Nursing Concept PAPER

Submitted By Tasha-Herndon
Words: 866
Pages: 4
Open Document
Concept of Nursing Theory Evaluation
Tasha N. Herndon
Duquesne University
GPNG 523 Historical and Contemporary Foundations for Advanced Nursing Practice
Cynthia Rost
May 27, 2015

What is theory evaluation? Theory evaluation is the method of thoroughly inspecting a theory (McEwen & Wills, 2014). It recognizes a theory’s degree of effectiveness to guide practice, research, education, and administration (McCrae, 2012). Evaluating a theory offers a systematic, objective way of examining a theory, assists in determining strengths and weakness, and identifies the potential impact of the theory to scientific knowledge (McEwen & Wills, 2014). Just as any ideas should be examined before blind approval, so should nursing theory. A critique involves seriously thinking about the theory and judging its worth in a certain situation. An evaluation regarding the involvement of the theory to body of knowledge must be made.
The scope of a theory must be considered before selecting a method of evaluation. Is the theory a grand nursing theory? A philosophy? A middle-range nursing theory? A practice theory? Not all characteristics of theory described in an evaluation method are apparent in all levels of theory. For example, questions about pain, ethnics, symptom management, and health promotion are probably not appropriate to use in evaluating philosophies. McEwen and Wills (2014) distinguishes this in offering certain guides for analysis and/or evaluation that vary according to the different types of nursing theory.
Theory evaluation may be thought of as one-step process, a two-step sequence, or a three-step process (McEwen & Wills, 2014). Models for theory evaluation are meant as tools to advise us about theories, and to inspire further development, refinement, and use of theory (Jeffs et al., 2013). There are no examples for theory evaluation that are sufficient and suitable for every nursing theory.
Throughout the years, many scholars have offered methods for theory evaluation to assist in determining if theories serve their foreseen purpose. In McEwen and Wills (2014), there is method that combines criteria from different methods of nursing researchers. This method offers an interesting approach and is intended to evaluate middle range and practice theories (McEwen & Wills, 2014). In the synthesized method for theory evaluation, there is a significant amount of questions to be considered. When considering my own practice, I believe of these there are 3 that are most important. Following is a list of these 3 questions.
1. What is the purpose of the theory?
2. Has the theory been tested empirically? Is it supported by research? Does it appear to be accurate or valid?
3. Does the theory contribute to the discipline of nursing?
When thinking about the importance of the prior mentioned questions in my own practice, the first concept I think about is pain assessment. Pain assessment is not only important in my own practice but in all nursing practice. Pain is the most common complaint of patients in the clinical setting. Middle range theory covers the concept of pain and therefore according to McEwen and Wills (2014) the subsidized method of theory evaluation can be used when analyzing this concept. Makic, Rauen, Watson, and Poteet (2014) use the subsidized method of nursing theory evaluation to evaluate the purpose of pain assessment, the supported research regarding pain assessment, and how pain assessment contributes to nursing practice. According to studies, unrelieved pain due to improper nursing assessment can affect the quality of life of patients (Makic et al., 2014). Learning about pain assessment and pain relief is an
Show More

Related Documents: Nursing Concept PAPER

Nursing Theory: Foundation for Nursing as a Profession Essay

Nursing Theory: Foundation for Nursing as a Profession Wilma J. Vintson Chamberlain College of Nursing NR 501: Theoretical Basis for Advanced Nursing Fall 2011 Nursing Theory: Foundation for Nursing as a Profession Introduction This paper will discuss nursing theory and review how it relates to nursing as a profession. It will also focus on aspects of Virginia Henderson’s theory on the complementary-supplementary model of nursing. Nursing leadership, as it relates to Henderson’s theory…

Words 2489 - Pages 10

Concept Analysis Of Caring

Nursing is multidimensional in its nature, much like the concepts that encompass it. Throughout this paper I will be doing a comparative analysis of the various definitions of caring, as proposed by various academic sources. The purpose of this concept analysis is to examine various definitions and theories of caring, while solidifying my own concept. Caring is often an ambiguous term with many contradicting implications. Although the interpretation of the expression is ambiguous, caring has significance…

Words 207 - Pages 1

Concept Analysis Competence

Concept Analysis of Competence Competence is fundamental when providing patient care in the healthcare setting. The purpose of this paper is to explore Competence through a method of concept analysis adapted by Slusher (2015). Purpose of Analysis Despite its vital role in patient safety, there is not a formally accepted definition of competence for healthcare professionals (Institute of Medicine, 2003, p. 24). The purpose of this analysis is to explore existing literature to expand understanding…

Words 626 - Pages 3

Addressing Nursing Knowledge

purpose of this paper is to define the concept of nursing knowledge and to explain how nurse researchers address the values that inform nursing practice. It is hard to answer this question: “ what is nursing knowledge?” The difficulty in providing a clear definition for this question relies on the complexity of nursing dynamic. However, several researchers attempted to define it. For example, a synthesis of the multiple definitions that were provided by Roy for the knowledge of nursing from various…

Words 537 - Pages 3

Oduro Aziabor I NU607 Theoretical Basis Of Practice Essay

are applied in practice (Cody, 2013). Nursing theories offers the stage that allows healthcare professionals to identify patients and their different health problems; this helps in the planning and intervention for better care (Zaccagnini & White, 2011). Theories may help in managing all levels of nursing practice, including organization, implementing, and clarifying ideal responses to nursing care outcomes (Chism, 2013). Nurses may adopt a particular nursing theory to support and use in their work…

Words 2710 - Pages 11

Florence Nightingale Research Paper

relative state. (Neuman, 1996, p. 69). Nursing. The concept of nursing in the metaparadigm under Florence Nightingale’s…

Words 709 - Pages 3

Evidence-Centered Care Theory

Patient Centered Care and Interrelated Concepts The purpose of this paper is to interrelate the concepts of patient centered care, evidence-based practice, and critical thinking. These concepts are interdependent keystones to quality patient outcomes. Patient centered care is the principle of modern medical care, and specifically nursing care. Evidence-based practice is the primary innovation mechanism in nursing care today. In order to utilize evidence-based practice to the fullest extent and…

Words 696 - Pages 3

Concept Analysis Essay

Comfort: Concept Analysis Concept analysis deals with the careful job of guiding clearness to the meaning of concepts used in science, according to McEwen, M., & Wills, E. (2010) in Nursing Theories and Nursing Practice. This paper will analyze the concept of comfort which comes from Katarine Kolcaba’s Comfort theory. Comfort is the state that is experienced automatically by receivers of comfort interventions. It involves the holistic experience of being strengthened through having comfort needs…

Words 2032 - Pages 9

Evidence-Based Nursing Practice

with SVCU unit assistant manager / unit educator. She helps so many nurses in guiding them in their workplace and with nursing education. With my mentor, we discussed a topic for the final paper for this course and the concept of evidence-based nursing practice (EBP), and how these ideas would be applicable in my own nursing education. An acceptable evidence-based research paper is prudently written and reliable. Therefore, it should consist of judiciously reviewed research articles, with systematic…

Words 244 - Pages 1

Professional Nursing Paper

Professional Nursing Nursing is known as an important profession which takes on the responsibility and continuous care for the sick, disabled and dying. As a part of the healthcare system, people and communities around the world greatly benefit from the care of nurses. There are many types of nurses, and due to this, the profession continues to grow. Customarily, nurses are dynamically involved in healthcare research, management, and patient advocacy. The purpose of this paper is to discuss the…

Words 792 - Pages 4