Simmons School Of Social Work

Submitted By Johannes-Kieding
Words: 1859
Pages: 8
Open Document
Men of Simmons
Johannes Kieding
Simmons School for Social Work
Social Action

Professor Bailey

Men of Simmons
In early September 2014 another MSW student and I put our heads together and decided to form a men’s group at Simmons. We both had questions around whether or not sexism was being sufficiently covered in the school’s curriculum, we both took an interest in the fact that as males we were minorities on campus, and I in particular felt that one of the best ways to deconstruct notions of masculinity rooted in patriarchy and sexism was to encourage healthy alternatives of what it means to be a man – to not just find what is wrong with masculinity as it has been socially constructed, but to also find aspects of masculinity worth kindling, worth celebrating.
We tossed around ideas until we finally coalesced around a couple of core principles and agendas we agreed upon for the group. This paper will discuss the thinking behind the group, the current status of the group, and my hopes for the group moving forward. I will be using Mizrahi and Rosenthal’s (2001) 4 C’s as a lens through which to analyze the men’s group project.
The poster that we ended up putting up on campus read as follows:
Men of Simmons is a new process-oriented support group for men at Simmons School of Social Work.
How do masculinity, sexism and feminism challenge or augment our experience as male social work students?
What isn’t being discussed in class? What else can we do to best prepare future social workers to confront gender-related practice issues?
An initial draft had included my ideas about finding a version of masculinity worth celebrating – along the lines of not throwing out the baby with the bathwater -- but this idea was ultimately rejected after consultations the administration. The idea was that by using the language that I had initially suggested we were coming too close to resembling the mainstream men’s movement that sees itself as oppressed and therefore flies in the face of what we know about the many unearned privileges that come with being male and the oppressive forces women are up against. I reconciled this outcome with thinking that my initial idea had more to do with pedagogy than actual substance – men are more likely to buy into the group if they feel welcomed and hear that there are aspects of their male identities worth celebrating – it’s not all bad. It was these words spoken by Paolo Freire (1988) that went through my mind at this time: “Social work practice, whether case-work, group work, or community organization, is inherently and substantively educational-pedagogical” (Freire, 2009, p. 93). I felt strongly that it would help men buy into the group if they knew there were aspects of their masculine identities worth cherishing. Bowing to the powers that be, however, the aforementioned wording became codified.
What do I hope to accomplish with this men’s group and how potentially effective might the project be in meeting the goals? Why the focus on gender/sex? Mimi Abramovitz, in speaking to the importance of gender, writes, “Gender, like race and class, structure the organization of social life” (Abramovitz, 1996, p. 13). As male social workers on the front lines of client-services we are in a unique position as agents of change. We can use our unearned privilege for good, we can begin the process of deconstructing unhealthy gender identities rooted in patriarchy and internalized sexism. For this to happen, the social work curriculum at Simmons School for Social Work must adequately incorporate readings and other materials that shed light on gender related issues in the clinical setting, and to my thinking, must provide healthy masculine alternatives, not simply find fault. Central to this goal is receiving input from participants in perceived gaps in the curriculum and giving this feedback to the school in the hopes that these gaps will be addressed. Furthermore, it’s a fact that females far outnumber males
Show More

Related Documents: Simmons School Of Social Work

Cousin Simmons Traits

Cousin Simmons is the village blacksmith, a relative of the Coopers and the father of Ruth. Joseph is a big, heavy set man with a large appetite and a lovable personality. He is not as intelligent as Moses Cooper, but he is kinder. April Morning written by Howard Fast happens over approximately twenty-four hours in the town of Lexington, Massachusetts and it edges toward the start of the American Revolution. The story begins late in the day on April 18, 1775, and ends the next night. Joseph was a…

Words 543 - Pages 3

Friendship Drama When It's Time To Stop Perseverating And Let It Go Analysis

Rachel Simmons, clearly points out the socio-cultural issues of stereotyping, friendship and bullying. According to Rachel Simmons’ in her article, most modern parents are, maybe too permissive to girls to an extent whereby an act of neglect is clear. The girls end up being selfish and self-centered. In another article by Karen Valby, “The Realities of Raising a Kid of a Different Race,” the writers focuses on the issue of child adoption, racism and stereotyping. From my analysis of Simmons’ article…

