Plato Gorgias Paper

Submitted By Caitlen-Sloan
Words: 1475
Pages: 6
Open Document
Caitlen Sloan
Dr. Staal
POL 200
01 May, 2015
Tyranny: The Greatest of all Fortunes

Ali ibn Abi Talib, an important leader in the Islamic faith, once said, “Do for today as if you live forever, do for the afterlife as if you die tomorrow” (Hilal). This quote outlines one of the basic beliefs of the Muslim religion: All people have the choice to act justly or unjustly, but they must one day be held responsible for their choices. Their faith contests that when dead, souls remain in a sleep-like state until judgment day, when Allah will determine their fate by their actions on Earth. In fact, most religions believe in a form of afterlife. The Christian faith, too, believes in an eternal life based on a judgment of one’s conduct throughout their time on Earth. God will evaluate one’s faith, upon death, to decide his placement in heaven or hell. Buddhists believe everyday actions elicit karma and one’s karma dictates their life stance for reincarnation. Even the ancient Greeks believed in a version of “heaven and hell” where bad souls went to the underworld and good souls went to a tranquil paradise. Socrates describes this Grecian belief and parallels Talib’s quote in his idea of the afterlife as described in, Gorgias by Plato. The entire dialogue of Gorgias asserts that living a just life is the only true form of happiness and, therefore, tyranny is worse for the tyrant than the oppressed. If one lives a just life, he confirms a positive judgment in the hereafter while the actions of a tyrant will ensure punishment upon judgment. However, if one were to remove the idea of an afterlife, Socrates’ indication of what a just life entails will change drastically. Socrates’ conversational skills are almost artful in the sense that he describes a word with the definition that best fits his needs for any particular topic. Although individual words may have many different meanings, once a specific one is agreed upon in a conversation, the participants are constrained to use the word in the context of the established definition. Socrates uses this skill throughout Gorgias, but especially while attempting to convince Polus that, “the greatest of all misfortunes is to do wrong” (Plato, 469b). The two agreed that doing wrong was more shameful than suffering wrong, but Polus asserted that suffering wrong was still worse than causing it. Due to this initial disagreement, Socrates began to define terms in order to unquestionably support his claim. They quickly agreed that suffering and pleasure were opposites and that good was the opposite of evil and pain. Socrates then convinced Polus that pleasure is synonymous with good, which must result in shameful being synonymous with evil and pain (Plato, 474c-475e). With these definitions in place, the initial agreement that doing wrong was more shameful than suffering wrong inevitably proved that doing wrong was also more evil than suffering wrong. Tyranny, therefore, is one of the ultimate evils. Tyrants kill, banish, steal, and wrong as they please, but the happiness their actions appear to bring them are only skin deep; their soul is suffering and scarred for the evil actions they commit. Socrates has hinted towards his idea of what a good life consists of during the course of his dialogues with all three men. He emphasizes that matters of the soul are far more important than that of the body because they contain the purest forms of ourselves (Plato 507-508). In his last discussion with Callicles, Socrates describes in further detail what a just man is like. He says a man who acts disciplined, brave, just, and reverent consequentially is a man characterized by the same traits. This man is considered a good man, due to his behaviors, and is therefore happy (Plato, 507a-c). True happiness is attained by pursuing self-discipline and justice, running from the opposite, and controlling our desires. This happiness is only true for a just man; an unjust man merely has the appearance of happiness.
Show More

Related Documents: Plato Gorgias Paper

Aristotle And Isocrates Rhetoric

completely different stances and not budging. In this paper, we are specifically looking at three philosophers, all respected in their time and still studied today, and trying to explain their approaches to rhetoric and how they see it best used. Plato, Isocrates and Aristotle each give distinct standpoints on the matter, they not only challenge but also break down any pre-existing notions about rhetoric. This brings us to the second aspect of this paper, relating the work of those three scholars to the…

Words 1107 - Pages 5

Plato's Use Of Rhetoric

completely different stances and not budging. In this paper, we are specifically looking at three philosophers, all respected in their time and still studied today, and trying to explain their approaches to rhetoric and how they see it best used. Plato, Isocrates and Aristotle each give distinct standpoints on the matter, they not only challenge but also break down any pre-existing notions about rhetoric. This brings us to the second aspect of this paper, relating…

Words 661 - Pages 3

Antigone: Communism and Noon est Essay

Political Science 275 Online, Spring 2015 Semester Paper The list of topics below is a starting point. You are free to come up with a topic of your own that you think would be more interesting to you; I have always believed that people do better work when they get to decide what they're going to be working on. If you want to use your own topic, by noon EST on Sunday, March 1 you must e-mail me a one or two page typed abstract or outline (it can be longer if you want) clearly explaining what you…

Words 937 - Pages 4

Plato's Argument For The Immortality Of The Soul

Immortality of the Soul Jane Smith November 5, 2014 PHIL 1000H Professor James Connelly The topic of this paper is the immortality of the soul. I will explain and assess Plato’s argument for the immortality of the soul, as developed in the Meno and Phaedo. In addition, this paper will discuss what epistemological considerations Plato used to support his view of the immortality of the soul, and how these considerations supported this view. I find Plato’s arguments for the immortality…

Words 1671 - Pages 7

Plato Presentation Paper

Cody Preble 10/5/14 COM 300 Presentation Paper: Plato Plato is one of the world’s best-known and most widely studied philosophers and intellectuals throughout history. Although very little is actually known about his life, which has forced scholars to construct most of his biography; with the help of his writings and the writings of other great philosophers and intellects. This has created a lot of controversy throughout the academic community, and scholars still debate whether all of Plato’s works…

Words 1774 - Pages 8