Essay about Moby Dick

Submitted By JamesWiedeman
Words: 815
Pages: 4
Open Document
James Wiedeman
Prof Rock Neelly
ENG 251 American Lit.
December 8, 2014

Moby Dick Movie Review

I'm going to go out on a limb and say Moby Dick doesn't lend itself to film and TV adaptations. The tale is dramatic, it's action-packed, it's visual and it's exciting, but there's an awful lot in the original text that you have to leave out in order to film it coherently. Melville's book is encyclopedic. It tells you a lot about whales and whaling; the motivations of the whalers, the camaraderie on board, the mechanics of capturing and dissecting the largest animal in the ocean and extracting the useful stuff that keeps America burning. This adaptation (and probably ANY adaptation) cuts to the chase, omitting these complex descriptions of whaling life in favor of characters and action, the meat and potatoes of Hollywood filmmaking. In doing so, it loses something of the quality of the story. It also loses the narrator: on TV, Ishmael, a witty and endearing narrator, becomes a one-dimensional protagonist, totally overshadowed by Ahab.

This is Ahab's film. William Hurt dominates every scene he appears in, and he appears in most of them. I'm convinced he's pulling out all the stops, aiming for an Emmy. I'm not sure how else to explain the hammy overacting, the grizzly beard, the cheesy dialogue delivered in a carefully cultivated "old salt" accent. Hurt thinks he's playing Hamlet, and he wants Ahab's descent into madness to be central to the story.

Ahab is typically dark, cursed, scarred, traumatized, intimidating and vengeful. Hurt's Ahab is just plain crazy. He jokes around with his men, delivers many of his most serious lines while grinning through his beard and squinting his eyes. On board the Pequod, he's like everybody's affectionate but slightly volatile Grandpa, not averse to a hug or a bit of laugh over a stein of grog. He says too much, and much of it is hard to understand, delivered in a sing-song cadence with emphasis in unusual places. Oscillating between booming vocal projection of Shakespearean proportions and just plain talking to himself, and introspective mumbling in which he appears to be talking to himself, Hurt seems to be performing for his own benefit rather than for an audience. This is an attempt to indicate Ahab's madness in a way nobody else has done before, but it alienates the audience as well as his fellow actors, and it's just not good acting. He's a pirate caricature whose attempts at pathos are unpersuasive. I prefer Gregory Peck's intense, brooding Ahab. A good Ahab should indicate more than he actually says, a dark exterior concealing untold depths of turmoil and mystery - like the sea! Argh!

Ethan Hawke is a solid Starbuck, and a very human foil to Hurt's gruff, squinty captain. He's emotional, penetrative, and seriously worried about the fate of the ship. More than anyone else he embodies the atmosphere of impending doom that plagues the voyage, and his sense of mortality is a visibly heavy burden. When Starbuck says that what he wants most from the journey is "to see Nantucket again", you believe him. He's a homesick sailor. At that point, everything's
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Moby Dick

Moby Dick Essay

Moby dick Harpooneers[edit] Queequeg Main article: Queequeg The harpooneers of the Pequod are all non-Christians from various parts of the world. Each serves on a mate's boat. Queequeg hails from the fictional island of Rokovoko in the South Seas, inhabited by a cannibal tribe, and is the son of the chief of his tribe. Since leaving the island, he has become extremely skilled with the harpoon. He befriends Ishmael early in the novel, when they meet before leaving for Nantucket…

Words 8134 - Pages 33

Moby Dick Essay

Moby-Dick The definition of madness is “mental delusion or the eccentric behavior arising from it.” In Herman Melville’s novel, Moby Dick, the character Captain Ahab perfectly suits the definition of madness. After losing his leg to the great, white whale, Moby Dick, Ahab developed a potent desire to seek revenge and kill the whale for taking not only his leg, but his dignity and human rights. Ahab believes the whale is a manifestation of all that is malicious in world and obsesses over the thought…

