To Symons, Hawthorne “had the Puritan sense of it in the blood, and the power to use it artistically in the brain” in a way that is rarely attempted or achieved. He explains how Hawthorne carefully showed the thin boundary between good and evil. Symons describes in detail how the importance of “mortal law” can only be explained in the novel by breaking it. He frequently uses the term “sin” as a way of explaining reality, drawing the boundary between what he considers to be “a great reality” and “a dream”