Pros And Cons Of Mandatory Minimum Sentencing

Words: 576

Pages: 3

Open Document

There has been a myriad of discussion and arguments on both sides of the aisle, when it comes to ideas and reform on minimum sentencing guidelines. Should judges be allowed to adjust sentences as they see fit, based on the totality of the circumstances of the case before them, or should each respective legislative body put strict guidelines in place that are not to be tampered with, leaving judges only a minimum of leeway one certain specific cases? There has been decisions made by the Supreme Court that upholds the idea that longer sentences do not violate the 8th Amendment protecting someone from cruel and unusual punishment, however there is still debate about if the practice of long-term prison sentences really is a good and sound criminal justice management idea (Larkin, 2014).

Historically, judges had virtually unlimited power to adjust sentences as they saw fit, based on whatever they decided at the time, with really no oversight (Larkin, 2014). However, in 1984 when Congress passed the Sentencing Reform Act, the reigns were pulled in tightly on judges, and the first guidelines on sentencing were used (Larkin, 2014). Congress also enacted various other types of mandatory minimum sentences on specific types of crimes, thus limiting the discretion of the …show more content…
This shift swung the power from the judges to the prosecutors (Larkin, 2014). “Judges may have to impose whatever punishment the law requires, but prosecutors are under no comparable obligation to charge a defendant with violating a law carrying a mandatory minimum penalty (Larkin)”. Furthermore, prosecutors have virtually all the power to decide exactly what to charge a person with, which allows them to essentially bargain with a person’s life, by dangling their freedom in front of them, and playing a game of Russian Roulette with regards to what charge they want to apply to the crime the suspect committed (Larkin,

Pros And Cons Of Mandatory Minimum Sentencing

Mandatory minimum sentencing has the most talked about lately in the criminal justice system. This sentencing has both positive and negative outlooks. Let’s start with the positive outlooks on how this sentencing is beneficial. Mandatory minimum sentencing address two of the world’s main acknowledged problem, sentencing disparity and unduly lenient sentences. Mandatory minimum sentencing guarantees that the sentencing fits the crime not the person. It is also said that, it prevents crime because…

Words 204 - Pages 1

Mandatory Minimum Sentencing Essay

society. Mandatory Minimum Sentencing in the American Justice System has long been argued by both Lawmakers and the public. We will go over some of the history of mandatory minimum sentences as well as the many pros and cons to these types of sentences. Some examples of pros and cons are the overall effect on public safety, the effect on the offenders, the cost to taxpayers, the lack of discretion for Judge’s, and whether the law should be repealed. The history of Mandatory Minimum sentencing laws…

Words 1979 - Pages 8

Kaplan Unit 3 Paper

Professor Condron December 10, 2012 In this assignment I will define indeterminate and determinate sentencing. I will also support an argument that will be effective for addressing a crime. Finally I will summarize my assessment of the sentencing models. Indeterminate sentencing is the legal…

Words 1494 - Pages 6

Adolescent Diversion Project

There are fourteen states in the U.S. that do not have a minimum age for trying children as adults, some children as young as eight have been prosecuted. Other states have set a minimum age of ten, twelve, or thirteen years old. In January 2001, Lionel Tate, a twelve-year old boy was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for the murder of a six-year old girl. Tate stated that he was imitating a wrestler, which he regarded as his hero, when he body-slammed, kicked, and knee-dropped…

Words 1149 - Pages 5

Summary: The United States Prison System

Every American taxpayer is a stakeholder in the United States prison crisis. The combined yearly cost of the corrections department (information gathered from only 40 states where numbers were available) is 39 billion dollars (Henrickson, 2012). This budget gives the United States the distinctive honor of having, “the costliest prison system in the world” (Lindorff, 2009) and causing American citizens to pay the most per capita for their prison system. The real cost, however, is even greater. This…

Words 1391 - Pages 6

Marijuana: Hemp and First-offense Marijuana Possession Essay

scenarios and list the pros and cons of both the legalization of marijuana or keeping it an illegal drug. In the 1600’s, American’s made hemp for rope, sails, and clothing. Marijuana is the mixture of dried, shredded flowers and leaves that comes from the hemp plant. In the early 1900’s, Mexicans fleeing to the United States, introduced the use of marijuana to the recreational use of the plant. By 1931, twenty nine states outlawed the use of marijuana. In 1951, stricter sentencing laws were put in…

Words 643 - Pages 3

The Three Strikes Law

Three Strikes Law 2 Three Strikes Law The Three Strikes Law has been a subject of much debate since its introduction as a regulation in 1993. The Three Strikes law was enacted in 1994 and is widely recognized as the harshest sentencing law in the United States. “The State of Texas was the first State to enact such a law in 1974.” (Laws.com) California passed its own law enacting a Three Strikes Law that mandates a sentence of 25 years to life for a third felony conviction.…

Words 1355 - Pages 6

Crime and New Law Essay

their records. These crimes, a particular list of offenses that count as “strikes,” include residential burglary, murder, attempted murder, rape, robbery and arson. An offender who already had one strike on his or her record would face double the minimum prison term once convicted of any new felony - not just those defined as strikes. In addition, the offender would have to complete 85 percent of the sentence before release from prison. An offender with two existing strikes on his or her record…

Words 6463 - Pages 26

Essay on Capital Punishment and Death Penalty Sentence

Death Penalty: Right or Wrong? Kimberley Houk COM 156 October 26,2014 Gina Greco Death Penalty: Right or Wrong? One main question regarding whether the United States should apply the death penalty as a form of punishment is a heated debate in American politics. The topic is so divisive because it deals with death, which is permanent. Life is valued in every society, and when life is taken away, emotions rise. Most human beings maintain a strong underlying fear of death, so they want…

Words 4332 - Pages 18

Business Law Final Essay

CHAPTER 5: INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY Intellectual Property: any property resulting from intellectual, creative processes – products of an individuals; mind Trademark: distinctive marl, motto, device, or emblem that a manufacturer affixes to the goods it produces so that they may be identified on the market and their origins made known (10 YEAR PERIOD – RENEWABLE) CASE 5.1 – Coca-Cola v. Koke Co. of America Koke can’t use the name because Coke was so common and well known, but Dope wasn’t an infringement…

Words 5985 - Pages 24