Poverty and Carnegie Essay

Submitted By dakotahl1

Words: 289

Pages: 2

Open Document

College Reading and Writing
Carnegie and Galbraith

Galbriath and Carnegie are basically opposites when it comes to Social Darwinism. Galbraith believes it’s an excuse to ignore poverty, whereas Carnegie believes it’s simply a part of nature. I can agree with certain points of both their arguments. Carnegie believes that it is the “survival of the fittest” was and still is true but I do still think with a certain amount of money poverty can be solved.
“The survival of the fittest” seems to be true because multi-million dollar companies seem to be there for a long time and don’t simply vanish. Due to the fact that most of them have very wealthy and smart leaders like Carnegie was. I think the ideas of both these men could be infused into diminishing poverty and making sure the rich’s money is spent the correct way. If the rich could be convinced that diminishing the percentage of those living in poverty would help the economy and therefore helping their own businesses, they would have no problem spending money towards helping improve those who live in poverty.
Even though Carnegie and Galbraith have different views on Social Darwinism and poverty both can likely be solved. Introducing Carnegie’s method of having the rich donate money with Galbraith’s wants to solving poverty may work. It’s the fact that they are opposites, which would make it work. If the rich were to be told that donating money towards solving poverty would help improve the economy, they would of

How Did Carnegie Contribute To The American Dream

to utilize the magnificent wonders of America. One immigrant, Andrew Carnegie, took total control of the American steel industry. Others such as J.P Morgan and John D. Rockefeller also monopolized industries but Carnegie stands out because he is an immigrant who saw the American Dream and utilized it greatly in his favor. So did Carnegie hinder the journey of others trying to utilize the American Dream or did he help it? Carnegie came over from the United Kingdom and worked very diligently. He made…

Words 1595 - Pages 7

Henry George Wealth Analysis

a million dollars?” This question concludes Henry George’s article, Progress and Poverty. George was a journalist who later became a reform figure. Progress and Poverty was an article about how wealth should be gained and what taxes should be collected. Andrew Carnegie, an immigrant turn American business leader, wrote The Gospel of Wealth (1889), an essay about how wealth should be distributed. George and Carnegie had different views about who wealth should be given to, how wealth should be given…

Words 530 - Pages 3

Gospel Of Wealth

texts, “The Gospel of Wealth” and “The Subtle Problem of Charity” were written by two vastly different authors, the monopoly owner and philanthropist Andrew Carnegie, and founder of a settlement house for the poor Jane Addams, but both texts focus on the inherent division in society and how charity should emerge from this division. Carnegie begins his entry by stating that the disparity between the millionaire and the laborer is a measure of how society has progressed and will continue to progress…

Words 467 - Pages 2

Biographical Essay: Andrew Carnegie's Life And Work

1835 was industrialist and philanthropist Andrew Carnegie (Biography.com Editors). He was raised by his mother, Margaret Morrison Carnegie and his father, William Carnegie. Andrew grew up with his brother Thomas in Dunfermline, Scotland, the center of the linen industry (American Experience). Carnegie’s father was a weaver, and his mother had owned a small grocery store in which she mended shoes at (American Experience). With that being said, the Carnegie family lived a happy stable life. It wasn’t until…

Words 510 - Pages 3

Why Is Andrew Carnegie Important

Andrew Carnegie was an industrialist who caused the expansion of the steel industry in the late nineteenth century. In 1853 he learned about business and investing as he worked as a superintendent for the railroads. Carnegie decided to invest his higher pay rather than spending it which allowed him to make connections with important men. When he decided to invest in steel because it was sturdy and lasted a long time, he learned of the Bessemer Process. Then in 1892, Carnegie established the Carnegie…

Words 685 - Pages 3

Carnegie Gompers Essay

Nick Battaglia Mr. Manelski CPUSH 9 8 March 2015 Andrew Carnegie Born in 1835, in the small coastal town of Dunfermline Scotland, Andrew Carnegie would later become one of the richest men on earth. If alive today, his fortune would be worth an estimated value of $309 billion dollars. Andrew was not born into wealth as one might guess. He was the son of a small business owner, who like many other small business owners, was forced to close their doors because of the rapid industrialization of the…

Words 1047 - Pages 5

Andrew Carnegie's Success

Prakash Tamang Ms. Kraus Andrew Carnegie The most richest man in the American history. Andrew Carnegie was from a poor family, he was born in 1835, Dunfermline, Scotland. He was twelve years when he came to United States as an immigrants. Andrew Carnegie was a hero because he was a leader for the country, give back to people, and a intelligent bussiman. Andrew Carnegie is great leader , because he shows how having a strong work ethic leads to success. He knew what was like to be poor. The difference…

Words 377 - Pages 2

Andrew Carnegie Essay example

Andrew Carnegie Andrew Carnegie, one of the captains of industry, helped build the steel industry of America which turned him into one of the richest entrepreneurs of his age. He had an ambition for riches which helped him on his path to becoming such a successful entrepreneur. His family fought to do away with inherited privilege and to bring about the rights of common workers. Carnegies impact with the steel industry was one of the most important innovations of the American industry.…

Words 354 - Pages 2

Compare And Contrast The Three Robber Barons During The Gilded Age

age. The poverty stricken the middle class and the wealthy. The political parties were all from the wealthy and the middle class. The “robber barons”, two major depressions and the labor unions were added to the gilded age. The three “robber barons” Andrew Carnegie, John S. Rockefeller, and J.P. Morgan were known as the three most powerful men in the time of the Gilded age. These three men didn’t develop their power and wealth calmly and by good means. Andrew Carnegie founded the Carnegie Steel company…

Words 134 - Pages 1

Andrew Carnegie In The Gilded Age: A Captain Of Industry

Andrew Carnegie arrived in America an impoverished immigrant but died a millionaire with more than a dozen beneficial public institutions under his name. How Carnegie built his way to riches and fame is what we discussed in our class trial. Although both redeeming and condemning aspects were present in Andrew Carnegie’s life, his attempts at safe factories, disconnection with the Homestead Strike, and philanthropic virtues ultimately make him a captain of industry whom did not break any official…

Words 634 - Pages 3