Modest Proposal paper

Submitted By Samantha-Hirte
Words: 1096
Pages: 5
Open Document
Samantha Hirte
Mark Tabone
English 355
11 June 2015
Rhetorical Analysis: A Modest Proposal
In the seventeenth century, people made habit of distributing political pamphlets in Ireland to promote intellectual ideas. Many people threw these pamphlets away and did not pay attention to them. In 1729 Jonathan Swift, author of “A Modest Proposal,” devises this proposal to show how bad and backwards the social class and general state Ireland was in. His proposal was that the infants of the desolate and poor should “contribute to the feeding, and partly to the clothing, of many thousands” in order to improve the standard of living and economy in Ireland (Swift).
Jonathan Swift’s reasoning behind this proposal is that many women were having children that they were unable to care for. He says that this proposal would make the infants, “beneficial to the public” (Swift). This proposal also addresses the horrible conditions in which the people were living in at the time. Swift blames the politicians for the deplorable conditions due to the lack of apathy presented in the decision making process, in fixing the conditions. In “A Modest Proposal”, Swift uses rhetorical exaggeration, sarcasm, and insincerity to express his aggravation with papists, politicians, and the poverty stricken citizens of Ireland at the time. In order to make his argument more effective, and to get his message across, Swift uses the rhetorical devices of logos and ethos.
Jonathan Swift employs the use of logos to help him throughout his proposal. In The History and Theory of Rhetoric, logos is defined as an account, or a clear and logical explanation, or an argument. Swift makes a very logical and persuasive argument that the Irish should eat their children. Swift makes a case that by feeding on the infants of the poor after they reach one year of age, the country would be solving several major issues the country is facing. By eating the babies they can reduce the number of children that the poor people have to support, the men would not beat their pregnant wives because the children they are carrying are valuable like a foal or calf, and by selling the infants as food the economy will be improved. Swift points out that an infant can be fed from its mother’s breast for up to a year after being born, with little or no additional nutritional support. Since theses infants need no additional nutrients other than their mother’s milk, it does not cost anything to feed them and support them for a full year. During this one year period the infants have time to grow and become fat, making them more delicious to eat. After this year, the families can sell the babies. They can then use that money to feed their other, older, children. He implies that babies will become a delicacy and that chefs will pay good money for a fat child. With fewer mouths to feed, the country will not suffer as much from poverty, and those who are poor will have a new source of income. Swift makes this ridiculously unethical argument to eat babies and yet makes it seem like a very logical thing to do. By eating these children, there will be a decrease in population, the economy will be stimulated, and overall quality of life will be improved.
In Rhetoric, by Aristotle, it states that, “persuasion can come through the hearers, when the speech stirs their emotions” (Aristotle 8). The rhetorical device that plays upon emotions in an argument or speech is called ethos. The usage of ethos appears in this proposal, appealing to two different emotions. One way in which ethos is used is by instilling a sense of pride in the countrymen of Ireland. Swift uses the proposal to anger and rally the people of Ireland into being patriotic and defending their country. Swift has seemingly strong views when it comes to the English and the Papists. He states that if an infant were to make it through childhood that they would leave Ireland to fight for Spain or sell themselves to Barbados as indentured servants,
Show More

Related Documents: Modest Proposal paper

Essay on Jonathan Swift and Swift

Binta Bojang Sarah Setnes Dale Comp. II-M February 27, 2015 Analysis of “A Modest Proposal” by Jonathan Swift In Jonathan Swift’s “A Modest Proposal”, he discusses a solution for the problem of overpopulation in Ireland. At the time “A Modest Proposal” was introduced, babies were being produced at an exponential rate which negatively impacted Ireland’s economy. Ireland, because of the country being crowded, suffered tremendous economic problems and quickly went into debt. Swift proposed that everyone…

Words 1004 - Pages 5

Essay Who Am I

Response Paper Back in the 1700s and 1800s there was a satirical based newspaper that often poked fun at the issues such as the government and other countries. According to an article written by Amy Forbes entitled, The Lithographic Conspiracy: How Satire Framed Liberal Political, the paper’s founder and editor was arrested around nine times. So this just illustrates how satirical use was often frowned upon. Satire is a strong and forceful way to get a point across not only to a few but to the…

