marxism essay

Submitted By nemochang
Words: 1078
Pages: 5
Open Document
Outline and evaluate Marxist explanations of crime

“Crime is social in origin and a normal response to prevailing cultural conditions” (Willem Bonger) Marxist believe that reason that it is the ruling class that is responsible for criminalising the working classes, which goes directly against what official statistics and Functionalism believe. However, Marxism and Functionalism do share a similarity in that both believe structures and institutions of society play a very important role in determining how people behave, criminally or otherwise.

Marxist sociologists argue that it is the nature of exploitative economic systems that capitalist societies have in place that is primarily responsible for crime. This is because the bourgeoisie and ruling classes oppress and exploit the working classes, which drives them into poverty. As the workers try to end exploitation whilst the owners of the means of production aim to keep the system to maintain profits. Most Marxists agree that crime is the result of poverty created through this system, for example people steal because they are materially deprived which is a result of low wages being paid by the ruling classes. This is a reason Marxists would give for the over-representation of the working classes in official crime statistics. On the other hand, Functionalism may argue that crime is not caused by material deprivation but by poor socialisation.

Another Marxist explanation is that it isn’t just the material deprivation caused by “wage slavery” but that capitalism generates crime due to the selfish mindset it creates. These feelings create crime as people put themselves first and in this world of advertising and consumerist culture. Chambliss states that the capitalist system fosters crime at all levels within the system. He also states that crime is built in to capitalist societies and from the boardroom to factory we are motivated by an insatiable desire for wealth. Marxist argued people within the capitalism develop commodity fetishism. Under capitalism everything that can be exchanged at a value becomes a commodity, even labour. An obsession with products where products are the goal in life, not human relationships.

Another explanation is that the law defends the interest of the ruling class. (chambliss 1976). Also the law protects private property. Also Marxist believe that the media is controlled by the rich people. Politicians from ruling class backgrounds are also influenced by them. Laws are made by the state, which represent the interests of the ruling class, this forms the basis of a theory for widespread crime and selective law enforcement; crime occurs right through society, but only poor criminals receive harsher punishments. However fuctionalists argue that law benefits everyone and it represent interests other than the rich. Feminist would argue that the law benefits men.

Marxist state white collar crimes, a crime committed by a person of responsibility and high social status in the course of his occupation. (Edwin Sutherland) There are two main types of white collar crime: crimes committed by professionals, or executives in the course of there occupation (occupational crime) and crimes committed b corporations or businesses, including pollution, fraud or corporate manslaughter. (corporate crimes).
By focusing on street crimes many sociologists ignore crimes of the powerful. Marxist suggest that white collar crimes are neglected due to blue collar crimes as they are more obvious and straight forward so police are less active in investigating white collar crimes. Government agencies often have little power to make a difference if they find wrong doing by white collar workers they often apply fines rather than a sentence.

It can be argued that Marxists ignore individual motivation of crime and over concentrate on the nature of capitalism and how economic factors force people to act in certain ways.
Show More

Related Documents: marxism essay

Essay on Sociology: Marxism and Traditional Marxism

labour and appearing to have a caring face, their is a false consciousness created amongst workers as they don't realise their exploitation. Equally important is the view of the Neo-Marxists, in particular Taylor et al who argue that traditional Marxism is deterministic. For example, it sees workers as driven to commit crime out of an economic necessity, but Taylor et al reject this idea, along with theories that claim crime is caused by other external factors such as anomie, subcultures or labelling…

Words 1188 - Pages 5

Marxism: Marxism and State Planning Agency Essay

Marxism In the 1840s, Marx began to argue that the only way for socialism to happen was for workers themselves to force the change. He wrote of a society where the workers owned the factories and farms where they were employed. Other elements of a Marxist society included free education, the abolishment of the army of the prior state, the right to vote and the right to determine representatives' pay and recall them if necessary. Marx's ideas greatly influenced Vladimir Lenin, one of the leaders…

Words 774 - Pages 4

Health: Marxism and People Essay

Social Inequality Unit 04 [pic] What are Marxist theories of inequality? Learning targets: • Marxism is concerned for the poor and powerless. • It claims that society is in conflict between the rich who control everything and the poor who must work for the rich and gain little in reward for their work. • The rich are able to maintain their position of power through control of the law, the police and other forms of authority. • The rich also control the manufacture…

Words 3807 - Pages 16

Marxism essay match up

Outline and evaluate Marxist views of the role of the family in society [33] • On the next slide is a plan for the Marxism essay. It has headings of issues to cover, which are colour coded. On the 3rd slide are the arguments and evidence that fit into these headings. • Move the evidence/arguments into the right sections on the plan. • The colour of the headings matches the headings. If you want to make it harder use the terms which are in black and white on the 4th slide. Outline and evaluate…

Words 1035 - Pages 5

Marxism and family Essay

1. Using material from item 2B and elsewhere assess the Marxist view that the main role of the family is to serve the interests of capitalism. Capitalism is society where there is a divide between two classes the bourgeoisie and the proletarians; Marxist sees the society as a massive supper structure with the bourgeoisie at the base of the structure and the proletarians. The bourgeoisie control the proletarians, using them for cheep labour and exploitation. Marxist view of the family is to…

Words 388 - Pages 2

Essay on Marxism Abstract

The German Ideology by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels was written in 1846, and later published in 1932 by David Riazanov in Moscow. Karl Marx himself was born in 1818 to an ancestrally Jewish family, only to be given a secular education in the efforts of furthering his and the family’s careers. He was largely unreligious, and so when Hegel’s writings became popular, Marx became a Young or Left Hegelian, who criticized the philosophy from a ‘left-hand perspective’. Eventually though, he became dissatisfied…

Words 566 - Pages 3

Marxism and Its Contribution to the World Politics Essay

German thinkers Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels developed a theory mainly based on a materialist view of history and society in early 1900s, which is commonly referred as Marxism. Since its' introduction to the political science Marxism have become one of the core schools of thoughts in international relations. However, Marxism in practice has evolved and shown differentiations from the initial thoughts and ideas argued by Marx and Engel. Especially Bolshevik leaders such as Lenin and Stalin have…

Words 3247 - Pages 13

Marxism in Titanic Essay

Critical Evaluation of Marxism in Titanic – Stephanie Kiewel – Critical Appraisal Film 5010 – Dec. 2013 The film Titanic used to be the most successful film of all times. The romantic disaster movie was released in 1997. It deals with both the historical catastrophe where 1,517 passengers lost…

Words 3042 - Pages 13

Marxism and Communism Christian Communism Essay

Introduction Communism is a social structure in which classes are abolished and property is commonly controlled, as well as a political philosophy and social movement that advocates and aims to create such a society.Karl Marx, the father of communist thought, posited that communism would be the final stage in society, which would be achieved through a proletarian revolution and only possible after a socialist stage develops the productive forces, leading to a superabundance of goods and services…

Words 4976 - Pages 20

Capitalism vs Marxism Essay example

Capitalism vs Marxism An essay on which economy is the better choice. By Kiros Johnson 1 An economy, as defined by dictionary.com, is the management of resources of a country with a view to its productivity. There are multiple economies in this world, all of which think they are better than the other. It’s almost as if the economies are political parties fighting over a piece of land. However, economies vary among all. The writer will…

Words 846 - Pages 4