To What Extent Is The Human Rights Act Controversial

Submitted By cathtan1234
Words: 702
Pages: 3
Open Document
In what ways, and to what extent, is the Humans Rights Act controversial. (40 marker)

Human rights are rights inherent to all human beings, whatever nationality, place of residence, sex, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, language, or any other status. Everyone is equally entitled to human rights without discrimination. These rights are all interrelated, interdependent and indivisible. The Human Rights Act was introduced by Labour in 1998. Although it has many positive effects it has fallen under scrutiny in recent years, as there is a cause for concern over whether or not everyone should be entitled to the same rights.
Arguably the most controversial point of the Human Rights Act is its obligation to support criminals and terrorists, this was recently highlighted in a small number of high-profile cases such as Abu Qatada, the hate preacher. Qatada was an asylum seeker who claimed to have suffered from torture in his home country of Jordan. His application was accepted and Qatada was granted refugee status in the UK. He was detained several times for acts of various different terrorism offences however was found not guilty and remained in the UK. On 12 November 2012, the Special Immigration Appeals Commission (SIAC) upheld Abu Qatada's appeal against deportation and released him on restrictive bail conditions. This was a very unpopular decision, even though officially it was against his human rights the Home Secretary Theresa May said the government would appeal against the decision. Abu Qatada was deported to Jordan on 7 July 2013, after an agreement between the Uk and Jordan was made. This particular case raises some very controversial issues with Human Rights Act, as it raises the issue of whether or not terrorists, murders, rapes and others who commit terrible crimes are entitled to the same human rights as everyone else and if so where do you draw the line?
The Human Rights Act is not entirely controversial, on the whole most people would agree that it is good to have laws that protect you if your basic human rights are breached. The HRA gives people a safeguard of democratic values, it treats everyone as an equal and it gives people the right to such things as freedom of speech, the right to liberty and the right to a fair trial. It allows people to know exactly what their rights are as a citizen of the U.K. Before the HRA people had to rely primarily on the self-restraint of the government. In these ways it is not so controversial as most human beings agree that these are things we all should be entitled to and it is necessary to have a bill to enforce this.
However
Show More

Related Documents: To What Extent Is The Human Rights Act Controversial

Politics Revisaion Essay

Politics (AS) Revision 1.1 - Democracy Forms of Democracy Direct Democracy – This is where the power to make decisions lies with the people. The earliest accepted form of this democracy was in Ancient Greece whereby the people (although only the Men) would gather, listen to speeches from leading citizens and then vote upon the issue. The majority vote was accepted. Clearly however, this form of democracy is not applicable with today’s society as many more decisions must be made and the voting…

Words 4097 - Pages 17

Politics in Media Essay

Dylan Poor 10/24/12 Comm 101 Politics in Media Media is such an important part of the American culture, and many other cultures around the world. People consume media in many different ways, including, television, radio, movies, and the internet. These different media have many channels which are owned by different people, and the owners can convey different messages within their information being produced. Some of that product has political views that may tie into anything that their media…

Words 743 - Pages 3

US politics Essay

Mr. West, in a radio interview Monday morning, said he feels used by Mr. Obama and he’s not going to think about the president anymore. “I’m not gonna mention him no more, I’m past that,” Mr. West said of the president on Philadelphia station Hot 107.9. “That’s out my thoughts. That’s lowering my priority of thinking at this point.” The rift is probably not causing the president to lose any sleep. Mr. Obama has referred to Mr. West at least twice publicly as a “jackass,” including once in 2009…

Words 400 - Pages 2

Obama and Politics Essay

Obama and Political Issues A major political issue that Obama has spoken on in his debates is his opinion about small business owners. He has made it pretty clear with his stand on Obamacare and with all of his tax cuts for small business owners that Obama definitely favors small business owners ( Pagliery 1 ). He raises taxes for the upper class, such as with the Obamacare tax, but lowers taxes for the lower/middle class and small business owners with various tax cuts ( Pagliery 1 ). Obama believes…

Words 649 - Pages 3

Politics 1A Essay

[See further Understanding Russian Politics, ch 5] A more diversified society. Under Soviet system, two ‘classes’ and a ‘stratum’. Differences limited by law. No living off the labour of others, or ‘exploitation’, or the class conflict of capitalism Little private wealth, limited differences in incomes (tho much distributed by administrative means or privilege) Brezhnev and hunting; heat-seeking missiles. With democratisation, these advantages became vulnerable; elite naturally…

Words 1104 - Pages 5

Essay On Aristotle On Politics

book titled Politics. In the book, he brought about discussion from the purpose of government to how the government should be utilized by its citizens. Patrick Coby stated, "at one time or another Aristotle's favor turns to monarch, to aristocracy, to polity, to some mixture of the three, or to any sort of constitutional order in which the rule of law is paramount"(Coby. 1986). He made many valid points on his breakdown of politics, but his specifics on politics as an art, politics as law, and moral…

Words 782 - Pages 4

Environmental Politics Essay

Japan has achieved and sustained tremendous economic development over the past century. This growth was highly in part to industrialization and the movement away from a agricultural society. Unlike many of it’s neighbors Japan’s industrial growth was in many ways similar to that of countries in Western Europe and the United States of America. However as we have seen in much of the Western World, this rapid growth tends to lead to many environmental problems down the road. After the Second World…

Words 539 - Pages 3

Politics of Travel Essay

From “The Politics of Travel”. Tourism is one of the fastest growing industries today. Thousands of people travel every day all around the world. People used to think that the tourism helps with the country’s economy, profits and development of local attractions and natural resources. However, there are some negative issues for a country produced by tourism. One of the most negative side effect caused by tourists is pollution. The more people come to visit a place, the big areas will get dirty. Destroying…

Words 404 - Pages 2

Essay on uss politic

U.S Government and Politics Interest Groups, is an organized group of individuals that seek to influence public policy. Which are also known as lobbies. Facts: Paul Schafer escaped Germany for sexually abusing charges against two boys. He Fled to Chile to later be charged with twenty-six charges of sex molestation. Schafer was caught in Argentina. Schafer used his powerful connections to influence the people in the colony. All of which allow him to become the monster he was. Villa…

Words 431 - Pages 2

Essay on Government and Politics

Presidential Powers Related to Public Policy American Government and Public Affairs Stefaon Singleton Tami Erickson Colorado Technical University Abstract The election of President Barack Obama was a very significant event for the American Government. The American Government has always had a standard to which the country was to be run. Each branch of government was given expressed powers by the constitution. Each branch has a certain job and has certain liabilities regarding the other…

Words 1035 - Pages 5