Philosophy: Virtue Ethics and Natural Sciences Essay example

Submitted By jzucks
Words: 1973
Pages: 8
Open Document
The Enlightenment Project
Imagine a world, Alasdair MacIntyre insists at the inception of After Virtue, where the sciences are renounced by the public and sentenced to obliteration. Following this jihad against the natural sciences, the public recants its condemnation, knowing its costly mistake and attempts to salvage any knowledge of natural science, however, only fragments of the knowledge once had still remain. Like the Library of Alexandria, tremendously vital knowledge would disappear, destroyed by a close-minded world. Their attempts to find what is lost would be futile for ”nobody, or almost nobody, realizes that what they are doing is not natural science in any proper sense at all. For everything that they do and say conforms to certain canons of consistency and coherence and those contexts which would be needed to make sense of what they are doing have been lost, perhaps irretrievably (MacIntyre 1).” This is not an imaginary world; this is reality, to MacIntyre, only it is the language of morality that is lost in this “state of grave disorder” instead of the natural sciences (MacIntyre 2). MacIntyre, thus turns to an analysis of history as the only way to understand morality where he believes he discovers the very epoch where the catastrophe took place, the Enlightenment.
The Enlightenment was a time when philosophy played a central role in society, unlike today, where philosophers attempted to discover a rational justification of morality in a secular world. MacIntyre calls the project a failure, a step towards the dystopian world against the natural sciences, the very fire that burned down the ancient library of wisdom in Alexandria. This is because all the conflicting voices that proved each other wrong, that they were unable to provide the foundation they were seeking. The failure of this “project provided the historical background against which the predicaments of our own culture can become intelligible,” meaning the Enlightenment was the “predecessor culture” to the catastrophe of emotivism (MacIntyre 39). Two major schools of thought emerged at this time: utilitarianism, championed by Mill, and deontology, championed by Kant and his descendent in thought, Kierkegaard. In order to prove that the conflicting views did not cause the Enlightenment project to fail, one must prove that their theses are reasonable or that they are non exclusive meaning there is room for a median position. This essay aims to analyze both ideologies using the critiques in After Virtue, where MacIntyre successfully proves the exclusivity of both and that utilitarianism to be unreasonable, however, Kantianism and Kierkegaardianism survive MacIntyre’s onslaught of critiques. Deontology shows that this epoch was not at all the society that condemned the natural sciences, but rather was the society that brought thought and morality to a new unchartered peak.
The easiest way to prove the success of the enlightenment would be to create a common ground for utilitarianism and deontology, however MacIntyre is keen on showing the incommensurability of the two. He did this mainly by pointing out the constant criticism between the leaders. The "effective criticism of each position by the others turned out to be the failure of all", and thus the project as a whole failed. By changing into a world of “secular rationality, religion could no longer provide such a shared background and foundation,” and the failure of the enlightenment to find a common framework is what leads to the exclusivity of the two schools of thought (MacIntyre 50). This would force the argument that through rationality their can be a common ground. Where Kant argues that “any rational agent is logically committed to the rules of morality in virtue of his or her rationality (MacIntyre 66),” Mill argues that one must rationalize that “actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness (Mill
Show More

Related Documents: Philosophy: Virtue Ethics and Natural Sciences Essay example

Aristotle: Epistemology and Knowledge Essay

Thoughts and Theories ! ! ! ! Knowledge and WisdomLogic & Critical Thinking ! ! ! curiousity Philo/sophy - Love and Wisdom. Wisdom = Intellectual and Moral Excellence. Love = Agapy. Subfields Of Philosophy Chapter 1 Review. Where does The universe come from? Cosmological question. Hesiod- Theo/gony" 750-700b.c Gia- Mother earth. Eros- Sexual Love/Lust Ouranos- Sky God Pontos- Sea-God Kronos- Son of Gia and Ouranos…

