Essay about Point of Law

Submitted By ezorn001
Words: 1898
Pages: 8
Open Document
Point of Law—Search and Seizure in the Classroom
Eric Zorn
ELS 657: Public School Law
Dr. Mark Lineburg 11/28/12

Abstract
Students in today’s schools are often concerned that their constitutional rights are being violated by teachers and administrators. Specifically, they are concerned that their privacy is being violated when there are random classroom searches. Upon reviewing relevant court cases and judicial documents it is clear that what students perceive as violation of their rights is well within the rights of school officials. While in school, the safety and wellbeing of the students becomes the responsibility of the adults therein. The role of parent is assumed by the teachers and administrators, and the court acknowledges that with this role parental rights are given. Random search and seizure is constitutionally valid if the end is to protect and keep the students safe at school.

Scenario
Newport News Public Schools often allow their administrators and school’s resource officers to conduct random classroom searches of students’ back packs and personal items. During these searches personal items are searched and items can be confiscated. For this scenario, while performing a random classroom search the school’s resource officer, acting as a school agent, discovers, in her backpack, a student’s cell phone, which is not powered off, and seizes the item. The student was not using the technology in class; however, Newport News Public School policy states that all phones are to be powered off during school hours. The parent will now be required to drive to the school to pick up the student’s cell phone, and both student and parent will sign a contract indicating that a second confiscation of the student’s cell phone will result in a five day hold before retrieval.

Question of Law
Is the school allowed to search students and their personal property randomly without reasonable cause or is this a violation of the students’ rights under the Fourth Amendment?
Can personal property be seized during random searches or is this also an impediment on students’ Fourth Amendment rights?

Cases Well over 20 years ago, in the state of New Jersey, there was a case brought before the US Supreme court that help to create the norms of public school search and seizures. The case was New Jersey v. T.L.O. (1984). In brief, this case involved a high school girl who had her purse searched after she had been caught smoking in the restroom. T.L.O was taken to the vice principal’s office and when asked whether she was smoking denied that she smoked, and went on to add that she never smoked. The administrator asked to search her purse and upon doing so discovered not only cigarettes, but also a pack of rolling papers. Experience had taught him that where there were rolling papers there was also often marijuana. His closer inspection, and deeper digging, confirmed his suspicions. The administrator found money and what appeared to be a customer list, and decided to hand the evidence over to the police. While with the police, T.L.O. confessed to selling drugs at her high school. The state of New Jersey then brought delinquency charges against her. However, in the end T.L.O. argued that the evidence used against her should be thrown out due to the improper search and violation of her Fourth Amendment rights by the school’s vice principal citing the exclusionary rule. The lower courts of New Jersey found no violation of the student’s rights. It was only at the state Supreme Court level that the search and seizure violation was questioned. From there her case went before the United States Supreme Court, and their ruling favored the vice principal and set a precedence for public schools and students’ Fourth Amendment rights.

School District Policy
The Newport News Public Schools’ Rights and Responsibilities Handbook discusses the students’ rights and responsibilities as well general information
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Point of Law

Essay on United States Constitution and Points Question

player and a “crook.” Answer True False 1 points Question 2 1. According to Milton Friedman, all of the following are reasons not to use corporate funds to serve social causes EXCEPT: Answer | | It’s a form of taxation without representation | | | It’s shortsighted and doesn’t consider the long-term impacts of such spending | | | It undermines the market system | | | It avoids the coercion of non-voluntary parties | 1 points Question 3 1. The…

Words 12115 - Pages 49

Argumentative Essay On Stop And Frisk

debate for minorities since they are often profilled by police under the law of stop and frisk. The two positions argue whether or not the policy of stop and frisk should be stopped. Both viewpoints have valid claims warranting consideration; for example, evidence indicates that stop and frisk unfairly targets minorities. In contrast, opposing evidence suggests that it does not. While both sides of the issue have valid points, the position that stop and frisk policies should be continued is the best-supported…

