Parthenon Debate

Words: 602

Pages: 3

Open Document

The situation surrounding the Parthenon sculptures and where their true home should be is a he said she said kind of situation. The British Museum believe that the pieces are all rightfully there’s. They believe this because Lord Elgin stated that he got two different forms stating he was allowed by Greece’s to take whatever artifacts he and his group wanted. Fast forward many years. The Greek government now want the pieces back and say that Lord Elgin had no right to take away the Parthenon sculptures. Now the art world is stuck in a tug of war on who should have ownership of the Parthenon sculptures. I for one believe the sculptures are okay where they are at. When the sculptures first were taken, Lord Elgin was given permission in the form of a firearm by Athen’s government. Greece’s current government now want the pieces back. I believe Greece should stick to their original agreement that they made with Lord Elgin. The sculptures are safe in England and no harm has come …show more content…
The sculptures are housed in the British museum where they are heavily guarded, while still being shown to the public. No harm has ever been done to them while on British soil. Even during the bombing of England in WW2, the British government made sure that the sculptures were placed in a safe location deep underground. However, if the sculptures were to be sent back to Greece they would be put in danger. Greece’s economic system is currently in a disarray, causing riots and a general instability. It would not take much convincing for a citizen who is down on their luck to try and steal the pieces to sell. Also, the supposed museum where the pieces would go is not that secure. Compared to the British Museum, security is less advanced, guards are few in numbers, and the piece’s new home is not completely protected. If the museum was to be caught in the crossfire of a riot, the Parthenon sculpture might by drastically

Elgin Marbles Analysis

Paulene Thorp ANT206-001 May 2, 2016 Parthenon Debate Elgin Marbles On a plateau after the Greek army’s final victory after fighting the Persians in 479 B.C. Pericles, a Athenian statesman decided to created the Parthenon on Acropolis, which took fifteen years to complete. The Parthenon was built to honor the Greek goddess Athena, and had decorative sculptures which were “symbolic of Greece’s political and cultural history” (2). The decorative sculptures consisted of 92 metopes that depicted the…

Words 1250 - Pages 5

The Parthenon Marbles

The debate between the British and Greek governments concerning the ownership of the Parthenon Marbles has been going on for hundreds of years. These sculptures were made to decorate the Parthenon and other monuments of Ancient Greece. The Parthenon is considered to be one of the world’s greatest cultural monuments. During the time in which the Ottoman Empire had domain over the territory of Greece, they gave Thomas Bruce a firman to take the marble sculptures to England. Years later, Thomas Bruce…

Words 299 - Pages 2

Acropolis Essay

building named the Temple of the Athena Nike designed by Kallikrates. A great statue of Athena created by Phidias, was originally stood in the center. To the right of where this sculpture was, there is the Parthenon. The architects that carried out this building were Iktinos and Kallikrates. The Parthenon is a Doric temple, which was designed with slight corrections…

Words 1328 - Pages 6

The Parthenon Essay

THE PARTHENON/ELGIN MARBLES By Renee Livio Who should own the Parthenon/Elgin has been a long and complex debate. Both sides, the British and the Greeks have valid and equal points as to why they should be the one to care and to keep these precious sought out marbles. Here today, I will present the arguments for both sides. “ÒÚ˘¿ The Parthenon, throughout history, has been shaken by earthquakes, set on fire, shattered to an extent, attacked a numerous amount of times, looted for its sculptures…

Words 1931 - Pages 8

Athenian Acropolis Essay

they attempt to continue to honor their past by revering a pinnacle of human art and history. The debate surrounding whether or not to return pieces separated has sparked worldwide interest. A large majority of the missing pieces reside in the collection of the British Museum of History, and were attained rather illicitly in the mid-nineteenth century. Historians and architects argue whether the Parthenon marbles should be returned or remain were they are. I would like to see the pieces returned to…

Words 1703 - Pages 7

Article Annotation Prompt Essay

detail. King discusses the very beginnings of the Parthenon, including how it came to be, how it was used throughout the years as places, such as a church at one point, the many battles it survived, and the very structure of the Parthenon itself. King then goes into further detail as to how Lord Elgin came about to obtain the marbles and ship them out of Athens to the British Museum. As a result, one of the main points of discussion is the debate over the marbles. King voices both sides of the controversy…

Words 503 - Pages 3

Elgin Marbles Research Paper

The Elgin Marbles or as they should be rightfully called “The Parthenon Marbles” today are housed in the British Museum. They were once part of the Temple Parthenon of the Greek Goddess Athena in Athens. The marbles were carved from stone and adorned the outdoor temple walls; these sculptures showed the early history and myths that belonged to the culture of ancient Greece. The temple itself has served many purposes throughout its life such as; a treasury, a Christian church dedicated to the Virgin…

Words 829 - Pages 4

Ancient Athens Research Paper

gained more land as it grew with its creativeness and intelligence. The city-state itself also has many wonders. The Acropolis was one of the oldest buildings in Athens, being able to withstand many attacks and battles throughout the years. The Parthenon, one of the most famous temples, was built for its patron goddess Athena. During the golden age of Athens, they were the cultural and artistic prime of Greece. They shared many important foundations and wonders of the world, building the foundation…

Words 3336 - Pages 14

greek notes Essay

History notes - Early Greece • Greece=45,000 square miles of territory • Mountains and sea were significant • Mountains isolated Greeks from each other • Each communities fiercely attached to independence • Fight each other to gain advantage • Greece had a long seacoast • Had islands • Became seafarers - Minoan Crete • Earliest civilization in the Aegean Region emerged on the large island of Crete • Named after Minos a legendary…

Words 4020 - Pages 17

Art Must Hang!—Must Art Hang? by Matthew Bowman Essay

Art Must Hang!—Must Art Hang? by Matthew Bowman The title of today’s lecture, “Art Must Hang!” playfully refers to the importance of exhibitions and other methods of displaying your works. Indeed, although the artwork might be created in the studio space, it might be argued that it never fully succeeds as an artwork until it has been exhibited somewhere or otherwise displayed for the benefit of the public. In that respect, the exhibition has a special significance in relation to the artwork…

Words 4561 - Pages 19