Assess How Successfully Utilitarians Defend The Principle Of Utility From Criticism

Submitted By thenestjspark
Words: 1052
Pages: 5
Open Document
Assess how successfully utilitarians defend the principle of utility from criticism
Many writers have often said that the best way to start an essay is on a positive note. So, I’ll start by saying this is a very tough answer which I will never have a one hundred per cent (100% for those of you who have an OCD with regards to numbers being written as words), watertight answer to - so much for that advice eh? Oh well – I said ‘writers’, not ‘great writers’ and these are the same people who eat crisps in a bowl, have a container marked ‘biscuits’, eat pizza with a knife and fork (I’m not going to lie, I am scoffing my face whilst writing this!) and say essays should be formal – well, you’re not going to like what’s coming so be a good little angel and have a relaxing beverage … and don’t forget the coaster! Anyway, back to the subject, I will never have a perfect answer because in order for that to happen, I will need to know all utilitarian’s in the world – which I don’t. In fact, I only know two open utilitarian’s – who go by the names of Bentham (and before you ask, no he’s not a malleable piece of poultry! His first name was Jeremy which, to be fair does make you think of Jeremy Clarkson who can be described as a certain type of poultry!) and Mill (again, before you ask, his first name was not Wind, it was John! He did have a middle name though, but sorry, that wasn’t Wind either! It was Stuart.) Both of these men, between them, formed Utilitarianism. And it is their respective versions of Utilitarianism that have been scrutinised and criticised. The degree of success to which utilitarian’s have defended their belief and theory against criticism varies depending on which criticism it is up against along with the type of weapon a given utilitarian has at the time of challenge. To help you keep score of the occasions in which utilitarian’s succeed in defending their belief in their ethical theory and the occasions in which they do not, I will play referee and …. Well, keep score (I hope that you too, can feel the tennis analogy coming on!).
First set. Anti Murray to serve. (No? Come on! Anti Murray! ANTI Murray! Fine! Suit yourselves you miserable little ….. Feel free to finish that sentence with your own expletives!) A criticism of utilitarianism is that it can condone supposed wrongs such as lying and stalking (there’s my defence sorted!). The compiler of antiutilitarian arguments seldom deter from the most common line of argument when criticising Utilitarianism. The line of argument being to describe an event, say what is the necessary reaction for a utilitarian, show that action to be wrong or bad and then win the point. Seems good to me. 15 love! It is good, except one small detail, the event in question always seems to be some sort of far-fetched example that happens once every million years or, to put it into a modern context, the time it would take for Adele to turn a full 360 degrees (that’s a full circle for those of you who are rubbish at maths and just plain common sense.). 15 all. The defence of utilitarianism is simply that for the criticism to be true, such events would have to have a chance of occurring which they never will (I mean, have you seen Adele?) meaning that the criticism is actually not worth considering at all not least because Utilitarianism is used as a practical guide for real situations. An example that is often used against Utilitarianism is that of a ‘Peeping Tom’ (need I explain?) who stares at a woman getting dressed without her ever finding out. According to Utilitarianism, Tom could peep all he wanted as his pleasure was being increased and no pain was being caused to the woman as she did not know. But, the defence aforementioned is applied because in the real world, such people are caught and their victims suffer. A defence of Act Utilitarianism (J.S. Mill’s Utilitarianism) would be that he would never justify the
Show More

Related Documents: Assess How Successfully Utilitarians Defend The Principle Of Utility From Criticism

Essay Learning Styles and Vark Analysis

involves a learning curve to which individuals follow. One common assessment used to establish a person's learning style is known as the VARK Analysis. VARK is an acronym for visual, auditory, reading/writing, and kinesthetic learners. This assessment is done online and will compile information on how a person answers a series of questions. Students and teachers will use this assessment to aid in better study habits. At the end of the assessment it will prompt a learning style type based off the questions…

