Philosophy 101 Midterm Essay

Submitted By jlouridas15
Words: 2034
Pages: 9
Open Document
James Louridas
Philosophy 101
Midterm Paper

1. In Ion, Ion claims that his skill at reciting and explaining Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey makes him an expert in every field on which Homer touches. What does Socrates think of this?
Ion is a great reciter of the works of Homer, the best in his mind. He draws in large audiences to hear him utter the fine words of the Odyssey and Iliad with such passion and emotion, which is unmatched by any other reciter in all of Greece. His skill has even granted him a golden crown by the Homer Association. Socrates envies Ion’s skill since in order to be a great reciter, you must learn the meanings of the poet’s work, not only their verses. Ion claims to speak exquisitely, in his own right, about Homer in interpreting and explaining his poetry and its excellences in every field on which he brushes upon. However, Socrates begs to differ and begins his argument on how Ion is a great reciter simply by a divine power possessing him while he eulogizes the works of Homer. Socrates states that Ion speaks so eloquently not from knowledge but instead from inspiration. Ion’s thoughts are being breathed into him by a divine power without Ion’s acknowledgement, similar to being possessed. Socrates breaks this down to Ion by avowing that reciters and even poets themselves have no knowledge of the skills and fields they so magnificently rhapsodize, instead they are part of a chain of iron rings. Socrates provides the analogy of a magnet with the power to draw an iron ring to itself and through that of another and another. Socrates is trying to explain to Ion that the magnet is the divine power and the first ring are the Muses, the second are the poets, the third are the reciters and the rest are the audiences who receive this inspiration by opening themselves to the poetry. In conclusion, Socrates’ argument is that the work of poets and reciters are not from any human skill or intelligence but is the product of the gods working through them.
2. In Apology, Socrates says that his mission as a philosopher was set for him by the oracle at Delphi. Explain this.
In the Apology, Socrates is on trial being prosecuted on several charges. His accusers, Meletus, Anytus, and Lycon, wanted Socrates punished for inquiring into things under the earth and in the heavens, and making the weaker argument the stronger, and teaching these same things to the youth. Socrates was put on trial to defend himself and his actions but Socrates only wanted to explain the “wrongdoings” he had committed. He explains that wisdom is not necessarily what you do know; it is being able to realize what you have no knowledge of, admitting it and openly seeking answers in order to gain that knowledge. Socrates begins his defense by stating that his “wrongdoings” were unintentional and it all began when the oracle at Adelphi deemed him as the wisest of all, according to his good friend Chaeraphon. Socrates claims to have been baffled by this indictment, since he always believed he knew nothing; however, he also accepts the fact that Apollo cannot lie so he set out to see if he could solve the puzzle handed to him and find anyone wiser than himself. Therefore this became his life’s mission, to expose false knowledge. He began his mission to disprove the Oracle by questioning others who had a reputation for wisdom. Socrates interrogated politicians, poets and the skilled craftsmen. In questioning the politicians, he discovered that they thought they were very wise, but in fact, they knew very little to nothing at all. The poets wrote implacable works yet seemed incapable of explaining them, and Socrates concluded that their genius came from inspiration rather than intelligence. With the craftsmen, Socrates found men who did have great wisdom in their craft; however they believed their expertise in one field led them to be experts in other fields where they had no knowledge of. In each case, Socrates confirmed that he truly was the wisest since
Show More

Related Documents: Philosophy 101 Midterm Essay

Essay about Syllabus: American Sign Language and Deaf Community

COURSE DESCRIPTION: The course is designed to teach students American Sign Language (ASL) by using the functional-notional approach, which focuses on the functions or communicative purposes of people’s everyday interactions. The philosophy of this course lies in the belief that the total immersion of ASL is based on the cultural and experiential approach in teaching students abut the language of ASL and its grammatical rules, syntax and some cultural features of the Deaf Community. The curriculum…

Words 1550 - Pages 7

Quiz Essay

1.Economics is best defined as the study of A) financial decision-making.B) how consumers make purchasing decisions.C) choices made by people faced with scarcity.D) inflation, unemployment, and economic growth.Points Earned: 0.4/0.4Correct Answer(s): C 2.Scarcity can best be defined as a situation in whichA) there are no buyers willing to purchase what sellers have produced.B) there are not enough goods to satisfy all of the buyers' demand.C) the resources we use to produce goods and services are…

Words 1099 - Pages 5

Midterm 1 Sample MC Questions 1 Essay example

Midterm 1 Marketing in IT – Sample Multiple Choice Questions 1. What utility does Cannondale create when the company combines aluminum and other components in the production of bicycles? a. ownership utility b. form utility c. place utility d. time utility 2. When you purchase concert tickets over the Internet, which of the following utilities is NOT created? a. place utility b. time utility c. form utility d. ownership utility 3. Which of the following must all organizations create…

Words 8567 - Pages 35