Purchasing Lessons For Schools Essay

Submitted By NhocDinhdinh1
Words: 1264
Pages: 6
Open Document
12

T H E M c K I N S E Y Q UA R T E R LY 2 0 0 3 N U M B E R 4

Purchasing lessons for schools
Brian Chapman and Chip W. Hardt

K E V I N C U R RY

Districts that improve their purchasing processes can capture significant savings.

Purchasing and supply management is rarely a top priority for school districts in the United States, but our research suggests that it should be. As a result of state budget crises, school districts are facing declining budgets for the first time in more than a decade.1 They are already struggling to meet stringent local and national guidelines for student achievement and to maintain their crumbling infrastructure. Better management of purchasing could help them make ends meet without compromising educational quality.
In our experience with school districts around the country—most recently with the Chicago Public Schools and the Puerto Rico2 Department of
Education—we found that bringing better discipline to purchasing and supply management can save school systems from 10 to 35 percent in many categories of nonpersonnel spending, including textbooks, transportation, food, and janitorial services. Annual savings in large urban school districts have ranged from $30 million to $40 million.
To achieve those sorts of figures, school districts need to examine their spending practices and to refocus on the original mandate of their central purchasing functions: saving money. Many of these departments have grown more concerned with filling out forms than with outcomes, and the result is that many departments have become inefficient bureaucracies that waste the taxpayers’ money and frustrate both teachers and school administrators.
School systems should ask two questions about every product and service they buy: “How much can we save by purchasing it centrally?” and “If it is complex, should the user—as opposed to central purchasing—buy it?”
1

School districts in Boston, Chicago, Los Angeles, and New York have seen their 2004 budgets fall by 2 to 12 percent from 2003 spending levels.

2

Puerto Rico, a self-governing commonwealth associated with the United States, is comparable to many large urban districts in size and management structure.

PURCHASING LESSONS FOR SCHOOLS

The answers can help determine whether each purchasing decision is made centrally or locally and what role the purchasing department should play (Exhibit 1).
Some commodities, including those provided by utilities and office supply companies, should be controlled centrally. The potential savings are huge, and it doesn’t really matter who is, say, the cell phone vendor or what type of copy paper a school system buys. For more specialized products, such as educational devices for hearing-impaired students, the right product is more important than the savings, and special-education staff members are the natural decision makers.

EXHIBIT 1

Who buys what?

Complexity of product

High

Critical items

Strategic items

Example: devices for hearingimpaired students

Example: capital-improvement programs, janitorial services, textbooks

Goal: quick turnaround, minimal disruption of day-to-day operations

Goal: maximum value

Natural owner: user’s department
Role of purchasing department : support for user’s department

Low

Natural owner: variable
Role of purchasing department : part of cross-functional team

Commodity items

Leverage items

Example: concrete for new construction Example: cell phone service, office supplies

Goal: efficiency of process, cost reduction

Goal: lowest price

Natural owner: variable

Natural owner: purchasing department

Role of purchasing department : leads sourcing (user’s department leads execution) Role of purchasing department : centralized purchasing, with no exceptions

Low

High
Savings potential

Identifying the role of the central purchasing department will also help determine how many people it requires. For items the department buys centrally, employees need to design product specifications, evaluate
Show More

Related Documents: Purchasing Lessons For Schools Essay

Econ Article Essays

MIAMI , Florida (Achieve3000, February 15, 2010). Every day after school, Phyllis Quach goes to a warehouse brimming with silk flowers, stuffed animals, and multifarious other gift items that her parents sell through their South Florida wholesale company. Helping with the family business allows the 17-year-old to learn valuable lessons about business finance. One such lesson is that a recession, like the one that has gripped the U.S., makes the challenging task of running a business even tougher…

