Philip Malloy started to hum the National Anthem, Miss Narwin politely asked him to stop but he wouldn’t. She asked again but he wouldn’t stop. He was sent to the principal's office not for singing but for being disrespectful, Philip Malloy accused Miss Narwin for being unpatriotic but this was not the case at all. He was suspended. Miss Narwin objected to him getting suspended, objected strongly. In fact, Miss Narwin was blamed for his suspension. It seems the whole story has gotten