Essay on Need Things

Submitted By jeannie2joel
Words: 2107
Pages: 9
Open Document
“Water for Elephants,” Sara Gruen’s lightweight page turner about a Depression-era traveling circus, would appear to be a vehicle ready-made for a prestigious family movie on the order of “Seabiscuit.” With its star attraction, a gentle elephant named Rosie who understands Polish, the novel belongs to the John Irving school of semi-serious whimsy with allegorical overtones.
The primary draw for Water for Elephants is the pairing of Reese Witherspoon and Robert Pattinson (ignore the ten year age gap) in a love story based on the best-selling novel by Sara Gruen. Sadly, passion and romance are two ingredients missing from this melodrama, which does an excellent job of re-creating the Depression-era circus business but is less successful in generating the needed heat between the two leads. The great intangible of chemistry isn't present, making Water for Elephants seem longer and slower than one might hope.
A love story set in a Depression-era traveling circus? Involving a handsome young veterinarian, a pretty lady who does tricks atop horses, the lady's volatile, abusive husband who's also the circus owner and ringmaster, and an elephant who understands commands in Polish? With colorful narrative assets like these, Sara Gruen's best-selling historical novel Water for Elephants has always unspooled in the mind's eye like a good old-fashioned movie. Only now, look! Up on the big screen, here's Robert Pattinson as veterinary student Jacob Jankowski, brought as if by fate into the hubbub of the Benzini Brothers traveling circus! Here's Reese Witherspoon as Marlena, the sparkling star attraction! Here's Inglourious Basterds' Christoph Waltz as Marlena's husband, August, the dangerous impresario! Here's the lovable elephant! And yet something is wrong under this big tent. Actually made to resemble a good old-fashioned, crowd-pleasing movie, this cinematicWater for Elephants droops and lumbers like Rosie the elephant herself.
It's odd, the anemia of this production, directed by Francis Lawrence (I Am Legend) from a squared-off script by screenwriter Richard LaGravanese (The Horse Whisperer). Inevitably, the movie veers from the novel in various small to medium ways, but not so much that a bookworm would complain. The heart of the story is there: how Jacob's life changes after his parents die in a car accident, how he finds his way to the Benzini Brothers, how August is even crueler to his circus animals than he is to his wife, and how the tense triangle of Jacob, Marlena, and August leads to a dramatic climax.

Waltz, in his spotlight, bites into his role with an almost manic energy that turns August into more of a cartoon villain than someone spurred to cruelty by tormenting psychological complications. (In the book, another character diagnoses August as a paranoid schizophrenic.) The ringmaster might as well be twirling a mustache or tying Marlena to a railroad tie, so exaggerated is the Evil Face Waltz puts on before August slips into one of his episodes of brutality. Then the director, not one for subtlety, pulls in close for those Evil Face moments, lest we miss the cue.
Water for Elephants makes use of a framing device similar to one the screenwriter used for The Bridges of Madison County: An old Jacob, played by Hal Holbrook, tells his story in flashback to a younger man who represents a new generation of circus operators. (In the book, young Jacob's story is interspersed with scenes of old Jacob in a nursing home before the old guy leaves the home and finds his way to the young guy's circus.) From a practical standpoint, those Holbrook bookends are a tried-and-true movie solution to unwrapping a picture and then tying it up neatly at the end with maximum heartstring tugs. But from a ''step right up and see the show'' standpoint, Water for Elephants should have sent in the clowns.C+

When people talk about a book with affection and even passion, the way they have Sara Gruen’s best-selling novel Water for Elephants, I
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Need Things

Buying Things I Want It But Do I Need It?

but do I need it? This generation gets new things so easily so of course it won’t be hard to throw anything away. I know this from personal experience; once something doesn’t look right anymore or looks outdated I throw it in the trash. A lot of things that I end up throwing away are things that I bought out of impulse while in the store. It’s my disposable culture that I have gotten used to, which I am starting to notice become a problem. There are many ways to avoid buying things we want but…

