Essay on Military and Battles

Submitted By tm2005
Words: 801
Pages: 4
Open Document
Timothy Myers
Concept of Decisive Battles
History, Mon-Wed-Fri

1) What big change(s) did the article discuss?
The author aims to argue about why the concept of decisive battles was found so useful by historians from ancient times up until a few decades ago, also why the concept had been abandoned. He also aims to evaluate whether or not this concept could still be of any use to historians as well as to the writing of world history. In some opinion it is said that medieval war was not controlled by battles but in fact that war was dominated by sieges, raids, skirmishes and ambushes. The change being argued in this article was the fact that “Battles” were no longer the main focus of historical writing and that battles were beginning to no longer act as the main focus for new historical writers.
2) What caused this change?
This change has come from the writing of new military historians, rather than surveying and the explaining of battle tactics historians had begun to focus on things such as recruitment, administration, supply systems, society at war and the culture of war. All of which would need more information to accurately write about. Battles were more so two military powers lining up and just having at one another. Some argue that battles had no decisive impact on history due to their lack of strategy, political and operational factors. Another reason for this change was the fact that world historians had become fond of explaining historical developments through long term structural factors which battles had lacked. Decisive battles have fallen due to three key reasons. There are currently no more battles on land, battles that have happened recently can no longer provide historians with simple writing. Finally with battles lasting months rather than hours they lose their ability to change the balance of power.
3) What were important consequences of this change? The way that historical books would now be written had changed due to the views most now had on the term Decisive battles. Although it is proven battles had their moments of glory and had caused major historical changes there was just no complexity behind them. Battles had somewhat lost their throne in history and had been taken over by the idea that battles could not truly be decisive. Battles had been proven to be the least representative of historical events. However some battles such as the one of Antioch were capable of changing history they more so allowed for historical windows to open allowing weaker militaries to overcome stronger opponents.

I felt that the author did a great job backing up his argument and explaining why the concept of decisive battles had begun to diminish over the years. There was great detail involved and I liked how he had stuck to one primary battle to explain his argument rather than jumping around and using too many events. While using the battle of Antioch to explain his argument he made very valid points, explain
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Military and Battles

Military: Battle of Iwo Jima Essay

novel starts with Bradley talking about his father, Jack “Doc” Bradley, and his upbringing around a father who never wanted to talk about his experiences during the war. Bradley says he did not know hardly anything about his father’s service in the military until after his death in 1994. After finding a letter from his father to his parents that was sent from Iwo Jima, Bradley decided to dig deeper. In the novel Bradley takes a trip with his family to Iwo Jima, and after discussing the experience…

Words 777 - Pages 4

Napoleon Bonaparte Research Paper

Napoleon Bonaparte: Military Leader or Poor Strategist Born in Ajaccio, Corsica on August 15, 1769, Napoleon Bonaparte was a dynamic military commander, and a charismatic leader even before he crowned himself emperor of France in 1804. Reigning only for a short span, Napoleon was motivated to repair France as he established his military dictatorship that would conqueror most of Italy, and various parts of the Holy Roman Empire. Though Napoleon is celebrated as a military genius, and is noted for…

Words 1159 - Pages 5

Polly Schoyer Brooks Battle Against The British

Furthermore, Joan’s military skill during war successfully helped the French win numerous important battles against the British. After Joan’s leadership motivated the French army, and got them rallied behind her she still needed to develop skilled tactics in order to defeat the British. As mentioned before, the French were being badly defeated in the Battle of Orleans when Joan inspired her army. On top of that, Polly Schoyer Brooks states, “The French turned back to the assault and pressed with…

Words 674 - Pages 3

Fort Pitt Campaign Analysis

has about the topic. This interest must manifest in the specific topic of study such as military history. The Fort Pitt Campaign, consisting of the siege of Fort Pitt and the Battle of Bushy Run representing a little studied and understood event during Pontiac’s War. Having lived over twenty years near the battlefield, yet never visiting the battlefield until the two hundred and fiftieth anniversary of the Battle of Bushy Run, introduced an event that was important to the growth of the United States…

Words 1226 - Pages 5

Tokugawa Ieyasu: A Shogun In Ancient Japan

commanders were needed during feudal times. A shogun was known as the commander-in-chief of the military. The shogun was generally the ruler of the country at the time. Tokugawa Ieyasu was one of the most well known and powerful shoguns during his time. He brought great success to Japan during his rule. Tokugawa was born in 1542 and was a natural leader. He was born into the family of a military leader. Due to war and unrest, he was sent away as a hostage. The text explicitly stated that he…

Words 504 - Pages 3

Palo Alto Battle Analysis

The Battle of Palo Alto is easily relatable to the evolution and contribution to current military operations. Tactics, techniques, and procedures are continually transforming and adapting to reflect the present threat and the progressing levels of technological advancement. Many actions are taken to ensure a measured advantage against an adversary such as the size of the friendly force, the quality and quantity of the equipment used, and the training to correctly and efficiently implement all of…

Words 596 - Pages 3

How Did William Wallace Rise To Power

He defeated an English army along with Andrew Moray who died from injuries that he obtained at the Battle of Sterling Bridge in September 1297. This was significant to Scotland’s fight for independence as Wallace led the rebellion against Edward I of England. This victory marked great significance in Wallace’s rise to power as he was named the Guardian of Scotland the following March. In his military and social presence Wallace significantly influenced not only Scottish history and Medieval Europe…

Words 797 - Pages 4

The Power of The Art of War in Busniess Essay

The Art of War in Busniess SunTzu, also called Sun Wu, who is the author of The Art of War, was a well-known military strategist and tactician during the Spring and Autumn period (722-481 BC). He is considered as the “ Master of War of the East” in today because the book he had written is the earliest military work in the world, and the theories from the book have been widely used in military for several thousand years. There are 13 chapters in the book and each one has included and dedicated to one…

Words 1168 - Pages 5

Joshua Chamberlin Outline

hero in the eyes of Maine’s people and beyond. He served four terms as the governor of Maine in Augusta. He was also a volunteer in the civil war, including six other battles that he participated in throughout his career as a soldier. Joshua Chamberlain however, did not receive military training despite his brief time at a military school located in Ellsworth, Maine. Joshua did however, desire to serve his own country of the United States of America. Joshua was also a graduate of Bowdoin College…

Words 1150 - Pages 5

Summary: The Rape Of Nanking

entering World War II, the military might of the island nation had been involved in previous battles with its fellow neighbor China, conquering land and taking valuable resources. On September 18, 1931, Japan blew up a Railroad in northeastern China. Labeling it as a sabotage by Chinese forces, Japan invades Manchuria and military occupation of the region is complete within six months. During the Marco Polo Bridge Incident on July, 1937, Japan on the guise of a military exercise launch an assault…

Words 345 - Pages 2