Outline 1. Language as uniquely human / Explana4ons for language evolu4on 2. Characteris4cs of human speech 3. Limita4ons and unknowns
2
1. Language as Uniquely Human
3
Discussion “Fully developed language was in place 50,000 years ago, when humans … were crea4ng art and burying their dead, symbolic behaviors that point unequivocally to fluent language.” – Steven Pinker
• Why is evidence of art crea4on considered evidence of humans using language? • What do language and art have in common? • What other behaviours are “uniquely human”?
Language as Uniquely Human • Language makes possible all the characteris4cs that make us different – Social organiza4on, tool making, technological advances, establishment and enforcement of social and moral laws, art, …
• If we follow evolu4onary theory, then language must have evolved at some point, making us different from other primates • But, there is an enormous gap between our closer rela4ves, our chimpazees, and us 5
Language Evolu4on: Basic Explana4ons 1. Language arose as a different system from any other pre-‐exis4ng communica4on system – Then no suppor4ng evidence available
2. Language evolved from an exis4ng communica4on system
6
Evidence for Second Hypothesis • Consistent with other evidence in evolu4onary theory – Evolu4on leads to the adapta4on of old mechanisms to new func4ons
• Human speech is imposed on mechanisms that evolved for different purposes – Lungs: to exchange CO2 and oxygen (in speech: to supply air for speech) – Teeth: to break up food (in speech: provides place of ar4cula4on for consonants) 7
Nineteenth Century Theories • All with cute names (bow-‐wow, pooh-‐pooh, yo-‐ he-‐ho, la-‐la theory), but basically varia4ons on some themes – Onomatopoeia – language arose from sounds that imitated what they were represen4ng (e.g., ‘bow-‐ wow’ for dog) – Sound symbolism – pronuncia4on of word reminds people of an aspect of the referent (e.g., ‘teeny’) – Emo4on – language arose from sounds used to describe emo4onal states – Coopera4on – as a result of the need to work together
8
Problems with 19th Century Theories • Arbitrariness – Don’t account for bulk of words in languages, which are arbitrary (don’t bear resemblance to en4ty they denote (e.g., dog, enthusiasm))
• Discon4nuity problem – No traceable progression from a