Essay about prisoner exchange

Submitted By Kyle-Moody
Words: 759
Pages: 4
Open Document
Prisoner exchange

Bowe Bergdahl was held in Afghanistan as a prisoner by an Islamic insurgent group since june 2009 when he reportedly walked away from his platoon. Shortly after allegedly leaving his fellow soldiers he was captured. Before the trade, Bergdahl was last seen in a Taliban video that they released to the US in decemeber of 2013 and his condition after the video was not know, though it was apparent that his hygiene, health, and mental stability all looked very poor. It is not clear whether he actually walked away, but recovered radio transmissions from the insurgent group reported that he was captured alone without any weapons, with no fellow soldiers in sight. Some sources state that before his decision to leave his unit, he wrote his parents saying how un-american he felt, and how he simply could not live the way he was any longer.
Many people are now arguing the case of desertation during a time of war, which holds a maximum penalty of death. Now the debate has begun to whether it can be considered desertation when neither president bush, nor president Obama has ever declared a “time of war” which upholds military code and justice. Congress also has never passed any declaration of war for Afghanistan.
A military law professor at yale said (3)"The command can say 'This fellow has been living in terrible conditions. We don't approve of what he did but we're not going to prosecute him,'" he said. "Or, the military could prosecute him as a way of signaling to others that 'Look, you can't simply go over the hill.' ... It's quite an interesting set of issues that will have to be addressed as a matter of both policy and law."
Bergdahls fate is now sitting on a very thin line and is resting soley on peoples biases, and what they have heard from the media. Every source has a slightly different view to the story. Some lean towards the fact that he’s been held in terrible conditions by people who hate americans for over 5 years, and others hold very tightly to military rules which not only legaly, but moraly forbid abandoning your fellow soldirs.
Exchanging 5 prisoners for Bergdahls return was excessive. Although he was thought to be the last Living POW, Dangerous terrorists back in the Middle East is exactly the opposite of what the United States has been working on since the war began in the first place. To me it seems like steps in the wrong direction were taken. The president always makes a point to say “we do not negotiate with terrorists”, but this exchange was clearly negotiated between the two parties. Forcefully retrieving him would have eliminated the exchange altogether, and kept the dangerous people from being freed back into their terrorist organization. Freeing a prisoner of war should be a top priority of the government and not organized as a trade, especially dealing with
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about prisoner exchange

Catherine Gourley's The Horrors Of Andersonville

during the Civil War which was from 1861 to 1865. Before fighting, neither side gave a lot of thought to the possibility of caring for large numbers of prisoners of war, and from 1861 on, prisoners suffered through difficult conditions in both the Union and Confederacy side. As the problem grew more harsher , the question exchanging the prisoners of war became increasingly sensitive which ultimately lead…

Words 2248 - Pages 9

Bergdahl Exchange Essay

Chris Tighe Charles Adside III Political Science 320 December 1, 2014 Constitutionality of President Obama’s Taliban Prisoner Exchange Section I: Introduction May 31st, 2014, what should have been a victorious day for the American government and people turned sour after politicians and citizens realized how we recovered Prisoner of War Bowe Bergdahl. After being held prisoner by the Taliban for nearly five years, Bergdahl’s health appeared to be deteriorating – as seen in Taliban propaganda videos…

Words 3044 - Pages 13

Andersonville Prison Research Paper

hold 10,000 prisoners and wounded soldiers. By August it held 45,000 soldiers. The prison was surrounded by a stockade of hewed pine logs that varied in height from 15-17 feet. They are planning by late June to enclose 261/2 acres. Each day the soldiers were fed only a teaspoon of salt, three tablespoons of beans, and eight ounces of cornmeal. The water they drink is used also as a sewer. Sometimes volunteers distributed bread and soup to the wounded. From these conditions prisoners suffered from…

Words 532 - Pages 3

Essay on Prison and Prison Society Course

CHAPTER 12 INCARCERATION AND PRISON SOCIETY Course Outline I. Introduction: The modern prison • Maximum security prisons prior to the 1950s was a massive wall institution • In the South the massive wall were less common as prisoners worked outside on large farms • The 1960s saw a move toward rehabilitation and “correctional institutions” • Since the 1970s minority representation has increased and gangs have raised the level of violence in prisons II. Goals…

Words 959 - Pages 4

Essay Sante Fe Prison Riot

in its past one July 19, 1922 and the other June 15, 1953, these however were nothing in comparison to the events to come. In the early morning hours of February 2, 1980 two prisoners began what would be recorded as one of the most violent prison riots in the history of the American correctional system. 33 prisoners died, over 200 inmates were injured and 12 correction officers were taken hostage of those 12, seven were badly beaten and raped. The causes of this riot were made…

Words 963 - Pages 4

Andersonville Prison Essay

Andersonville Prison It is conceivably considered to be one of the prisoner of war encampments that best illustrates the unpleasant and inhuman environments endured through the American Civil War. Of all of these constructed prisons during this time period, the most notorious was indubitably Andersonville. Andersonville was also known as Fort Sumter (Andersonville-American Civil War). Found in Sumter County, Georgia, Andersonville prison was primarily intended to house around 10,000 men. The…

Words 1181 - Pages 5

The Victory of the North in the Civil War Essay

the South was because the Union had more men to fight the war so they could afford to lose men. Grant knew this and knew it well, which is one of the key reasons he stopped the prisoner exchange. This meant that not only was the Confederacy loosing men to death but it also lost men to the prisons. With more and more prisoners coming in on both sides, the prisons had to hold more men and have more guards to increase to chances of preventing escapes. Again, with the Union's advantage in man power it…

Words 502 - Pages 3

Burleson Battle Analysis

battle lasted but eighteen minutes. The total number of deaths from the battle resulted in 639 with only nine deaths on the texans side and 630 on the mexicans side. Houston took a musket ball to the ankle during the fight. No texans were taken prisoner, but 730 were taken on the mexican…

Words 512 - Pages 3

Prisoner No. 8612 Research Paper

with Prisoner #8612. He began to suffer from acute emotional disturbances, disorganized thinking, and instances of uncontrollable crying and rage. The researchers, now also starting to mold into their characters, believed he was trying to con them and get them to release him. Prisoner #8612 was offered to become an informant for the guards in exchange for no harassment, and told to think it over. During the next count (which took place at 2:30 a.m.), Prisoner #8612 told the other prisoners, “You…

Words 650 - Pages 3

How Did The Mongols Cause Greater Cultural Destruction

and whether they caused greater cultural destruction or greater cultural exchange. They still caused some greater cultural exchange. I think the Mongols caused more cultural destruction. The reason for how they did a lot of bad things is that they killed a lot of people. They also sold a lot of stuff to other places, so they weren't all bad. One of the bad ways they killed people is a Mongol soldier killed their prisoners by shooting them with a bow or burying them upside down. In 1237 there was…

Words 317 - Pages 2