Research Argument: Standardized Testing Gets F

Submitted By robertjames83
Words: 1923
Pages: 8
Open Document
Robert James
1 December 2014
Engl 101.2132
Essay 3: Research Argument
Standardized Testing Gets an ‘F’ Standardized testing seems pretty harmless. Straightforward, inexpensive, neat, fair. But students have grown so accustomed to taking multiple-choice tests to prove themselves that people don’t bother to question the tests’ validity. In truth, these tests are meritocratic tools that affect us all, from the day we enter kindergarten to when we might apply for college or a job. It is even a pervasive influence in the workplace. Ability is judged from meaningless tests of “aptitude,” regardless of proven ability to do the work, get the grades, or accomplish remarkable things. The results of such tests tell precious little about competence. They merely measure one’s ability to perform well on tests. As a college student, and aspiring teacher, I refuse to accept that this is the only way students can be evaluated. Young minds are active and eager, but these tests are boring and kill creativity. Each and every one of us learns in our own way, so why enforce a “standard” that encourages a crippled curriculum. Teachers have become little more than mouthpieces for their school boards, reduced to “teaching the test” in order to maintain some semblance of learning. If students perform poorly, that teacher is scrutinized for lack of performance. In the end, this results in a weakened classroom environment in which teachers are robotic and withdrawn and students are less invested in learning. No other nation tests as much as the United States. The politicization of education has been no help. Many worry that the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 and Common Core State Standards will perpetuate a culture of over-testing. Fortunately, parents, educators, and policymakers are beginning to understand that many have bought into a view that learning, teaching, and even intelligence can be indexed by a single yardstick. The New York City Council, for example, is backlashing against standardized testing, “saying a reliance on those tests is ‘undermining educational quality and equity in public schools’” (Bidwell para. 12). Simplistic thinking in which there are only right and wrong answers can be replaced and students and schools can be assessed by what they can actually do on activities that really matter. School curriculums that rely upon standardized tests limit students’ ability to think deeply and creatively and constrain teachers to a mechanical form of instruction. So to create a more effective learning environment, state school boards should adopt performance-based evaluations and allow teacher judgments based upon student observation. These needs have been translated by journalists, educators, and education-related field experts for years. Some, like Peter Sacks, truly understand the plight plaguing our schools. While he does not work in academia, his career in independent journalism has granted him unbiased insights into the troubles standardized testing has presented. With nearly three years of research under his belt, including testimonies from educators and testing experts, Sacks’ book Standardized Minds seeks to inform the public about the limitations and effects of testing where educators had failed. Sacks recommends “that true reform of our schools must include a revolution in the way we measure children and in the very meaning of what schooling should be” (3). His usage of the term “revolution” suggests a radical shift in the way we are currently assessing student performance. However, other experts, like Michelle Rhee, disagree with the anti-testing camp. An educator herself, Rhee professed that to prevent children from participating in state-mandated standardized tests is tantamount to social anarchy. In her Washington Post article “Opting Out of Standardized Tests? Wrong Answer,” Rhee thinks that parents are endangering the education process by keeping their children away from these tests. Parents are beginning to become
Show More

Related Documents: Research Argument: Standardized Testing Gets F

James E Crisp Essay

Sleuthing the Alamo Davy Crockets last stand and other mysteries of the Texas revolution one has to applaud James E. Crisp and his dedication of unlocking the past and where Crisp investigates the fallacies and myths by exploring and decrypting and putting the puzzle together by researching the work of others like the de la Pena’s diary or the master thesis of Edward William Bartholomae in James E Crisp search for truths regarding the Texas revolution regarding Sam Houston’s speech was the Texas revolution…

Words 476 - Pages 2

Jamestown Project book review Essay

“The Jamestown Project,” Kupperman encloses the four hundredth year anniversary of Jamestown. To revisit the view of England to the New World, one hundred years behind they’re enemy’s the Spain. This paper will analyze Kupperman’s article with arguments, viewpoints, and examples to express the reason on how Jamestown survived through trial and error to stay a colony today. This book will surprise readers looking to delve immediately into the adventures of Captain John Smith and the other English…