Words 1541 - Pages 7

Essay about Dominican: Thomas Aquinas and God

Italy), circa January 28, 1225. Saint Thomas Aquinas (c.1225-1274) was a scholastic philosopher and Dominican whose work had an enormous influence both on the course of Christian theology and on the course of philosophy generally. Before Aquinas' work, the dominant figure in Western philosophy was Augustine, who emphasized the principles of God's sovereignty and the importance of revelation. The translation of Aristotle's works threatened this, however, because it appeared to give primacy to individuals…

Words 2977 - Pages 12

Essay on Psy 310 Assignment

Roots of Early Philosophy in Psychology Carlos Torres PSY/310 6/1/15 The roots of early philosophy are the initial study of understanding; it is therefore the core of psychology, which is used to motivate an individual’s thoughts, feelings, and actions to understand behavior. Philosophy relates to how an individual’s experiences through understanding with no emotions. Therefore, one understands of how both philosophy and psychology can correlate with each other, even though…

Words 1046 - Pages 5

History Of Philosophy

1. Philosophy is the intellectual attempt to understand reality through rational, critical questioning. It can be also defined as exercising our intellectual curiosity- trying to define philosophy is doing philosophy. The origin of the word philosophy comes from the Greek words “philo” (love); and “Sophia” (wisdom) and can be literally translated as the love of wisdom, wisdom in terms of intellectual wisdom. It began in 585 B.C.E with the shift from believing in a myth to using our own intellectual…

Words 635 - Pages 3

The Meaning Of Life

and happiness, and borders on many other issues, such as symbolic meaning, ontology, value, purpose, ethics, good and evil, free will, the existence of one or multiple Gods, conceptions of God, the soul, and the afterlife. Scientific contributions focus primarily on describing related empirical facts about the universe, exploring the context and parameters concerning the 'how' of life. Science also studies and can provide recommendations for the pursuit of well-being and a related conception of…

Words 3304 - Pages 14

Virtue and Aristotle Essays

Aristotle: Ethics and the Virtues The Goal of Ethics Aristotle applied the same patient, careful, descriptive approach to his examination of moral philosophy in the Εθικη Νικομαχοι (Nicomachean Ethics). Here he discussed the conditions under which moral responsibility may be ascribed to individual agents, the nature of the virtues and vices involved in moral evaluation, and the methods of achieving happiness in human life. The central issue for Aristotle is the question of character or personality…

Words 2042 - Pages 9

Greek Philosophy Essay

Heather Zinck Kim Bauman Humanities 1301 24, January 2014 Understanding Greek Philosophy In the complexity of Greek Philosophy, it is best to take a look into the life of Socrates first. Socrates, (469-399 BCE), was among three very influential philosophers for the Greeks and his work is still studied at length today. He believed in enjoying life and also that truth, beauty, and justice have objective content and that we are born with an innate understanding of their existence. (www.watson…

Words 779 - Pages 4

Chapter One Essay

dealing with Chapter one: Background A: Moral: A manner of being or acting or of conducting oneself, especially in regard to man only human beings may act freely 2 conditions for moral responsible: 1) knowledge 2) freedom B: Theology: Theos Logia study science of God; not as He is Himself but as revealed to man. Not as man can deduce from reason but rather it is faith seeking understanding in light of visible creation. C: Moral Theology: 1) studies human conduct in the light of Salvation Truth, the teachings…

Words 1346 - Pages 6

Essay on accounting ethics

This is a 6-page essay discussing ethics and governance in business. It identifies one specific organization and critically evaluates its performance in relation to the key principles of business ethics. It provides background information about the organization, information about ethical dilemmas within the organization and possible ways these dilemmas can be solved. It relies on 15 sources and is presented in Harvard format. Enron and Ethics Introduction Enron is an American company based in…

Words 1855 - Pages 8

Biography Of Socrates

one of the founders of Western philosophy, he is an enigmatic figure known chiefly through the accounts of later classical writers, especially the writings of his students Plato and Xenophon, and the plays of his contemporary Aristophanes. Many would claim that Plato's dialogues are the most comprehensive accounts of Socrates to survive from antiquity. Through his portrayal in Plato's dialogues, Socrates has become renowned for his contribution to the field of ethics, and it is this Platonic Socrates…

Words 9241 - Pages 37