Words 584 - Pages 3

Ebp In State Sentencing And Corrections

One of the most important practices taking place today in state sentencing and corrections is the use of EDP. The initial meaning of EBP, which stands for Evidence-Based Practice, was used for the practice of medicine, but was later adopted by many other fields such as education, child welfare, mental health, and criminal justice. EBP is a practice that when approached can be tested in controlled experiments and then be proven correct through the experiments, which implies that there is a set outcome…

Words 209 - Pages 1

Scope Of Practice Essay

M4D1 Scope of Practice Choose one of the six (6) ANA Standards of Practice and describe how the practice of an RN is different from your current role in healthcare The American Nursing Association (ANA), Scope and Standards of Practice, were created as a way to define and set boundaries along with setting clear limitations for the roles of the Registered Nurse and Licensed Practical Nurse. The six (6) ANA Standards of Practice are assessment, diagnosis, outcome identification, planning, implementation…

Words 563 - Pages 3

Differeniated Strategies Essay

those more advanced and ask easier questions for beginners. After the lecture is complete, students can pair up to “re-teach an idea or concept to struggling learners” (Tomlinson, 2012). Providing visual aids, recording class discussions and allowing the advanced students to re-teach the ideas or concepts to struggling learners, students are actively participating in class. The re-teach concept uses the strengths of some students while helping other students learn and relate to the concepts being…

Words 1913 - Pages 8

Notes On Western Civilization

Inside Assessments your on-line exams will appear. Once you access the on-line exams, you have to finish within 50 minutes or you lose one point for each minute over time. Three are non-proctored exams, on the honor system, but also coming out of a random question pool. You cannot use notes or books. It cannot be printed out, only electronically submitted to Blackboard. If the connection is broken by your browser or ISP, TELEPHONE ME AT HOME (850-244-3240) and I can re-set it one time. After…

Words 334 - Pages 2

Essay on Management and In-class Activities

Course Documentation Outline School of Business, Biosciences and Justice Studies SECTION I 1. Program : Business Administration 2. Course Name: Business Management 1 3. Course Code: BUSI 2000 4. Credit Value: 4 credit 5. Course Hours: 42 hours Class | Lab | Field | Other | Total | 42 | | | | 42 | 6. Pre-requisites/Co-requisites/Equivalent Courses PR/CO/EQ | Course Code | Title | None | None | None | 7. Faculty:…

Words 5021 - Pages 21

Relational Model and Assessment Criteria Essay

intended study without prior written permission from St Patrick’s College. Remember to keep evidence of your submitted coursework. Unit Outcomes being assessed by this coursework: |Outcomes |Assessment criteria for pass | | |To achieve each outcome a learner must demonstrate the ability to: | |1 |Understand data models…

Words 1419 - Pages 6

Marketing Mix Essay

BELFAST METROPOLITAN COLLEGE BTEC NQF HIGHER NATIONAL ASSESSMENT FRONT SHEET School: Applied Sciences, Hair and Beauty Course: HND Beauty Therapy Sciences Assessment Set By: Sarah Hamill Date: February 2013 Assessment Validated By: Paula McAnearney Date: February 2013 |Name: Martina Mc Atamney |Date Issued: |Grading criteria attainable within this assignment( | | |11/03/13…

Words 842 - Pages 4

unit 3 Essay

Unit 3 Assessment Assessment You should use this file to complete your Assessment. The first thing you need to do is save a copy of this document, either onto your computer or a USB drive Then work through your Assessment, remembering to save your work regularly When you’ve finished, print out a copy to keep for reference Then, go to www.vision2learn.com and send your completed Assessment to your tutor via your My Study area – make sure it is clearly marked with your name, the course title…

Words 2965 - Pages 12

Assessment and Quality Assurance Essay

Training, Assessment, Quality Assurance (6317) Qualification Information Policy Statement It has come to our attention that the acronym 'TAQA' has been adopted by a private training provider as their company name. The TAQA acronym has been used by City & Guilds since early in 2010 to represent the group of Training Assessment and Quality Assurance qualifications which were launched in September 2010. City & Guilds has no relationship with the training provider and does not in any way endorse their…

Words 1201 - Pages 5