Words 1072 - Pages 5

Essay on Scarf: Immigration and Law

Contemporary Proposal A seemingly controversial topic over the course of American history has been immigration and the formation of the laws for the issue. Throughout our country’s history, if one wasn’t an American born citizen, they were then considered an immigrant. Over the years certain measures or laws were made to restrict or reduce the number of immigrants allowed into the Continental U.S.A. Only until Ellis Island open in 1892 were immigrants allowed to flow into America and granted…

Words 1267 - Pages 6

How Is Diction Used In A Modest Proposal

In a time of famine and disparity, Jonathan Swift writes A Modest Proposal, stating that the only way to solve the problems at hand was by eating babies of the poor. Swift, however doesn’t mean this, instead this entire proposal was a flare gun to draw attention to the Irish need for a better solution. In his essay, Swift uses language such as satire, diction and logos to develop his position that Ireland is in desperate need of economic reform. Mainly using satire and diction to grab the reader's…

Words 546 - Pages 3

Martin Luther's Ninety-Five Theses Summary

On October 31, 1517, so the story goes, a modest priest named Martin Luther nailed a bit of paper to the entryway of the Castle Church in the college town of Wittenberg. The thoughts contained in these Ninety-five Theses, which intensely tested the Catholic Church, spread like out of control fire. Inside two months, they were known all finished Germany. So effective were Martin Luther's broadsides against ecclesiastical expert that they spellbound a mainland and tore separated the plain establishment…

Words 897 - Pages 4

Literature and Journalism Essay

interpreted in a number of different ways. This is because when different readers read a text, their understanding is not the same and sometimes the writer’s intention may be missed. For instance, in Jonathan Swift’s essay: A Modest Proposal, the writer, did not intend his proposal of rearing babies for food to be taken literally. Some of his readers were very outraged at the idea of infanticide and cannibalism. Literature as a body consists of three main components (literary history): 1) A body of…

Words 1988 - Pages 8

Critical Thinking and Moodle Essays

As this is a condensed course, please be prepared for an average of ten hours per week of reading/writing/posting. The final paper involves a peer-edit session; failure to participate in this session will result in a 25% loss on the paper’s grade. Late assignments will be docked 25% and will not be accepted more than one week after the due date. Students may submit late papers without penalty if they can provide appropriate documentation for situations of emergency (such as illness or a death in the…

Words 1226 - Pages 5

Essay on The Paradox of the Affordable Care Act

The Paradox in the Affordable Care Act Submitted By: Vodney Wynn vewynn@aol.com October 12, 2014 PA582_CourseProject Table of Contents Introduction…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………3 The History of Healthcare Reform……………………………………………………………………………..…4 The Problem with the ACA……………………………………………………………………………………………6 The Current Policy………………………………………………………………………………………………………..8 Policy Alternatives………………………………………………………………………………………………………10 Evaluation Criteria………………………………………………………………………………………………………10…

Words 4244 - Pages 17

Woodrow Wilson Research Paper

repeal previous acts that he thought hurt the county like exempting American coastal shipping from tolls (APNotes). Following World War I, Woodrow Wilson wanted to establish a basis for a lasting peace following the allies’ victory. He created a proposal called the Fourteen Points which declared that World War I was being fought for a moral cause and calling for peace in Europe. Wilson was the first national leader to address the world through radio transmission. He hoped to persuade the governments…

Words 1545 - Pages 7

New Heritage Doll Company: Capital Budgeting Essay

New Heritage Doll Company: Capital Budgeting In mid-September of 2010/ Emily Harris, vice president of New Heritage Doll Company's production division, was weighing project proposals for the company's upcoming capital budgeting meetings in October. Two proposals stood out based on their potential to strengthen the division's innovative product lines and drive future growth. However, due to constraints on financial and managerial resources, Harris knew it was possible that the firm's capital budgeting…

Words 3242 - Pages 13