Narrative And Resistance Essay

Submitted By phillip45
Words: 4596
Pages: 19
Open Document
The Role of Narrative in Understanding Organizational Resistance to Change:
A Social Construction Perspective
“The reason for evil in the world is that people are not able to tell their stories.”

- C.G. Jung

Social Construction Theory as presented in Peter L. Berger and Thomas Luckmann’s (1966) work The Social Construction of Reality presents a perspective on the nature of society that should be interesting to any change agent: first, that societies are continuously constructed by individuals, second, that this process occurs through individuals externalizing subjective phenomena and third, that these externalizations become objective realities - society - that then become internalized by individuals who are part of that society (Berger & Luckmann, 1966). Berger and Luckmann present a kind of feed-back loop that portrays society as something we construct as well as something that constructs us. The ramifications of such a premise for the practice of Organizational Development (OD) and change agents are potentially far reaching, for the perspective allows change agents to view problems within organizations as socially constructed, and therefore changeable. Berger and Luckmann’s text outlines in detail the process by which externalization of reality occurs to create an objective reality we call an ‘institution‘ and by extension a ‘society.’ By studying this process as it occurs within individuals and communities, change agents may be able to identify how problems are socially constructed within an organization, and how they might be solved. Donald L. Anderson’s text (2012), Organization Development, The Process of Leading Organizational Change examines Berger and Luckmann’s theories in a summative way, but it seemed important to study these theories in further depth in order to present a fuller understanding of the theory, since it is the backbone of this paper’s position: OD professionals, as well as their methods of diagnosis significantly participate in creating the resistance to change that OD professionals find problematic. Narrative, defined for the purpose of this essay as any spoken or written account of connected events, is a central factor to the externalization process described by Berger and Luckmann, both explicitly and implicitly. It is key to how individuals construct knowledge, how knowledge is transmitted and how habits become institutions, then societies. Narrative is crucial to how legitimacy of institutions and societies are maintained, constructed, and transmitted and is critical to how a ‘symbolic universe’ is constructed that is then internalized by members of that society. A ‘symbolic universe,’ according to Berger and Luckmann, is essentially the symbolic understanding of the world that the society proposes is true and real and that all members of that society accept and internalize as a fundamental, taken-for-granted truth about the way things are. This internalization of a ‘symbolic universe’ is the critical point at which an individual becomes a ‘member’ of a particular society. Berger and Luckmann present other factors that participate in the process of externalizing and internalizing a symbolic universe other than narrative. A focus on narrative, however is interesting for a modern investigation of Social Construction Theory because narrative has been identified by various researchers in cognitive psychology to be a key factor, if not the key factor to how individuals construct identity, both individual identity as well as social identity (Hardcastle, 2003; Herman, 2007; Neimeyer & Tscudi, 2003; Nelson, 2003). These psychologists, who are also social constructivists, believe narrative may be more central to Social Construction Theory than originally envisioned by Berger and Luckmann. This paper investigates and synthesizes various research studies in the field of OD and Cognitive Psychology to examine the degree to which change agents can investigate and change their
Show More

Related Documents: Narrative And Resistance Essay

Resistance Is Futile: A Narrative Analysis

done for fear of getting too close to deadlines. This often leads to rushing in, grammatical mistakes, spelling errors, and a flood of other thoughts clouding focus from the task at hand. Consequently, after reading an article by Jennifer Blair, "Resistance is Futile", I begin to wonder if I, and many others, do not procrastinate enough (Blair, 2008). Good time management…

Words 375 - Pages 2

Covey And Douglass

"The Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, An American Slave" (1845) and "My Bondage and My Freedom" (1855) are two narratives that detail Frederick Douglass's encounter with Edward Covey, a notorious enslaved breaker. Douglass's narrative is intense, emphasizing the physical and psychological toll Covey took on him, asserting his humanity in the face of dehumanizing oppression. "My Bondage and My Freedom" presents a more reflective account, focusing on the psychological dynamics and Douglass's…

Words 1416 - Pages 6

How Did Slaves Use Momentary Resistance

everyday hardships. Most slaves used momentary resistance which was a form of peaceful resistance, but some slaves used other slave resistance with a more clear claim to freedom like Planned personal or Institutional resistance. Momentary resistance were those that took place in the work environment. When slave masters increased work loads slaves would fake illnesses, sabotage production, slow work,or break tools. In the narrative “Slaves’ Resistance on Southern Plantations”, Carter J. Jackson told…

Words 359 - Pages 2

Resistance To African Americans Analysis

little in common, they have common themes which include resistance and creolization. The texts are significant in that they show how African Americans were able to adapt to life in America. How they were able to make the most of the cheap food that was available to them and attempt to negotiate a place for themselves and their…

Words 1827 - Pages 8

Rigoberta Menchu

a first-person narrative of Menchu's experiences, illuminating the discrimination, oppression, and abuses of human rights that indigenous groups in Guatemala have to deal with.The main themes of the book are Menchu's personal experience as a Quiché community member, her participation in the fight for indigenous rights, and her observation of the heinous acts of violence committed against her people by the Guatemalan government. Her family's participation in the peasant resistance movement, her upbringing…

Words 969 - Pages 4

Civil Disobedience In The Vietnam War

man they feel has endangered the values of our nation. People have begun to fear the creation of a new narrative in our country, one predicated on “alternative facts” and “winning” at the expense of Native tribes and the environment in his resurrection of the Keystone XL and Dakota Access Pipelines. Being necessary to the progress of our nation, Americans must not fall victim to a false narrative. In doing so, we must strive for independent thought, maintain our historical foundation, and ensure…

Words 711 - Pages 3

John Lewis Journey

the Wind by John Lewis: Book Review Walking with the Wind, by John Lewis provides poignant narratives and accounts of his life journey and involvement within the era of the Civil Rights Movement. Lewis’s memoir illustrates that achieving success demands sacrifice, and delves into the profound emotional and physical repercussions across generations while emphasizing the significance of various forms of resistance, perseverance, and steadfast moral conviction in fights for civil rights. This essay will…

Words 758 - Pages 4

One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest Comparative Essay

In the novels, “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest” by Ken Kessey, and “The Awakening” by Kate Chopin, the theme of power pervades the narratives, driving characters to confront oppressive societal forces. No matter the differing settings and characters, both “One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest” and “The Awakening” examine power dynamics, showing the struggle for self-determination against oppressive societal forces. To compare and contrast the two novels, there are a few things that will be focused on…

Words 1208 - Pages 5

Stephanie M. H. Camp's Closer To Freedom

cotton and tobacco plantations would be the primary economic resource and the resistance of the slaves to the notion of being imprisoned with a focus on the resistance of women. Stephanie M.H. Camp’s Closer to Freedom examines the numerous ways that enslaved women resisted slavery in nineteenth-century America, including truancy, illicit parties, and abolitionism. Camp does not examine every form of slave resistance but instead focuses specifically on the role of women in challenging the realm…

Words 632 - Pages 3

Anti-Mexican Discourse

the living example of the idea of meritocracy highly valued in the U.S. Beginning college two years ago, I have begun to understand the various factors that are responsible for the discriminatory violence, financial exploitation, and the acts of resistance regarding Janitors and their families. There is a vast amount of anti-Mexican discourses that portray the Mexican population…

Words 1546 - Pages 7