Words 901 - Pages 4

Ishmael In Moby Dick

The story Moby Dick, by Herman Melville, tells the story of a “simple sailor” who goes to the ocean for money, exercise, and to catch the big white whale. Although Herman Melville describes Ishmael as a “simple sailor”, Ishmael is quite the opposite. In the first chapter Ishmael shows the reader that he is anything but simple. It can be inferred from his knowledge of history, religion, and his diction, that Ishmael is more than simple. If Ishmael were truly simple, then he would not imagine the…

Words 548 - Pages 3

Moby Dick Letter Essay

Moby Dick Letter Dear Captain Ahab, There have been rumors going around the ship that we are continuing to look for the Great White Whale, Moby Dick. You are respected greatly but this conflict is starting to get out of hand. We must discontinue our search and go back to land because you are starting to become obsessed with this hunt and that will lead to chaos, it is getting too dangerous for the crew, and you are doing this more for vengeance than for the job. To begin with, you were fine…

Words 641 - Pages 3

Moby Dick Rhetorical Analysis

repeats throughout Moby Dick. I focus on alliteration at the beginning, stating things like “groggy groan” and “frigid floor” to parallel Melville’s alliteration in description. I also inserted a few longer sentences (50+ words) in order to imitate those that are seen in Chapter 41 and 42 in Moby Dick, where Ishmael is describing the White Whale. (My sentence “As I walked across the frigid floors…” compared to Melville’s “Aside from those more obvious considerations touching Moby Dick…” In Chapter 42)…

Words 224 - Pages 1

Moby Dick Ahab's Actions

Moby Dick is a story about a dangerous journey to catch and kill a whale. The protagonist Ahab pursue's this whale solely based on his vengeance. With this goal of capturing said whale Ahab and his crew go on the trip to find it. Ahab is desperate, his passion turned into an unhealthy obsession where his unethical decision making, contorted values, and mistaken symbolism of the whale lead him to his death. Moby Dick was written in 1851 by Herman Melville. Melville was a writer of novels and poetry…

Words 921 - Pages 4

Moby Dick Research Paper

The Epic is a genre that spans across time and culture. A few titles include from Dante’s Divine Comedy, to The Lord of the Rings, to The Epic of Sundiata . The influence of the Epic was intended as Melville wrote Moby Dick. Melville uses several choice elements of an Epic story to create a new American form of it to suit his time and his viewpoints. Although there are some variations among readers and critics on what defines a story as an “Epic” story, there is a general agreement on certain literary…

Words 1660 - Pages 7

Essay on moby dick analysis

Moby Dick Book Review The novel, Moby-Dick, can teach you many things if you can remain focused long enough. However, the most prominent lesson that can be learned from the work is not that complicated and rather apparent. This lesson can be summed up in one sentence; don’t become to focused and obsessed with one goal to the point that you exclude the more important things in life. This lesson is represented with Ahab’s peculiar obsession with hunting and killing a whale. By setting this…

Words 342 - Pages 2

Moby Dick And Hawthorne Analysis

Nathaniel Hawthorne and Herman Melville to try and grasp the full meaning of our meaning, the gravity behind humanity, and the ineffable struggle to comprehend the significance of society and ourselves. Both Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter and Melville's Moby Dick attempt to solve this enigma of life and civilization, looking into the hearts and experiences of those who inhabit it; either aboard an eccentric whaling ship or on the outskirts of 18th century Boston. The two authors present in their works a means…

Words 2019 - Pages 9

Moby-Dick by Herman Melville Essay

men from many different countries and races. Soon the ship is in warmer waters, and Ahab makes his first appearance on deck, balancing gingerly on his false leg, which is made from a sperm whale’s jaw. He announces his desire to pursue and kill Moby Dick, the legendary great white whale who took his leg, because he sees this whale as the embodiment of evil. Ahab nails a gold doubloon to the mast and declares that it will be the prize for the first man to sight the whale. As the Pequod sails toward…

Words 1071 - Pages 5