of allowing same-sex marriage “…would improve the budget's bottom line to a small extent: by less than $1 billion in each of the next 10 years” (Congressional Budget Office, 2004). A ‘small extent’ is relative to the rest of the federal budget, but a billion dollars a year for 10 years is no small sum of money. Furthermore, there is nothing for our culture to gain by alienating homosexual couples. Gays and lesbians are members of our families, social groups, and workplaces, demeaning them with hateful laws and indicating to them their relationships are of less value than a heterosexual couple is not going to cause them to cease to exist. It will, however, serve to marginalize them. Ostracizing productive members of society is not progress and is a detriment to civilization as a whole. Societal benefit by the legislation of moral values is often cited as a reason to prevent same-sex marriages.
The core teachings of many religions denounce homosexuality as a sin, unnatural and morally wrong. I understand this and though I disagree with it, it is the right of these religions to teach such things. The nation was settled and founded by peoples and their descendants seeking, among other things, freedom from religious persecution by the kings and governments of their homelands. This was such an important ideal that it was codified in the First Amendment to the Constitution, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof;…” (U.S. Const. amend. I). It is this second clause that is important here. The First Amendment, having been
Show More

Related Documents: Marriage Equality Research Paper

Marriage Equality Essay

One of the basic principals for the social work profession is social justice. In order to achieve social justice social workers must often times take part in policies and programs that seek to reach equality for individuals who are not treated fairly. According to the National Association of Social Worker’s Code of Ethics “Social workers should engage in social and political action that seeks to ensure that all people have equal access to the resources, employment, services, and opportunities they…

Words 2848 - Pages 12

Marriage Equality Essay

Marriage Equality Britney N. France Tusculum College Abstract Gays and lesbians argue that their right to get married is equal to everyone else's. Christian groups and many church officials argue that gay marriage is immoral and against God's plan for marriage. The successful, pragmatic strategy of gay activists has been to assert that same-sex marriage will not change the institution itself. Their argument is that there is no need to defend marriage against loving same-sex couples, because these…

Words 1537 - Pages 7

Marriage Equality Essay

Marriage Equality Inquiry Questions • What is Marriage Equality? • Where in Australia has a marriage equality bill ever been passed and what were the effects? • What are the consequences and results of same-sex marriage in other countries around the world? Question 1: What is Marriage Equality? The Australian Constitution states that Marriage Equality is the recognition, performance and/or acceptance of a same-sex marriage. Question 2: Where in Australia has a marriage…

Words 1972 - Pages 8

Essay on Marriage Equality

Marriage Equality Tiffany Harris April 3, 2013 Comm/215 Latashia Bates Marriage Equality The upcoming decisions on Marriage Equality by the Supreme Court for same sex couples. Should marriage still be considered a religious arrangement or is it seen as just a civil union between to people? In the recent weeks TV and social media have been abuzz over the debate both sides fighting for what each believes is right. I believe that it should be every Americans right…

Words 696 - Pages 3

Essay on Marriage Equality

Marriage is a human right 1 Running Head: Marriage is a human right Marriage is a human right; not a heterosexual privilege…

Words 835 - Pages 4

Essay about Marriage Equality

On Marriage Equality Marriage equality is a subject that frequently triggers intense emotions for those who battle towards the legalization of it and for those who battle against. Same-sex marriage is the union of two individuals of same sex in a marital relationship with full legal rights, recognition, and protection by the state as in the marital contract between a man and a woman. Currently over 37% of Americans live in 17 states that have adopted full equality on the state-level, another 12%…

Words 2044 - Pages 9

Essay on Equity: Same-sex Marriage and Marriage Equality

on same-sex marriage paving the way for marriage equality for all California residents. California Attorney General Kamala Harris argued before the Circuit Court to overturn Prop 8. There was the possibility that it could take up to twenty-five days before same sex couples can legally marry after the Circuit Court struck down Prop 8. Attorney General Kamala Harris then urged the court to act sooner. Meanwhile, Governor Jerry Brown directed all California counties to issue marriage licenses to…

Words 521 - Pages 3

Classical: Same-sex Marriage and Marriage Equality Usa Essay

Monica Se******* Mrs. LaTour English 101 10th April 2013 Equality for All The media is constantly influencing the American society on what equality consists of. In 2008 the state Supreme Court of California ruled that same sex marriages are legal under the state Constitution. This ruling stirred up many emotions throughout the American society. Both positive and negative opinions came exploding from all directions. Same sex couples took quite a beating with all the media exposure about if their…

Words 1430 - Pages 6

Out Of The Shadows: The Push For Marriage Equality

Christian Caron Professor Schurin POLS 1602 April 26, 2013 Out of the Shadows: The Push for Marriage Equality The United States has long struggled to realize its Declaration of Independence’s promise “that all men are created equal.” At the country’s inception, slavery fueled the Southern economy, and only a fragment of the population could legally exercise their right to vote. The full benefits of citizenship were unavailable to women, ethnic minorities and the poor. Nevertheless, voting…

Words 2974 - Pages 12

Marriage Equality, a Basic Human Right Essay

Oualid Jniyah K.Wiley ENC 091 December 5, 2014 Marriage Equality Too many people argue that same sex marriage should not be legalized because it offends religions (Christianity), it turns a Moral Wrong into a Civil Right, and it violates the natural law, even some politicians have always opposed same-sex marriage, according to Senator Michele Bachmann, on the gay community and same-sex marriage, “This is a very serious matter, because it is our children who are the prize for this community…

Words 757 - Pages 4