Movie Review: The Influence Of The Clean Air Act

Submitted By shayla106
Words: 580
Pages: 3
Open Document
There are a few scientific errors that are important in the film. At one point Gore claims that you can see the aerosol concentrations in Antarctic ice cores change "in just two years", due to the U.S. Clean Air Act. You can't see dust and aerosols at all in Antarctic cores -- not with the naked eye -- and I'm skeptical you can definitively point to the influence of the Clean Air Act. I was left wondering whether Gore got this notion, and I hope he'll correct it in future versions of his slideshow. Another complaint is the juxtaposition of an image relating to CO2 emissions and an image illustrating invasive plant species. This is misleading; the problem of invasive species is predominantly due to land use change and importation, not to "global warming". Still, these are rather minor errors. It is true that the effect of reduced leaded gasoline use in the U.S. does clearly show up in Greenland ice cores; and it is also certainly true that climate change could exacerbate the problem of invasive species.
Several of my colleagues complained that a more significant error is Gore's use of the long ice core records of CO2 and temperature (from oxygen isotope measurements) in Antarctic ice cores to illustrate the correlation between the two. The complaint is that the correlation is somewhat misleading, because a number of other climate forcings besides CO2 contribute to the change in Antarctic temperature between glacial and interglacial climate. Simply extrapolating this correlation forward in time puts the temperature in 2100 A.D. somewhere upwards of 10 C warmer than present -- rather at the extreme end of the vast majority of projections (as we have discussed here). However, I don't really agree with my colleagues' criticism on this point. Gore is careful not to state what the temperature/CO2 scaling is. He is making a qualitative point, which is entirely accurate. The fact is that it would be difficult or impossible to explain past changes in temperature during the ice age cycles without CO2 changes (as we have discussed here). In that sense, the ice core CO2-temperature correlation remains an appropriate demonstration of the influence of CO2 on climate.

For the most part, I think Gore gets the science right, just as he did in Earth in the Balance. The small errors don't detract from
Show More

Related Documents: Movie Review: The Influence Of The Clean Air Act

Antarctic Circumpolar Current Controversy

tectonic events that led to the establishment of the modern Antarctic Circumpolar Current (ACC) (20 marks, max. 200 words). The Antarctic Circumpolar Current (ACC) was established during the Eocene-Oligocene transition into a modern day east flowing, wind driven current, which connects all of the three major oceans (Barker & Thomas. 2004). Research suggests the development of the ACC was dependent upon the tectonic isolation of the Antarctic continent, through the divergence of the Indian-Australian…

Words 1105 - Pages 5

Summary response paper

the sediments of an Antarctic sub glacial lake for the first time” information from the British Antarctic Survey says that there may be new life forms found in extreme conditions. A group of British scientists went to Antarctica to explore the theory that life forms once existed in the dark and deep lakes hidden beneath the ice sheets in Antarctica that were buried over 100,000 years ago. The temperature at the North and South poles have both been rising. Therefore, the ice sheets are melting.…

Words 395 - Pages 2

What Effect Would Low Co2 Levels In The Atmosphere Have On The Climate

When looking at ice core samples from Antarctic, over the last 650,000 years carbon dioxide concentrations have been at their lowest when the extent of ice sheets were at their highest. This could become an ice age if the CO2 levels were low enough. 3. A portion of all solar radiation (heat from the sun) is absorbed by the earth and a portion is reflected back out into space. The amount of solar radiation that a material reflects back out to space is called the albedo. Do sea-ice and continental…

Words 213 - Pages 1

Earth: Earth and Magnetic Field Essay

of continents and islands which together have many lakes and other sources of water that contribute to the hydrosphere. Earth's poles are mostly covered with ice that is the solid ice of the Antarctic ice sheet and the sea ice that is the polar ice packs. The planet's interior remains active, with a solid iron inner core, a liquid outer core that generates the magnetic field, and a thick layer of relatively solid mantle. Earth gravitationally interacts with other objects in space, especially the…

Words 439 - Pages 2

Essay on Climate Change: Fact or Fiction?

Climate Change: Fact or Fiction? Martin Ray Central Carolina Technical College December 1 2013 Abstract Climate Change is a term often used in place of the term “Global Warming”. This is the first place the general population errs. Climate change refers to a change in the earth’s natural state; it includes global warming, but also includes, global cooling, the changes in precipitation, changes in the atmosphere, land masses and oceans and also changes in storm frequency and…

Words 2958 - Pages 12

Glacial Retreat Essay

retreat, greenhouse gasses, we hear this constantly in the media, in conversation but do people actually realize what is going on. The retreat of the glaciers affects the availability of fresh water for irrigation, animals and plants depend on the ice melting, and in the long term the level of the oceans will be affected as well. The Himalayas, the southern Andes as well as Mount Kilimanjaro are showing some of the largest proportionate glacial losses. The fact that the glaciers are melting is not…

Words 525 - Pages 3

Emperor Penguin Research Paper

heat loss with an under layer of softer feathers called woolly down. When there are cold winds the penguins can puff out their feathers trapping some air that they warm up keeping them more insulated. When being in a harsh environment such as the Antarctic animals need to be warm-blooded to be operational, the emperor penguin has a layer of fat under their feathers. A penguin can have nearly a third of its body weight as fat this…

Words 658 - Pages 3

FINAL ESSAY

environment in which the individual has grown up in, social, political and environmental factors all contribute to ones attitudes and values, by the end of this report I shall identify why each stakeholder holds the attitude and value that they have. Values Core beliefs that guide and motivate attitudes and actions ethics.org/definitions Attitudes Feelings towards certain idea or issues UNESCO, 2010 Stakeholder a stakeholder as any group or individual who can be affected by the achievement of organisations…

Words 2451 - Pages 10

The Global Warming Controversy Essay

and 1970's global warming became a concern (Bilger 15). In the early 1970's, the Earth had become unusually cool in temperature. Scientists believed that we were entering into another ice age. They believed that air pollution was blocking the sunlight and cooling the Earth. Nigel Calder said, "The threat of a New Ice Age must now stand alongside nuclear war as a likely source of wholesale death and misery for mankind" (Horner 55). By the 1980's, this theory had been proven false, and many people thought…

Words 1825 - Pages 8

Essay about Task2 The Arctic Ice Caps

The Arctic Ice Caps What are the Arctic Ice Caps? • The Polar Cap is the frozen waters of the Arctic Ocean, and the permantently frozen land masses located north of the boundary known as the Arctic Circle. A significant percentage of the Arctic Ocean is frozen year round, and are referred to as the Arctic Ice Cap. • The Arctic Circle is currently located at approximately 66 degrees latitude north of the Equator. However, this location is based on the tilt of the Earth, and can vary up to 2 degrees…

Words 1698 - Pages 7