Words 564 - Pages 3

Segregation: Martin Luther King, Jr. and Dr . King Essay

explicit points of argument. The Clergymen had addressed their concern for the willingness of Dr. King and his followers to break the law. They were concerned with the fact that the segregated would only follow laws to which benefited them. Addressing this concern Dr. King gives the explicit point of “There are just and there are unjust laws.”(parag.13). Dr. King provides anecdotal evidence by referring to Saint Augustine who said, “An unjust law is no law at all.” He further supports this point by explaining…

Words 782 - Pages 4

Essay about Exam for Chapter 1

out of 10 points | | | A group of young professionals were discussing the relationship between law and business. Adam argues that law primarily benefits the owners of businesses at the expense of workers and customers, while Beth takes the opposite position - that law primarily benefits the individual employees, customers and others, at the expense of the owners of businesses. Charlie posits that all parties are better off because of the presence of law, while David asserts that law is not a…

Words 1244 - Pages 5

Supply and Demand and Certain Private Businesses Essay

Lesson 1 (3.0 points) 1. Name at least two things financial planning could help you do. (0.5 points) Create a budget Save and invest money 2. What is trade? (0.5 points) Trade is the exchange of things of value. 3. What is a service? (0.5 points) A service is something of value that a person can do for other people, such as babysitting, tutoring, or landscaping. 4. Name one of the three functions of money. (0.5 points) Medium of exchange 5. The real estate market is categorized in which…

Words 345 - Pages 2

Lincoln's Reconstruction Plan Essay

5) Create more jobs for both black and white FINAL DRAFT: Overall Plan Name: (Ex: Lincoln’s Reconstruction Plan) Jenni and Leo’s Reconstruction 5 Point Plan Title of Law/Act/Plan #1: _______Abolish Slavery Permanetly Act______ (Example:Title of this law we are creating will be: The Gradual Emancipation Act of 1865) Problem being addressed: Which of the post-war problems are you trying to resolve here? Answer this question: Explain the actual problem that existed: (Example:…

Words 2161 - Pages 9

Diversity In Law Enforcement

in the U.S. Law Enforcement community is, what the ideology of the people is about, and how the U.S. Laws are being interpreted. Throughout this paper the reader will be able to get another point of view on these points. This is done by presenting information from scholarly peer reviewed articles, articles published by newspaper authors, a survey, and graphs describing information regarding diversity in the U.S. Law Enforcement community. Key Words: Diversity, U.S. Law Enforcement, Laws, and Ideology…

Words 1502 - Pages 7

Essay about Win Win

control) target and reservation points, a win-win may not be possible nor a BATNA (best alternative to a negotiated agreement). Although a win-win may not be possible, the two parties must prepare with their critical factors. In addition, the worksheet for negotiations is also a great preparation tool. The critical factors for the party for gun control are banning assault weapons and performing background checks at gun shows. The party against gun control does not want laws to change because of the…

Words 475 - Pages 2

Charting An Essay: On Not Going To School

Essay: On Not Going to School ¶(s) Saying Doing Operating Reacting 1 Mandatory attendance law forces kids with no ambition for education to attend school regardless to what they may want. The author has stated that if they remove the attendance law that it would make more room for the students who want to learn. The writer identifies the law as a no choice attendance based on the mandatory attendance law for our American education system I don’t agree so much with the writer. I feel kids should…

Words 358 - Pages 2

Essay about Lab 6

GS104 Lab Report Experiment # 6 Hooke’s Law David Case: February 12, 2015 Experiment #6 Hooke’s Law Objectives: To investigate Hooke’s law and to determine the spring constant for two springs and a rubber band. Materials: Rubber Band Computer and Spreadsheet Scale-Spring-500-g Tape Measure Srpings, 2 sizes-Pk Experiment 1: This experiment will use a spring scale in place of calibrated weights to increase the force on a spring. However…

Words 1123 - Pages 5