Words 506 - Pages 3

Tuskegee Syphilis Research Paper

Ayanna Simmons The Tuskegee Syphilis Study was one of the worst research crimes using humans as test subjects inhumane research studies in American medicine in the 20th century. “Eventually, it included autopsy. It did not include treatment either for syphilis or secondary problems including heart disease” (Edgar, 1992). For forty years doctors watched as their “experiment” took…

Words 1279 - Pages 6

Essay on The Death Penalty

Virginia case and the Roper v. Simmons case. In Atkins v. Virginia case Daryl Renard Atkins was convicted of abduction, armed robbery, and capital murder, and sentenced to death. At approximately midnight Atkins along with his partner William Jones were armed with a semiautomatic handgun where they abducted a man by the name of Eric Nesbett. They robbed all of his money and brought him to a nearby automated bank teller where they made him withdraw all of his money. The two men didn’t realize there were…

Words 1754 - Pages 8

Their Eyes Were Watching God By Zora Neale Hurston

rebuilding and taking over Eatonville, Florida as their new mayor, Joe also easily dominates Janie. Simmons describes Joe by stating, “Joe’s authority, she shows, replicates the authority by which whites have oppressed African American” (Simmons 183). The quote reinstates the power Joe holds over both Eatonville and Janie. With this restricting authority he prohibits her form engaging in conversation with other men and forces her to keep her hair hidden away under a scarf. Janie’s compliance to his demands…

Words 1348 - Pages 6

Argumentative Essay: Should All Players Be Paid?

One and Done “I had 190 dollars, in my account and I spent 140 dollars at Wal-Mart because I needed linen and new bedding and stuff, so now I have fifty dollars, it’s gotta last me a week.” – (Ben Simmons), what does it take to fulfill a dream? Determination, perseverance, and hard work, most would agree that these attributes are needed to fulfill your dream or goal. People would spend hours, weeks, and months, even years to be successful, so once they have their dream job, they know this has happened…

Words 1451 - Pages 6

Ku Klux Klan Political Influence

During the Reconstruction Era in a devastated South shortly after the Civil War, the scene for the rise of the Ku Klux Klan was set. Since then, there has been three different incarnations of the Klan, with its political influence and membership peaking during the 1920’s in its second form. A group which originally sought out to disenfranchise and prevent blacks from entering society by means of violence and murder, now had bigger goals. The second Klan targeted Jews, Catholics, immigrants, and more…

Words 1589 - Pages 7

Opportunism In All The Kings Men

All the King’s Men was shallowly construed by critics as an exclusively political novel when initially published. After all, Robert Warren clearly expresses his dissatisfaction with the rampant corruption in the Deep South by basing Willie Stark on the ruthless Louisiana governor Huey P. Long. The critics seized the novel for its political commentary and extrapolated political sentiments from the novel to predict Warren’s own beliefs. Increasingly however, critics now realize that the novel’s focus…

Words 1578 - Pages 7

Gender Stereotypes In Television Sitcoms

circumstances in a way that is entertaining to the viewer. Gender, gender roles, and gender stereotypes have been portrayed variously throughout television sitcoms. Some portraying women, mothers, housewives as “like a child to the man, husband, father” (Simmons and Rich 2013). Referring back to Gender Role Portrayal and the Disney Princess, and the masculine and feminine characteristics categorized, I could easily see some of the characteristics in the male and female characters in the shows I was watching…

Words 685 - Pages 3

Rabbit Proof Fence Film Analysis

Mateship, good humor, courage and ingenuity are all qualities that come to mind when hearing ‘Australian heroes’ or ‘significant Australians’. These characteristics stereotypically relate to the well renowned ANZAC legends and significant men of Australia that are shown through the lens of Australian film. Australian film has used stereotypes to engage and beguile audiences for the past 100 years. However, what many Australian films fail to capture is the heroic and significant women who also convey…

Words 678 - Pages 3