My Brother Sam Is Dead

Words: 1489
Pages: 6
Open Document
The novel My Brother Sam is Dead by James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier, and the short story “The Sniper” by Liam O’Flaherty, share similar themes. My Brother Sam is Dead shows the eldest son, Sam Meeker, going out to fight in the Revolutionary War, with the Patriots side however, the father, Eliphalet Meeker, is with the other side, the Loyalist, causing the youngest son, Tim Meeker having trouble which side to pick which is questioned throughout the novel. “The Sniper” takes place in Dublin, Ireland between a sniper with the Republican and another sniper with the Free Staters, trying to get the perfect shot to kill the other. After the Republican Sniper kills the Free Staters Sniper by tricking him, he flips over the body that he …show more content…
In the text, it states, “The sniper looked at his enemy falling and he shuddered. The lust of battle died in him. He became bitten by remorse. The sweat stood out on his forehead. Weakened by his wound and the long summer day of fasting and watching on the roof, he revolted from the sight of the shattered mass of his dead enemy. His teeth chattered, he began to gibber to himself, cursing the war, cursing himself, cursing everybody”(227). War not only changes people but also had an overpowers people’s mind making them think that by being in war it'll give them victory and pride, but deep down inside them they don’t want to do and they regret killing others. Consequently, it makes them have this remorse inside of them but they ignore that feeling and continue to kill others in war which then shows how war changes people. Additionally, this short story shows theme of war being a disadvantage on people and families because it makes people be more loyal to war than their actual family and think of war before their family. This is shown when it states, “He was eating a sandwich hungrily. He had eaten nothing since morning… Then the sniper turned over the dead body and looked into his brother's face.”(225-228). The Republican sniper was sitting on top of the …show more content…
The text show that war only tears families apart and it also changes people turning them into beast. Moreover, the soldiers became more devoted to war rather than their own family which shows that war changes people into doing things that don’t actually want to do. Lastly, the themes show that people are willing to do anything just so they can have the victory and glory of war even if that means that means losing their family bond. These two text are important for people my age to read because it shows the reality of war and what really happens during war rather than what we actually think which is people fight and in the end there's a winner and we don't focus on the negative aspect of it. Also, it's important because people my age don’t really interest in war and don’t really look into, so reading these two texts show what war really is which informs us and shows the actuality of war. Students like me can learn from these two text is that war is a very serious and dangerous thing, especially because it can destroy a person or even a family which makes war very poisonous. Furthermore, we can learn is that no matter what war will still occur because people will continue to get in fights and it's inevitable but we can learn that fighting is not a good way to answer it and instead we should show love and sympathy to others and not answer issues and problems through violence. Lastly, we can
Show More

Related Documents: My Brother Sam Is Dead

Summary Of My Brother Sam Is Dead

I am writing about the historical fiction novel “My Brother Sam Is Dead”. This is a book written by James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier and was published on the first of January 1974. The book takes place in Redding, Connecticut during the Revolutionary War and is told from the point of view of Tim Meeker. The novel “My Brother Sam Is Dead” takes place in Redding, Connecticut while the revolutionary war is happening. Redding, Connecticut is a rural part of the state. The story is told…

Words 336 - Pages 2

My Brother Sam Is Dead Essay

side to be on, and they are caught right in the middle of it. In the book , My brother Sam is Dead, The Meekers (in the story) are an average household family living in the year of 1775. The Meekers have two boys Sam and Tim, and their parents own a tavern in the town of Redding. The Independents war comes along and brother Sam wants to join the war. Sam does so and becomes a patriot, father does not like the idea of that. Sam is just a little kid and he does no know the brutalities of war. I also think…

Words 599 - Pages 3

My Brother Sam Is Dead Themes

My Brother Sam is Dead; Theme In the book My Brother Sam is Dead, by James and Christopher Collier, the Meeker family is broken apart due to the Revolutionary War. Tim’s brother was in that war, but on the Patriots side, in which father disapproved of. In this novel many other tragedies happen, such as a British raid and father dying. One of the major themes of My Brother Sam is Dead would have to be that not everything goes your way and that life is just unfair. In My Brother Sam is Dead father…

Words 563 - Pages 3

My Brother Sam Is Dead Summary

Tim Meeker, the narrator of My Brother Sam is Dead, is the son of a loyalist, yet the brother of a patriot, Sam Meeker. His father is a war veteran and wants to stop Sam from going to war, but Sam wants to enlist and steal Brown Bess. In Chapter II of the book Tim and his father are at their local church, an Anglican church, near the field where the trainband practiced. Father asked Tim where Sam is going and he replies and says he is going “Up to Wethersfield and is going to march up with people…

Words 214 - Pages 1

My Brother Sam Is Dead Quotes

My Brother Sam is Dead In war, there is no such thing as peace. War is a terrible thing to resort too. When there are many options besides war. Throughout the book there are many pieces of evidence that show the negatives associated with war. In the book Tim is the main character. He shows the reader through his thoughts that war is a horrendous thing. In the book My Brother Sam Is Dead, authors James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier, argue that war is a futile and unnecessary event.…

Words 917 - Pages 4

My Brother Sam Is Dead Summary

Brothers James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier published My Brother Sam Is Dead in 1974. They introduced us to Sam and his brother Tim along with the entire Meeker family. The book takes place starting in 1775 during the time period of the start of the American Revolution. Throughout the tour, many locations will be mentioned and given visualization to display the information from the book and city provided. The introductory of the book starts with Sam coming home and explaining that they…

Words 1128 - Pages 5

My Brother Sam Is Dead Quotes

to achieve your goal. Violence is never the answer. “War turns men into beasts.” My Brother Sam is Dead is a book written by Collier and Collier in which they explain the bad things occuring during war. So many thing can happen during a war, such as tearing families apart. They also argue against war through the clash of generations. The book also shows the principles versus the reality of war. In My Brother Sam is Dead, althought both sides of war are shown, Collier and Collier ultimately argue that…

Words 687 - Pages 3

My Brother Sam Is Dead Analysis

made a story for students to visualize how the world was like. In the story My Brother Sam is Dead he talks about Tim how his brother is a patriot and his father is a loyalist. Tim wants to find out if it's a patriot or loyalist but his father died by a British ship and his brother died by patriots so that makes tim confused Tim and Sam are both brothers that love each other very much but sam went to college and left sam them after join the war and became patriot. “I wanted to come over and see…

Words 408 - Pages 2

My Brother Sam Is Dead Essay

My Brother Sam is Dead is one of the most intellectually stimulating novels explaining the operose life of the Revolutionary War. The Collier brothers are the ingenius authors of this book. The story revolves around Tim and Sam Meeker, as well as their family and close friends. During 1775, the year the story is staged in, Sam has joined the continental army which has caused much grief to his family and friends. This is because his father is a Loyalist and they have many disputes about their beliefs…

Words 669 - Pages 3

Analysis Of The Book 'My Brother Sam Is Dead'

I heard shouting when I woke up. My brother sam is dead is a book about a family in the revolutionary war. The family lives in a small tory town named redding. The family faces several internal conflicts about what side of the war is right. They go through many obstacles to overcome this. How can Tim choose when he had to go against his own father or his brother who he has admired for so long. My brother sam is dead teaches us how ordinary families were affected during the revolutionary war.…

Words 363 - Pages 2