Poem Essay

Submitted By Adrien-Alejandro
Words: 855
Pages: 4
Open Document
Adrien Alejandro
Professor Dyre
English 1600
9 March 2015 Can’t we all just be Bros?
In Thomas Hardy’s “The Man He Killed” the speaker lets the readers know his thoughts on war. The poem makes us question whether or not we are all equal inside. Is war a necessity for our survival, or are we just doing it because our country tells us to? Only the soldiers who have experienced war first hand can tell and this is Thomas Hardy’s story.
To begin with, in the first stanza of the poem the speaker mentions “we should have sat us down to wet/ Right many a nipperkin” (3-4)! Which in translation means that if “he” and the speaker had just sat down in a bar or pub and had a small number of drinks, that they would have been good friends with some things in common. Of course the “he” in the poem refers to an enemy of war, and so the speaker believes that anyone can settle their differences over a glass of beer if only they just took the time to do so. At the end of the second stanza the speaker has already shot and killed the enemy but when staring face to face with him, curiosity and wonder go through his head as the speaker doubts the purpose of war all in all (5-8). The chances of him meeting that specific enemy as infantry could have been a chance of meeting him in an inn or pub. For example, say the speaker and his enemy both have syphilis but do not know it yet because they are too busy fighting a war, but the enemy decides to invite the speaker to a bar, that they just happened to be fighting next to, for a couple of drinks and one hour later they turn out to be the best of friends and find out that they both contracted their deadly disease from the same woman!
Moreover, the speaker tries to reason with himself by trying to think of a good enough reason as to why the speaker shot another human being. Lines 9 and 10 say “Because he was my foe, / Just so: my foe of course he was” (9-10). Did the speaker shoot him because he was really his “foe” or was it the speaker’s duty to kill? The speaker tries to come to a reasonable justification that it was ok to kill the enemy so he, the speaker, would not have to grip the thought of such a thing but because his enemy was simply just a foe was not good enough. The speaker keeps the question of “we could have been friends if met in different conditions” in the back of his mind (9-12). Up to this point, the speaker is having problems trying to comprehend the war the speaker is fighting in and wonders what outcomes could have resulted if he had just met his rival at a pub that if they could have become friends instead of foes.
Next, the fourth stanza of the poem mentions a reason why the speakers rival could have possibly enlisted in the war; maybe he could have had the same reasoning as the speaker did. The speaker joined offhand because he, the speaker, was out of work, out of money. Was
Show More

Related Documents: Poem Essay

Poem Essay

Dreams by Langston Hughes is a great poem. It is very short but it also has meaning to it. It amazes me how this man can write a poem in less than 9 lines and still have the ferociousness as the greatest writers did back when they were alive. Dreams has different poetic devices used throughout the poem such as, imagery and metaphors. This is the poem. Hold fast to dreams For if dreams die Life is a broken-winged bird That cannot fly. Hold fast to dreams For when dreams go Life is a barren…

Words 432 - Pages 2

essays/poems

Aryn De La Garza English 2 March 27, 2014 Creon’s Decision I think his law is very unreasonable, considering all it did for him was cause death of his son Haemon as well as Antigone. Yes it would have prevented anarchy on that particular law, but at the same time I’m sure it caused anarchy about what happened to Antigone and Haemon. It is not necessary to exercise absolute power, because then it gets into their minds and they feel that they can do whatever they want as kings. Thus leading…

Words 371 - Pages 2

Essay on the poem tall

Essay- (on the poem Tall) The poem Tall written by carol Ann Duffy is based upon a young women who doesn’t stop growing throughout her years of life and grows so tall that she outgrows the earth’s atmosphere but is still able to reach down to the service to intervene in the course of disaster. People in her society seem to think she has a magic power or some king of ‘super strength’ but she hasn’t, she’s just an extra tall woman. The poem in which describes the women and her desire to ‘fit in’…

Words 1065 - Pages 5

Poem Essay

Singh Mrs. Hunsaker AP Literature 13 February 2015 Curiosity Analysis In his poem, “Curiosity,” Reid uses juxtaposition to compare the two extremes presented in the poem, drastic shift in tone, and a paradox describing true living to demonstrate that life shouldn’t be wasted being conservative, but rather spent being open to new and untested undertakings. Reid uses juxtaposition to compare the two extremes presented in the poem. The rivalry between the cat and the dog is as old as time, and is used as…

Words 734 - Pages 3

a poem Essay

Pirate or Puritan? Which one are you? 1. I learned that William Bradford left his child behind to venture with his wife to Plymouth. I learned that he was named governor after John Carver died until William himself died I learned that his wife fell overboard during the journey and died 2. He did a lot for the colonial Americans; he was responsible for so many people and their wellbeing. 3. Williams’s wife Dorothy fell overboard and drowned while the pilgrim men were out exploring and looking…

Words 414 - Pages 2

Poem Essay

Solitude in Poetry Lord Byron was a famous poet during the era of Romantic poetry. His European sonnet “Solitude” is one of his best works. His poem “Solitude” clearly demonstrates the themes of Romantic literature. In “Solitude”, Lord Byron embodies the belief that man is good when living with nature and away from corrupted society. In the midst of the poem, Byron states, “This is not solitude, ‘tis but to hold / converse with nature’s charms, and view her stores unrolled” (8-9). The poet expresses…

Words 431 - Pages 2

Subaltern: Writing and Poem Essay

have selected to write my paper on John Betjeman’s poem “A Subaltern’s Love Song.” This poem is a witty approach at explaining passionate feelings from the poet’s point of view, who is also the speaker. It is a satire and imaginative written work, which I will go into detail further in the paper. I will explain the analytical style on this poem, assess the meaning of the poem and discuss how this poem captured my interest. The poem is a satire, for the reason that he wrote it about a…

Words 594 - Pages 3

Poems: Aggression and F. Poems Life Essay

Adler F. Poems Life In school you’re taught then given a test To classify you with the worst or the best Anxiety and thoughts of failing causing stress You get it done though never settle for less In life you learn while you are being tested To overcome and shine is how to be respected The struggle is your test that teaches a lesson In order to act you must use your discretion Make provisions to go in the right direction Control your anger and appease aggression Understand others and…

Words 429 - Pages 2

EBC Poem Analysis Essays

1 Bonillas Ranae Bonillas ELA Honors Per. 3 Ms. Pusey 6 October 2014 Dickinson and Frost Poem Analysis Essay "Let life be as beautiful as summer flowers, And death as beautiful as autumn leaves.", as Rabindranath Tagore says. Tagore uses symbolism and similes to convey that life should be beautiful and lived to the fullest, while death should still be beautiful yet, not as bright and joyful as life. To be, or not to be accepted…

Words 643 - Pages 3

Bruce Poem Essay

William Faulkner, “Nobel Prize Acceptance Speech” December 10, 1950; Stockholm, Sweden A true master of the written word, William Faulkner did not often make public his gift for the spoken variety. So there was some interest as to what he would say when accepting the Nobel Peace Prize for his “powerful and artistically unique contribution to the modern American novel.” The year was 1950, the Soviet Union had tapped the potential of the atomic bomb, and the atmosphere in the the United States crackled…

Words 301 - Pages 2