Words 723 - Pages 3

Season Pass Research Paper

to be lower, the motivational question of buyers is, “What’s in it for me? How will I benefit by purchasing your pass as opposed to the next best resort?” A pre-determined snow resort must have rental equipment, ski and snowboard lessons as every buyer is not an intermediate and will be categorized into groups such as beginner, intermediate or advanced, gift cards and vouchers upon the purchasing of their season pass. For example, a seasons pass holder can receive vouchers for food service benefits…

Words 849 - Pages 4

State Children's Health Insurance Program

characteristics is the “Coordinated Approach to Child Health” curriculum. Based on the review of literature, the curriculum includes six lessons which consists of four components: classroom curriculum, physical education, child nutrition services program, and family involvement. Overall, the CATCH intervention program promotes physical activity, includes healthy food options at school and home, discourages the use of tobacco products, and provides a stimulating learning environment. The product may be remodeled…

Words 1564 - Pages 7

Mark Cuban Research Paper

Much like the scientist entrepreneur, a builder is someone who puts careful thought into the “practicality” of their ideas and is determined to cultivate a deep understanding of how things really work. However, unlike the scientist, a builder is also someone who is consistently prepared to capitalize on viable opportunities in an effort to scale their business to its greatest possible potential. If the builder group had a motto it would be, “the bigger, the better”, and few entrepreneurs embody…

Words 1691 - Pages 7

Tda 2.2 Explain How To Support Children And Young People's Performance

The overall purpose of the school is to better the life of its pupils by offering guidance and teaching as well as encouragement. I reviewed the reward policy under the guidance of headteacher, bringing in SPOT. This prize system drives pupils to try harder in school and be better behaved because they know all the positive things they do are being recognised and rewarded. I also implemented the stamps system and reviewed the point sanctions as a way of encouraging good behaviour. I like to remind…

Words 599 - Pages 3

A Lesson Before Dying

reservation has her two young children taken by the government because she could not understand a paper they had her sign. Throughout the two stories A Lesson Before Dying and “Lullaby”, both the main characters experience and witness firsthand extreme systemic racism and injustice, which have been apparent throughout history, and occur even to this day. In A Lesson Before Dying, Grant finds himself being asked by his Aunt Lou and close, family friend Miss Emma to help Jefferson “become a man” before his…

Words 801 - Pages 4

Essay on Manage Quality Customer Service

Private Schooling The first process is investigating why Parents would choose Private Schooling for their child/ren. The School would investigate the following. Investigate the needs of families in the local area. This does change depending on different areas. For example the fees and how much people in the local community are willing to pay and also see what the other schools in the area are charging. Look at the numbers of students in each class…

Words 2327 - Pages 10

Essay about Prince Sports Case Analysis

reviews. One way this could work against Prince is if there are any dis-satisfied customers they are able to leave reviews and feedback for possible new consumers to see, resulting in the loss of business. Many new consumers do review searches before purchasing a product or service on the web. Economic forces are based on the economy. If the economy is good it will work in favor for Prince. If consumers feel comfortable in the purchase of a new product that will only result in more purchases, and more…

Words 1377 - Pages 6

Warren Buffet Essay example

and the only son. Buffet began his education at Rose Hill Elementary School in Omaha. A career change with Warren's father in 1942, being elected into a four year term as one of the U. S House of Representatives caused the Buffett's to have to move to Fredericksburg, Virginia to be closer to his new job. Warren continued his elementary education and attended Alice Deal Junior High school and later graduated from Woodrow High School. As a child Warren wasn't a normal kid, he was able to calculate numbers…

Words 832 - Pages 4

Gun Control Essay

were killed by an assault weapon which led to the 1988 firearms amendment which banned assault style guns and the 1996 massacre of 16 school children brought a ban to hand guns in the U.K. Gun violence in the U.K. has dropped dramatically since the institution of these bans (rappler.com). Although Britain does not have the gun culture of America we could take lessons from the drop in gun deaths. The constitution declares that we all have a right to bear arms, but the ever expanding violence in our…

Words 1197 - Pages 5