Research Paper on the Pentagon Papers Case

Words: 1649
Pages: 7
Open Document
Albo 1
Harrison Albo
Mrs. Knotts
3 English H
February 27, 2012
The Pentagon Papers Case
In the past, there has always been conflict between the free press and the government. This conflict was very evident in the Pentagon Papers case, also known as New York Times Co. v. United States. Historically, the Supreme Court has disagreed on the limitations that can be placed on the First Amendment. The Supreme Court faced these issues in the case of The New York Times. The newspaper obtained a copy of a Defense Department report that explained government deception in the Vietnam War. The Pentagon Papers emerged when the American people disagreed on the United States involvement in the war. Under the First Amendment, The New York Times argued …show more content…
The lawyers only had approximately twenty hours to prepare their oral arguments and briefs. On June 30, 1971, only five days after the case started, the Supreme Court issued its decision.
The Supreme Court ended up with a 6-3 vote against a prior restraint affecting the publication of the Pentagon Papers. Justices Burger, Blackmun, and Harlan objected and Justices Black, Brennan, Douglas, Marshall, Stewart, and White agreed. The per curiam of the verdict as seen on a website document, states: Any system of prior restraints of expression comes to this Court bearing a heavy presumption against its constitutional validity. Therefore, the government carried a heavy burden of showing justification for the imposition of such a restraint. The District Court for the Southern District of New York, in The New York Times case, and the District Court for the District of Columbia and the Albo 5 Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, in The Washington Post case, held that the Government had not met that burden. We agree. (Bruce, par.2) The brief opinion reflected the wide range of views of the nine judges. The Court could not come to agreement on a standard for determining how the government should handle prior restraint in subsequent
Show More

Related Documents: Research Paper on the Pentagon Papers Case

Trust in Government Essay

Research Essay Before November 22, 1963, even though the United States had many negative incidents in the past, a majority of the American people still had their faith in the government. There were no protests about war, chaotic outbreaks, or any type of argument that the Government wasn’t doing its job. In fact, over 75 percent of Americans had total confidence for their government (Marshal). The reason Americans felt this way is because Eisenhower was a former General of the U.S. Army, and…

Words 2118 - Pages 9

Essay on A 20Beautiful 20Mind

A Beautiful Mind For this review paper I am going to analyze the 2001 movie A Beautiful Mind based on the real-life story of John Nash. John Nash was born on June 13, 1928, in Bluefield, West Virginia. The setting of the film took place in Princeton University in Princeton, New Jersey, in 1950 and in the Massachusetts Institute of technology in Cambridge from 1951 to 1959. A Beautiful Mind illustrates many of the topics relating to psychological disorders. The main character of the film is John…

Words 1516 - Pages 7

Essay on CN REPORT

of communnication. It can be thought of as an unlimited way of storing and sharing information between people, corporations, or govrments. The idea of Internet was first developed by the Advanced Research Projects Agency or ARPA of the US Department of Defense. ARPA, which was a group under the Pentagon, had an objective to build a network that would allow scientists at different locations to share their information and work together on military and scientific projects. The network was called ARPANET…

Words 1420 - Pages 6

Why Do Government Use Drones?

control. “In 2007 FAA issues a policy statement prohibiting the use of drones for commercial purposes (Gent).” Since then, the commercial use of drones has only belonged to the government or any agency that government allows. The reason behind this case is that people can use it for bad purposes such as delivering drugs, entering into illegal areas, or tracking anything that has the illegal use. On the other hand,…

Words 1001 - Pages 5

Essay Case Study

Case Study: "Sony Reels From Multiple Hacker Attacks" Abstract The purpose of this paper to answer the questions purposed in writing assignment 6. The first question involves the hacking of the Sony PSN and the effects this has on organizations. The second question involves whether it is even reasonable to assume that organizations can have protection measures in place to stop the world’s best hackers. The third question involves whether or not hackers should be prosecuted and sent to jail.…

Words 1953 - Pages 8

Female and Women Essay

Reading Response Paper #1 When I first realized I needed to take a communications course this semester and I started looking through my options, this course and it’s description caught my eye. After reading the description and thinking about it for a few days I came to the conclusion that there was no way I knew as much as I thought I knew and wanted to take this particular course. When I got the syllabus and began reading the text and the first few reading assignments, I realized quickly that I…

Words 2612 - Pages 11

United States and New York City Essay

Chrystal Tuigamala Professor Patsy Iwasaki ENG 100T 3 December 2014 Research Paper Should we be more concerned with threats from abroad or from threats from within? America as a country is known throughout the world as quite powerful. Other countries are somehow threatened by this power, therefore they want to take control of the many benefits that America has especially the right to freedom. America welcomes people of all ethnic backgrounds, and it is very possible that some of these people may…

Words 1228 - Pages 5

Social Media In The Military Essay

Army Online Conduct & Social Media Their Effects on the Military The usage and effects of social media, in its many forms, are vast and widespread, both within our country as well as internationally. Websites and mobile applications, allow their social media users to share content and communicate over worldwide networks. “The number of social media users in 2018 is 3.196 billion, up 13 percent year-on-year.” (See Appendix for Global Digital Report 2018). With such popularity and social acceptance…

Words 1454 - Pages 6

Spanky's Web Essay

This paper will relate economic and political events to current trends in the human services field. Identify demographic trends that influence future needs in the delivery of human services. The team will focus on the North, South, East, West of the USA, and Military serving in foreign lands for our collection of data for this paper. East One major trend in the East coast that has affected Human Services professionals is the Terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001 (9/11). There is no doubt that…

Words 2111 - Pages 9

North Korea: Nuclear Friend or Foe? Essay

weapons, further nuclear research, and pursue other nuclear-related projects, this can be very real. It might happen in ten years, a few months, or even – tomorrow. The issue of nuclear proliferations is an issue of much concern by the United States. Since its creation back in the 1940s through the Manhattan project, the atomic bomb has been the bane of society, in terms of the level of potential threat it holds for the international community. The focus of this paper looks at U.S. policy towards…

Words 2258 - Pages 10