Words 1221 - Pages 5

Essay on A Comparison of W.K Clifford and William James's Arguments on the Right of Belief

Clifford and James Summaries of W.K. Clifford and William James’s arguments for belief | In this paper, I hope to effectively summarize W.K Clifford’s (1879) argument on the ethics of belief, followed by a summary of William James’ (1897) argument on the right to believe, and finally, provide an argument for why W.K Clifford’s (1879) argument is stronger by highlighting its strengths while simultaneously arguing against William James’ (1897) argument. According to Clifford (1879), there…

Words 2520 - Pages 11

National Collegiate Athletic Association and College Football Essay

SP15467 Ms. James Eng 106 Final In Buzz bissinger’s article “why college football should be banned” Bissinger and author Malcolm Gladwell argue in favor of a ban on college football. The core of Bissinger’s argument is financial: athletic departments annually dump millions of dollars into football teams at the expense of university students and other athletic programs. Bissinger also talks about how college football exploits athletes who don't benefit. Bussinger claims the sport is too dangerous…

Words 417 - Pages 2

Scientific Revolution Dbq

In addition, the opposition cites evidence from "James Cook". The author maintains that James Cook had set new standards for thoroughness in discovery and seamanship in navigation, cartography, and the sea are of men ("James Cook." Britannica School. Encyclopedia Britannica). This research attempts to prove that James Cook was such a great naval captain because he discovered the island of Hawaii on accident while trying to find the…

Words 905 - Pages 4

Citation and Final Project Essay

Kaplan University CM 220 Section X James Mason July 31st 2012 Unit 4 Project: Reflecting on Sources Complete all three parts of the worksheet below. Be sure to cite all sources in APA format, including using in-text citations and reference page citations in the spaces provided. The writing should be in Standard English and complete sentences. The sources noted in this worksheet should be related to your "big idea," which is the basis of your final project in this course. Save this document…

Words 1158 - Pages 5

Bergen Community College: Composition And Literature Department

the opportunity for extensive practice in critical reading and thinking, and academic essay writing. This course emphasizes the writing process and concentrates on the organization and development of ideas in written form. Correct language usage, research skills, and document presentation are covered. Particular attention is given to writing about the texts students have read and the integration of primary and secondary sources into their writing for the purpose of supporting a thesis. The prerequisite…

Words 2297 - Pages 10

Religious Experience Essay

i) Analyse the essential ideas in the argument for the existence of God based on religious experience. A religious experience is a non-empirical encounter with the divine, which often makes the individual feel as though there is something beyond our physical being. They have thus long been the foundation for religious belief as they offer personal evidence for the existence of God. Religious experiences present a tremendous challenge to philosophers who may in turn attempt to offer an alternate…

Words 1782 - Pages 8

Citation and Essay

Essay Writing Guide (Credit also to Natalya Hughes, Lawson Fletcher, James Meese and Raya Massie) An essay is a persuasive piece of writing. That means it must have an argument. All of the advice below is oriented towards this basic definition. Submission and Presentation Keep the assignment within the one document. Just start a new page for each section. Cover sheet should precede every digital essay, within the file – it’s no different to a physical one. The essay should be formatted as such:…

Words 2832 - Pages 12

Media Coverage Of Women's Sports

“More people watched the women’s FIFA World Cup on TV than ever before… (Bianco, 2015).” “The final game, U.S. against Japan, drew the highest metered market rating ever for a soccer game in the U.S. airing on a single network [Fox Sports], with a total audience of 20.3 million viewers (The Tucker Center for Research in Girls & Women in Sports Scholars, 2015).” If 12million people tuned in to watch the women’s World Cup on Fox Sports, one would think that…

Words 966 - Pages 4