- Three basic attitudes behind progressive movements:
- Anger over the excesses of industrial capitalism and urban growth
- Emphasized social cohesion and common bonds to understand modern society
- Against social Darwinism
- Felt citizens needed to intervene to improve social conditions
- Progressives offered a combination of social justice and social control
Women Spearhead Reform
- Many middle class women supported the settlement house movement
- Reformers such as Jane Addams and Florence Kelley promoted female education
The Urban Machine
- Women had to work outside existing political institutions
- City politics had become a closed and corrupt system
- Machine politics - well organised, dominant political parties catering to specific voters
- Viewed their work as a business, served people who needed assistance
- “Honest Graft” - Making money from inside information on public improvements
- Timothy “Big Tim” Sullivan - embodied the machine politics style
- Gained votes by helping pass reforming legislature, eg. child labour laws, etc
Political Progressives and Urban Reform
- Political progressivism originated in the cities to challenge machine politics
- Governments hardly seemed capable of providing basic essential services
- “Good Government Movement” - led by the National Municipal League
- Fought to make city management a non-partisan process, like a large corporation
- Progressive politicans focused on changing policies, not the political structure
Progressive in the Statehouse
- “Wisconsin Idea” - The application of academic scholarship and theory to public needs
- Adopted by many states
- Western progressives displayed the greatest enthusiasm for institutional political reform
- The Initiative - allowed direct vote on an issue raised by petition
- The Referendum - allowed voters to decide on bills referred to them by the legislature
- These and other measures intentionally weakened political parties
- Southern populism = biracial policies - Southern progressivism = whites only
- Southern progressives supported black disfranchisement as a reform
- “Grandfather clauses” - uneducated whites could vote if their grandfather was able to
- Southern progressives pushed for fully segregated public areas
New Journalism: Muckraking
- Jacob Riis - How the Other Half Lives - first real exposé detailing poor living conditions
- Journals such as McClure’s began uncovering the bad side of American life
- Journalists included Lincoln Steffen (The Shame of the Cities) and Ida Tarbell (History of the Standard Oil Company)
- Exposure Journalism, as it was called, paid handsomely
- President Theodore Roosevelt coined the term “muckrakers” for these journalists
Intellectual Trends Promoting Reform
- Intellectual thinkers began challenging several core American ideas - this led to reforms
- L. F. Ward - Dynamic Sociology - said applying Soc. Darwinism to society was wrong
- Legal, educational and industrial reformers began speaking out against their fields
- Lochner v. New York - Judge Holmes ruled that a 10-hour day for bankers was wrong
- Holmes affected a new group of lawyers known as the “social jurisprudence”
- Edward A. Ross - Social Control - became a key phrase in progressive thought
- Argued that society needed an elite with the best interests of society at heart
Unifying Themes
- Three basic attitudes behind progressive movements:
- Anger over the excesses of industrial capitalism and urban growth
- Emphasized social cohesion and common bonds to understand modern society
- Against social Darwinism
- Felt citizens needed to intervene to improve social conditions
- Progressives offered a combination of social justice and social control
Women Spearhead Reform
- Many middle class women supported the