Medical Care At The Crossroad

Submitted By bcamin
Words: 868
Pages: 4
Open Document
MEDICARE at CROSSROAD
Canada is at the crossroad today. The number of older Canadians is increasing dramatically as the baby boomers age. All across the country, waiting lists keep growing and many patients cannot find a family doctor. Governments have huge deficits and hard-pressed for additional funds. Critics argue that urgent action is needed and that by encouraging people to pay will lessen wait times. However, in reality, Canadians would be worse off if they had to pay for some of their medical care themselves.
First, if patients have to pay for medical care currently publicly funded, many families will avoid going to the doctor endangering their health. A study found that, patients charged user fees in Saskatchewan in 1968 and eliminated seven years later reduced the annual use of medical services by about six per cent (Beck, R.G. & Horne, J, 787). In 1996, Quebec implemented a scheme requiring patients to pay part of the cost of drugs. The Journal of American Medical Association conducted a study on this, which revealed that patients reduced their use of fewer critical drugs and critical drugs and seriously affecting their health (421). This would deter or delay using the health system until their illness gets serious. User fees would deter the frugal, less advantaged and lower-income from getting the help that they need. Do we as a society want parents to decide whether parents should take their kids to the doctor or buy groceries?
Secondly, health insurance policies are inconsistent, expensive, cumbersome, hard to discern, full of fine print and contain many loopholes. Most Canadians face a huge tax burden, rising cost of living and will not be able to pay for these additional medical expenses out of the pocket. To offload risk, most individuals will resort to buying health insurance.
In their article Raisa Deber and Noralou Roos rightly noted that insurance policies discriminate the needy people:
The insurance package that patients buy is susceptible to rapid change. In their article, expert’s highlight, a report from the Commonwealth Fund that raises concerns regarding premiums increasing thrice the rate of median income. Deductibles have also increased by 80% during 2003 to 2009. Furthermore, the report contains grim warning that the most vulnerable and in need of medical attention have trouble finding an insurance company that will cover them.
Insurance companies will be cherry pick the young and healthy and avoid patients with complicated medically issues. One can draw parallels with car insurance where selected drivers having low premiums while neighbourhoods with newcomers have very high premiums. Insurance companies will be discriminate against patients with known pre-existing conditions and use the fine print to deny coverage of certain ailments. Even worse, patients face the prospect that the insurance coverage can be cancelled – leaving the vulnerable at the mercy of their company.
Finally, Allowing Canadian to pay for more of their medical care will lead to the slippery path of US two-tier health systems. A system where as former Prime Minister, Jean Chretien said, “down there, they check your wallet before your pulse” where well-off has access to quality medical care, while roughly 50 million people are without any health coverage (10). Allowing a two-tier system would lead to a private paid health care sector to draw doctors from the public system. We already have a shortage of doctors and if physicians work outside of the public system, the supply will be reduced [in the public system], and thereby actually increasing waits times. Ask yourself, how many
Show More

Related Documents: Medical Care At The Crossroad

Analysis Of Parting At The Crossroads By Antonia Maission

Antonia Maioni, in her book Parting at the Crossroads: “The Development of Health Insurance in Canada and the United States” compares which country has the best healthcare system. Although these neighbors develop different forms of health insurance, universal health care system in Canada while a dual-tiered system of Medicare and Medicaid, what population does it target to and, what portion of the nation is neglected. Moreover, how the misidentification can cause a divergence between two different…

Words 77 - Pages 1

Occupational Therapy Career Plan

As I was searching for a job to report on for my second career profile I found myself at a crossroads and confused as to what I could report on. I found myself in this position because I never saw myself as anything other than a physical therapist and to me this was tough to find another job to report on that I could see myself being just as passionate in as I plan to be in physical therapy. At first I landed on athletic training, but then decided to make a quick pivot and go in the direction of…

Words 850 - Pages 4

Bioethics, Unit 3, Web Research_Justice and Health Care Essay

The impact of a trillion-dollar deficit for widespread government expenses severely affects the additional costs for the program, as well as needing additional funds to help in coverage costs. The plan appears to transfer funds from areas such as Medicare and Medicaid and other programs to defray the growing costs of the Affordable Care Act. According to Battistella (2013, p. 410) “Obamacare truly represents a historical milestone in the nation’s century-long quest for universal health coverage…

Words 845 - Pages 4

Canada's Health Care System Essay

Canada Health act being a federal legislation (Bernard, 1992, p. 102). Federal budget cuts, has caused various problems within Medicare such as increased waiting times and lack of new technology. Another problem with Medicare is that The Canada Heath Act does not cover expenditures for prescriptions drugs. All these issue has caused individuals to suggest making Medicare privatized. Although, Canada’s health care system consists of shortcomings, our universal…

Words 4022 - Pages 17

2009 power of prevention Essay

The Power of Prevention Chronic disease . . . the public health challenge of the 21st century 2009 National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion The Power of PrevenTion ChroniC disease . . . the publiC health Challenge of the 21st Century The United States spends significantly more on health care than any other nation. In 2006, our health care expenditure was over $7,000 per person, more than twice the average of 29 other developed countries.2 We also have one of the fastest…

Words 6491 - Pages 26