Mind and Strong Ai Essay

Submitted By eg2017
Words: 982
Pages: 4
Open Document
Thought is a Tool a Mind is a Being
In John Searle’s article, Minds, Brains, and Computers, he argues against the notion of strong AI; which states that an appropriately programmed computer is equivalent to a human mind, and has similar cognitive states (Searle, 349). Based on Searle’s definition of Strong AI, I will argue that a computer is not equivalent to a human mind because it does not apply meaning to the information it processes.
Many critics of Searle state that computers have the capacity to simulate the human ability to understand stories. CITATION RCS77 \l 1033 (Schank) One critic in particular named R.P. Schank, writes an argument in favor of this notion presented as two premises. “(1) […] The machine can literally be said to understand the story and provide answers to the questions. (2) What the machine and its program do explains the human ability to understand the story and answer questions about it (Searle, 350).” In order to disprove this argument Searle demonstrates an analogy that simulates a computer program. The analogy involves a monolingual English speaker locked in a room with instructions on how to manipulate Chinese symbols. The English speaker is ultimately able to answer questions that a native Chinese speaker would be able to answer. However, the English speaker does not apply the same meaning to the Chinese symbols the way that a native speaker would when answering the questions. This analogy is meant to display the difference between a computer and a human mind in reference to intentionality; which entails the ability to apply meaning.
Machines do not truly grasp the meaning of their actions when instantiating programs. In contrast, a human mind applies meaning to every action that it performs.
Those in favor of strong AI claim that there is no difference between the instantiation of a program and the application of meaning when answering questions, either from a human or a machine. “One of the claims made by the supporters of strong AI is that when I understand a story in English, what I am doing is exactly the same –or perhaps more of the same—as what I was doing in manipulating the Chinese symbols (Searle, 351).” In the quote Searle is demonstrating the views of his critiques. However, it is incorrect to assume that instantiation and the application of meaning are one in the same when answering questions. Searle argues against this idea in favor of strong AI. “ (1) […] It seems quite obvious to me in the example that I do not understand a word of Chinese stories… the computer has nothing more than I have in the case where I understand nothing. (2) […] We can see that the computer and its program do not provide sufficient conditions of understanding since the computer and program are functioning, and there is no understanding (Searle, 351).” Searle demonstrates in this counterargument that it is erroneous to assume that the English speaker in his analogy ties meaning to the answers he/she outputs. He then delves into the conditions of sufficiency; the computer (English speaker) has a working system to output answers, but lacks the sufficient requirements for the application of intentionality (meaning). Computer systems have the ability to process information (think) just like Biological systems (human mind), just not the ability to have intentionality to their programs (thoughts). Searle’s argument against Strong AI might hold. However, his premise concerning human intentionality verses machine intentionality provides a debate for the meaning and source of Searle’s definition of intentionality. Searle is vague on his definition of intentionality. Searle alludes to the idea that the definition of intentionality is to add meaning. However, I could argue that he’s too vague with this concept and state that computers do have intentionality (meaning) for their programs and can add meaning to their outputs. What distinctly separates the human ability to add meaning and the
Show More

Related Documents: Mind and Strong Ai Essay

Dualism Vs. Functionalism: The Mind-Body Problem

The Mind-Body Problem The mind–body problem is the problem of explaining how nonphysical mental states (like beliefs, feelings, and thinking) are related to the physical states of the human body. Substance dualism and functionalism are just two out of the many theories that exist in hopes of answering this question. In this essay, I will discuss the details of both substance dualism and functionalism, and their arguments as answers for the mind-body problem. I will also look at arguments against…

Words 1059 - Pages 5

Truenorth: A Theoretical Analysis

pursuing and consuming artificial intelligence, commonly referred to as AI technology. These and other popular depictions of artificial intelligence as evil overlords exemplify how AI arouses strong reactions. Such intense emotions result in unwarranted apprehension towards all technology associated with AI, including neuromorphic technologies, machines whose form, function, and architecture are designed with the mammalian brain in mind. One manifestation of this technology is the neuromorphic computer…

Words 1351 - Pages 6

Philosophy: Artificial Intelligence and Turing Test Essay

From Machine to Man Just as people of the past thought it was impossible to build a machine to take them to the moon, so do we think that we cannot build a machine with a mind. You may have heard about the Turing Test, Strong AI Thesis, and John Searle's Chinese Room thought experiment, but what do they have in common? They all revolve around the fact that one day it will be entirely possible for computers to have a greater self-understanding than we do as humans. Now, I don't know about you,…

Words 896 - Pages 4

Artificial Intelligence Essay

don’t always have to understand the language. Just like in science there are three separate categories this research is put in to. First there is strong artificial intelligence, then simplified artificial intelligence and also cognitive simulation. All the above have different jobs they must follow. The one used the most highly is strong AI. Strong AI aims to create a machine that has the ability to in distinguish that between human…

Words 2143 - Pages 9

Psy/1205-01 Emotional Intelligence

Written Assignment – Unit 7 PSYC 1205-01: Emotional Intelligence. University of the People Professor Tiffani Cofield. 28, May 2024. SWOT Analysis: Strengths What do you do well? What unique resources can you draw on? What do others see as your strengths? Weaknesses: What could you improve? Where do you have fewer resources than others? What are others likely to see as weaknesses? I am taking a bachelor's degree in my profession, which will give me a benefit in the labor market; I think it…

Words 1238 - Pages 5

Destination Image In Tourism

2009: 716). According to Mona Bouzari (2012:18), citing O'Neill & Jasper (1992) which states that afective image (AI) is a component that is associated with emotional response of visitors on a destination. In particular, as suggested Gartner (1993) in Mona Bouzari (2012:18), that the image can be considered as an effective tool to be applied in some activities such…

Words 757 - Pages 4

Essay About AI

People should be concerned with those potential dangers which new technology could bring to us. For example, the artificial intelligence(AI), it is the demon in many science fiction films. It’s also the most brilliant technology which scientists study on it for many years. The fear for AI even happens on people who knows technology the most. Recently, Elon Musk, the founder of Space­X and Tesla, described AI as “The biggest existential threat.” He said, “I think we should be very careful about artificial intelligence…

Words 1899 - Pages 8

John R. Searle's Minds

Searle in Minds, Brains, and Programs is weather or not a machine could think? According to the positions in favor of Strong Artificial Intelligence (Strong AI) as presented, “the computer is not merely a tool in the study of the minds; rather, the appropriately programmed computer really is a mind, in the sense that computers given the right programs can be literally said to understand and have other cognitive states” (Searle 417). The position for Strong AI is that computer systems…

Words 1625 - Pages 7

Essay on Ai Weiwei & Marcel Duchamp - Debate Within the Art World

materials available to them play a significant role in the creation of their artworks. However, an artist’s intentions can be misinterpreted or disregarded by their audience, often sparking fervent discussion within the art world. Through the artists Ai Weiwei and Marcel Duchamp, we can clearly see how personal reactions to an environment shape the intent of artworks. Additionally, from their audiences’…

Words 2985 - Pages 12

Accounting Information Systems Test Bank 10th Edition Essay

b) interested outsiders. c) competitors. d) the government. 26. The primary objective of accounting is to a) implement strong internal controls. b) provide useful information to decision makers. c) prepare financial statements. d) ensure the profitability of an organization. 27. The Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB), in its Statement of Financial Accounting…

Words 41103 - Pages 165