Nature vs Nurture Essay example

Submitted By cherowil
Words: 1212
Pages: 5
Open Document
Nature versus Nurture
Dorothy Williams
Western Governor’s University

Table of Contents
Abstract
Introduction
Case Studies
Case Study Comparison
Conclusion
References
Abstract
The nature- nurture debate is a controversial topic. Studies are done to determine if genetics or environment affect an individual’s physical and behavioral traits. This paper discusses the basics of the nature-nurture controversy as well as the reasons the nature-nurture debate is so controversial. Two studies on this topic are compared and contrasted to determine if genes or personal experiences determine which influences a person’s personality traits and behaviors more.

Nature versus Nurture
Introduction
Many studies have been completed on the controversial topic of nature and nurture. The nature-nurture debate stemmed over the question of what makes a person who they are. Theorists questioned if a person’s behaviors and personality traits come from influences of their surroundings or if the person is born that way. Nature is a person’s natural qualities, referring to biological factors, or the traits that an individual inherits in their genes. Nurture refers to childhood experiences or the way an individual is raised. Nurture is personal experiences involving social and environmental factors (Risch, 2002). The nature-nurture debate is controversial because some theorists believe that a person’s personality traits and behaviors come strictly from inherited genes, while other theorists believe personality traits come only from childhood experiences or environmental influences. Many other theorists believe that both biological and environmental factors play a role (Bouchard, Lykken, McGue, Segal & Tellegen, 1990).
Case Studies Two case studies on the topic of nature versus nurture were examined to find the similarities, differences and to determine the conclusions reached in each case. In the first study, twin boys named Bruce and Brian Reimer were studied. Shortly after birth, Bruce Reimer’s penis was destroyed during circumcision. A psychologist from Johns Hopkins University became involved in the case and suggested to the boy’s parents to raise their child as a girl instead of a boy. The parents agreed and Bruce Reimer was castrated at 21 months. The boy was renamed Brenda, raised as their daughter from that point on, and never told that he was born a boy. As Brenda aged, she rejected typical girl activities, toys and clothing. Brenda imitated her father much more often than her mother. Brenda expressed multiple times that she looked like a boy and acted like a boy. Brenda and her twin brother, Brian, showed very similar personality traits and behaviors despite being raised as members of the opposite sex. Brenda was teased in school and got into numerous fights. The psychologist encouraged Brenda’s parents to have gender reassignment surgery to construct a vagina from Brenda’s damaged genitals when she was nine. Brenda objected and threatened to kill herself. Brenda continued to be in conflict with her femininity, continuing her destructive behavior and attempting suicide several times. At the age of 14, Brenda’s parents were convinced by a different psychiatrist to reveal the truth about her birth. Brenda immediately began living as a male and named herself David. David had genital reconstruction and testosterone injections to restore masculine body features. David lived the rest of his life as a male. This study evidenced a strong case for the nature theory as this child always identified with being male even though he was raised as a female. The conclusions of this study are that nature is the strongest influence, as a male child was raised as a female, but retained a strong male identity, personality traits, and behaviors (Schillo, 2011). In the second case study examined, siblings were studied to determine whether environment or genetics have the biggest influence on intellectual development. The
Show More

Related Documents: Nature vs Nurture Essay example

Nature Vs Nurture

The question of nature vs nurture in psychology is a question that humanity’s greatest minds have been debating for millennia. From Plato who believes in nature, against Aristotle who argued for nurture. To as recently as today where scientists are still trying to figure out the answer with no prevail. (Nature vs Nurture) The basic premise of this debate is whether the mind is influenced by the world around it or is already predetermined. In other words, certain people believe that the mind is a…

Words 1179 - Pages 5

Nature Vs Nurture

and what is taught to us. We are taught by our parents, by our teachers, by grandparents, by siblings, friends, ect.. but ultimately a parents wants there child to grow up knowing they taught them to do what was right and wrong. This is where Nature vs. Nurture come into play this is where we learn ones interest and abilities such as creativity, social skills, problem-solving ability, and so forth. Parents are the keys to intellectual development for almost all children in the care and education…

Words 599 - Pages 3

Nature Vs Nurture

Some say that behavior results from nature, or one’s own genes, while others say that behavior results from nurture, or the environment. People are aware that both nature and nurture influence how humans live and think but exactly how much of human traits are determined by either nature and nurture remains unknown. Scientists may seem more engaged in the nature theory because of the biology and chemistry involved. This in turn leads to further research in the nature field. On the other hand, psychologists…

Words 1001 - Pages 5

Nature vs. Nurture Essay

Nature vs Nurture: Do You Choose Your Sexuality, Or Is It Genetic? The nature vs. nurture debate is one of the most enduring in the field of psychology because of the many different topics that can be attained in this single field. Psychologist have thought and asked questions of how far are human behaviors, ideas, and feeling, innate and how far are they all learned? These issues are at the center of the ongoing nature versus nurture controversy. The French philosopher Rene Descartes suggested…

Words 1083 - Pages 5

Essay on Nature vs. Nurture

Nature vs. Nurture The dubious history of the heredity environment controversy can be easily traced as far back as the start of the present century with at least some historical evidence placing the roots of this dispute in the time of John Locke. This controversy has continued despite continual reiteration that the critical question is not how much of a trait is due to heredity and how much is due to environment, but rather how environment transact to influence development." ( Wachs ,…

Words 2492 - Pages 10

Nature Vs Nurture

In psychology, there are two main point of views when analysing the brain. The two main points are nature and nurture. Nurture is the theory that a person's behavior is determined in the womb. While, nature is the theory that your behavior is determined by your experience or environment. On May 21, 1960, Jeffrey Dahmer was born in West Allis, Wisconsin, raised by disheveled parents, Lionel and Joyce Dahmer. He was known as the Milwaukee Cannibal, an American serial killer and sex offender, who committed…

Words 264 - Pages 2

Nature Vs Nurture

do a person environment control them or is their fate destined throughout their genes? The concept of nature versus nurture is a debate on whether a person behavior is based on the environment or do genes influence a person behavior. Nature is the behavior influenced by the gene. Nurture is based on how a person was raised. A person being born good or bad is one example of nature versus nurture. In my opinion, I think a person environment cannot play a part on whether or not a person is good or…

Words 160 - Pages 1

Nature Vs Nurture Debate

Debate on the Nature Versus Nurture controversy dates back to 1869 when the phrase was first conceived by Francis Galton, a man who had wide-ranging knowledge. Galton began to investigate further on the nature versus nurture debate when his half-cousin, Charles Darwin, publicized On the Origin of Species, where Darwin first began his study on the theory of evolution. Intrigued by Darwin’s theories and ideas, Galton publicized two books exploring inheritance, and evolution of traits. Since Galton…

Words 677 - Pages 3

Mcleod Nature Vs Nurture

thought nurture is important. In the article “Nature vs Nurture in Psychology” Saul Mcleod reports that the debate of the influence between nature and nurture. Mcleod claims that some nativists believe genetic factors control our physical characteristic and behavior. And empiricists believe that human’s development and behavior influenced by environment. Also she describes that there a controversy between whether “ genius” is from nature or nurture. In brief, the author states that nature and nurture…

Words 996 - Pages 4

Nature Vs Nurture

personality? Some say that your personality and actions are based on genetics, and others say it is based on how you were raised, media, and other things in society. Nature versus nurture is a very big debate amongst scientists and people in general. Personally, I believe that both of these take part in your personality and behavior. Nature would be your genetics, and nurturing factors would be your family and how you were raised, your friends and the people that you hang out with, and the media such…

Words 1169 - Pages 5