Politics In Canada Paper

Submitted By ibonhomme
Words: 1413
Pages: 6
Open Document
Ilarion Bonhomme
102097
November 2012
78:260 Government and Politics of Canada

The Canadian Electoral System

In this paper I will argue that changes to the Canadian electoral system are something that needs to happen. Some of the reasons that I believe change needs to happen that I will highlight in my paper are single member plurality denies representation for all voters, produces false governments, regional differences are exaggerated resulting in low percentages of women and visible minority MPs.
Before starting this paper I looked for a definition of an “electoral system”. My favorite definition that popped up was “a legal system for making democratic choices” (http://wordnetweb.princeton.edu/perl/webwn?s=electoral%20system). I like this one the best because of the idea of democratic choices is pointed out in it. In a democracy the voice of the people looms large and should always be represented as strongly as possible. In the Canadian electoral system I don’t feel like this is the case due to Canada’s electoral system. Canada operates under the first past the post or single member plurality electoral system (SMP). Under the single member plurality electoral system each electoral district or riding, the candidate with the most number of votes in an election wins a seat in the House of Commons, or the legislative assembly in provincial and territorial elections. The leader of the party which wins the highest number or seats, instead of the party with the highest percentage of the overall vote is asked to arrange the government. In other words it is it is not necessary to win an overall majority of the vote: providing the candidate has at least one more vote than each of the other candidates, and then he or she is declared the victor (Farrell 2001, Electoral Systems, Pg.19).
Supporters of the single member plurality system hope to not see reform to the system for a number of different reasons. For one the current system is simple and easy to understand. SMP is simple in terms of actual voting and figuring out the winner is not complicated at all. Another thing some people believe the SMP does that is a positive is that it creates stable governments; stable governments in terms of no extremist leadership. Under the SMP the government, so the argument goes, is not hostage to vagaries of relying on small (often extremist) parties for legislative support (Farrell 2001, Electoral Systems, Pg.20). Another so-called positive of the SMP system is how long it has been used for specifically in Canada. SMP has been around since medieval times, meaning it is tried and true, therefore reliable.
In the SMP system voters are denied the representation they should be given as citizens of Canada. The winner-take-all style used by the SMP voting systems provides representation only for those voters who support the most popular party in their riding. Just 58.8 per cent of eligible voters cast a ballot in the 2008 federal election, the lowest in Canadian history (http://www.680news.com/federal-election/article/220853--harper-wins-majority-government-ndp-official-opposition). I believe this statistic is directly correlated with the belief that only a small amount of Canadian citizens views will be represented anyway so people have become reluctant to vote. The political thoughts of the additional voters are not represented at all. Alan C. Cairns defines this idea brilliantly. “Advocates of proportional representation base their arguments on democratic federalism. They simply argue that each vote should have equal weight and that the distortion of voter’s preferences by single member constituency systems is no more to be justified than the use of false scales by a butcher” (Cairns, The Electoral System and the Party System in Canada, Pg.55). Customarily the greater percentages of votes cast by voters go toward helping to elect no one. In the 2008 federal election 62.37% of votes went unused
Show More

Related Documents: Politics In Canada Paper

Declining Turnout In Canada

This paper will be looking at answering these two questions. Who or what is to blame for the declining turnout in Canadian federal elections? And, how serious is the problem? By using an Elections Canada article by Jon H. Pammett, and Lawrence LeDuc, a Samara democracy report by multiple authors, a book by Henry Milner, as well as information from Statistics Canada, and Elections Canada, I attempt to reveal the current major causes for the declining turnout in Canada. From these articles and my own…

Words 321 - Pages 2

Human Agency Inequalities In Canada

recently we have observed that the effects of human agency and the inequalities between varying agencies have a major impact. Inequalities within a society have arguably become one of the main determiners of agricultural productivity globally and within Canada. Various effects of human agency include adaptability, innovation, and a sense of individualism in individuals’…

Words 213 - Pages 1

Low Voter Turnout In Canada

may create an overall disinterest in politics and challenge our democratic system we currently have in place. Many Canadians “...fought long and hard for this right, overcoming gender, racial, religious, or administrative obstacles to ensure women, judges, persons with disabilities and…

Words 1611 - Pages 7

The Impact Of The Cold War

the twentieth century (Immigration and Population Statistics). Canada may not have been involved in the war as much as the U.S but they were in danger as well, and it defiantly changed Canada’s economy and politics in many ways. As you read this essay, you will learn about peace keeping, Canadian and U.S relations, and how the cold war changed Canada’s economy. Peace keeping is a very important aspect of Canada, and Canada has done major contributions towards the cold war and has always…

Words 1157 - Pages 5

Regionalism and Its Effect on the Canadian State Essay examples

defined as a political ideology grounded on a shared sense of place or attachment and is discussed in terms of Canadian society, culture, economy and politics.1 From the days of confederation, Canada has developed into regional cleavages and identities based on various geographical characteristics, traditional lifestyles and economic interests. Two of Canada`s greatest regionally distinct political cultures are known as Western alienation and Quebec nationalism.2 Historically, the lack of regional awareness…

Words 2230 - Pages 9

Voting In Canada

Every year Canada’s voter turnout decreases. Some citizens blame it on the younger generations disinterest for politics and pure laziness, others blame it on the cynicism within our electoral system and rightfully choose not to vote, and finally some blame it on the fact that our westminster system is out-dated and does not represent the views of every single individual. Recently, in the past 10 years there has been a push to change our electoral system within a couple province to the single-member…

Words 1729 - Pages 7

Trudeau's Argument Analysis

“Because it’s 2015” is what our new Prime Minister said when asked about his cabinet for his term.Trudeau wanted a “cabinet that represented Canada and that was gender balanced” (Global News). Trudeau knew that Canada was diverse and that today gender, race or age should not be a problem when hiring people for the position. Equality should not be as big of an issue as it is in 2015. The concept of minorities and visual minorities should not still be around, but it still is. This concept was put into…

Words 792 - Pages 4

Class cleavages Essay

Discussion Paper 1 How relevant do you think class & urban-rural divides will be in the future? In the context of Canadian society, both class and urban-rural cleavages will be subdued going forward. Firstly, the Canadian social and economic backdrop is grounded on compassion and prosperity (Brooks, 2012). On the economic front, Canada over the last decade has seen unemployment fluctuate between 6 to 9 percent. Using unemployment as a leading indicator for deep class stratification and perpetuated…

Words 1191 - Pages 5

Zine Ideal Culture

BrokenPencil is an independent arts, music and zine culture magazine in Canada. It is printed four times a year acts as an outlet for inquisitive minds to see a snapshot of what zine, chapbooks and literary articles are floating around the country. It also features unique editorials that call into question the nature of mainstream…

Words 1027 - Pages 5

Pro Conscription In Canada

Military, but at the height of World War I, there was no choice. In 1914, when the British Empire, including Canada, forcibly entered the war, Canadian citizens who felt ultimate pride in their country volunteered to help in the war effort. However, it was never enough to succeed (Morton, 2023). Conscription, which is the compulsory enlistment into expeditionary forces, took effect in Canada in 1917 due to the underwhelming number of men willing to participate in the front lines. Canadian Francophones…

Words 1591 - Pages 7