Words 1199 - Pages 5

Things I Need to Be Sucessfull in Life... Essay example

pleasant. Conquering this sacred mountain by both young and old at their own caliber with a proper plan and equipments is a great achievement in itself. As we go above from the base of the mountain to its apex there are10 posts in–between. You need not start your climb from the base itself as you can reach the 4th or the 5th post by road and from here it takes about 4-5 hours to reach the peak and about 2-3 hours to descend. Huts and lodges are situated all over the mountainside and are…

Words 890 - Pages 4

Compare/Contrast of Two Short Stories - River Nemunas & Things We'Ll Need for the Coming Difficulties Essays

The River Nemunas by Anthony Doerr and Things We’ll Need For The Coming Difficulties by Valerie Vogrin are primarily related by a common theme of isolation. Isolation is certainly the main link between the stories but there are other parallels that can be drawn as well. On the other hand, there are things that the two authors did differently while still staying with this common idea. Along with analyzing the theme of isolation, this paper will also serve to compare and contrast the writing style…

Words 1291 - Pages 6

Explain What Drives History

drives history is the need to sustain life and to fulfill basic human needs. This includes things such as food and shelter. In order to have things such as food and shelter someone needs to produce these. Once an efficient way to produce these things has emerged and these basic needs are met more complex needs now need attention. These complex needs include things such as pleasure and self-fulfillment. This is a never ending cycle because there are always going to be needs that need to be met and there…

Words 519 - Pages 3

Why It Is Important To Be Thankful Essay

important to be thankful because we all need to realize that some people do not have the things that we have such as shelter, food, clothing, health, education, water and more. Everyday we take things for granted that other people don’t have and we need to try our best to sit and think about how granted we are. We also need to be thankful because it would be very rude and disrespectful not to be to our family that provides us the essentials. The top three things I am thankful for is family, clean water…

Words 505 - Pages 3

Archery And Arrows Of The Renaissance

now here they are we make bows and arrows and we do some jousting, and last thing we do is make spires. First thing we did was make bows and arrows.You will need is a straight piece of wood.Then carve the wood into a ark.After that make a nochs on the top and bottom of the bow.Then hold the string take one end of the string and make into a lope then do it to the other end then put it on the bow on the nochs.Next thing is to make the arrows…

Words 446 - Pages 2

A Short Summary On Not Buying

spend tons of money on things almost everyday. Two individuals decided that they wasn't going to buy anything for the whole year. They Are trying to test if the whole economy can go a whole year without shopping without consumer goods and experiences. It seems so difficult but you never know it can be easy. How can you even go through the whole year without buying anything you want this has to be a difficult task. Do you think you could go the whole year without buying things you like ? Have you…

Words 619 - Pages 3

The Inheritance Of Tools Analysis

The small thing in the family are the most important. They need to be cherished and never forgotten. Those are the thing that shape you into what you are going to be in the future. A theme of the 2 stories,”The Inheritance of Tools” by Scott Sanders and the Margret’s Story by Diane Setterfield is to cherish the small things in life. The small things in the family are the ones that needs to be cherished. In the Inheritance of Tools it states that “The hammer … three of us had used it to build…

Words 322 - Pages 2

Need and timely Manner Essay

five o'clock every day makes me exhausted; which in turn makes doing everything I need to get done harder including my assignments. There are a few things that I find challenging in academics two things that come to mind are not knowing the right words to use, and where to put my punctuation in the required places. In December, I know the hard thing for me will be the math. I struggle with math and so I know I will need a tutor not just online through the college but someone face to face. For that…

Words 771 - Pages 4

What Is Human Services? Essay

Everyone at some point in their lives needs help. This help could range from help with their bills to help with adequate shelter or even help with everyday living skills. No matter what the reason is for the help, it is an inevitable that people need it. In these times of need, people may wonder who they can turn to for help. This question often goes unanswered because people are so unsure. Rest assured, however, that Human Services is here to help. People just need to know where to look and even how…

Words 1120 - Pages 5