Return of Martin Guerre Essay

Words: 933
Pages: 4
Open Document
Starting with the premodern society and moving on to our modern society I will compare and contrast the two societies.

In the film The Return of Martin Guerre, the people lived on a pre modern society. They lived in a agricultural society and this was shown by many reasons. First they had permanent homes and used animals as well as tools to work their crops. They also used a crop rotation instead of burning the land. This is just a basic outline of the society that Martin lived in. Looking deeper into their social structure their society was much different than a modern one. As far as statuses and roles, Martins society believe that status was more ascribed than achieved. This meant that being an older person or a parent meant you …show more content…
Less of you status is ascribed and more of it is achieved by doing things like going to school where you mainly encounter the secondary group. The status set is also much larger than before and role conflict does arise more often.

In a modern society there is also a big difference in group interaction. Unlike pre modern society which dealt with the primary group, the secondary group plays a major role in the lives of people living in a modern society. As mentioned above about family and school, a majority of our life in an information society involves dealing with people in the secondary group to achieve our goals.

There is also a large difference in specialization in a modern society. In Martins village each person had a similar job and shared experiences. In a modern society work is highly specialized and we rely on each other to do the jobs that were once done by only a few people. Things like building homes and growing food now come from entirely different sectors of our society. All of this is termed organic solidarity.All these specialized jobs are essential to our survival.

Finally, I will explain the differences between social personality. Unlike Martins gemienschaft, there is another term called gesellescaft to describe a modern society's personality. It basically means stranger and in essence that is what the society deals with daily strangers. In a
Show More

Related Documents: Return of Martin Guerre Essay

Return Of Martin Guerre Analysis

The Return of Martin Guerre is about peasant life in the 1540’s and concerns the disappearance of the wealthy Martin Guerre for eight years. Martin leaves his wife Bertrande behind and after eight years he returns to her or does he. The real Martin does not return but an imposter, Arnaud de Tilh or Pansette. De Tilh and Bertrande live together for three years before the story begins to unravel and de Tilh is put on trial for impersonating Guerre. With Bertrande’s backing, there is speculation that…

Words 477 - Pages 2

The Return Of Martin Guerre Analysis

The Return of Martin Guerre - by Annabelle Krueger The story of Martin Guerre is said to be a true one, but the only real proof are two old books, one by Judge Jean de Coras and one by Guillaume La Sueur. In the film from 1982 a poor peasant, named Martin Guerre, encounters problems consumating his marriage with his Bertrande, only after the priest of his village, Artigat, had to perform an exorcism to get rid of his 'demons'. After Martin Guerre's father accuses him of stealing from him he abruptly…

Words 361 - Pages 2

The Return Of Martin Guerre Analysis

The Return of Martin Guerre According to Zemon Davis, Bertrande de Rols was a willing accomplice to Arnaud du Tilh’s crime of deception and fraud. In The Return of Martin Guerre, she questions Bertrande’s role in the Martin Guerre case. She accuses Bertrande of knowing that the new Martin Guerre was not her husband, but a stranger claiming to be the man she was married to. On the contrar, in the telling of the Martin Guerre case in Arrest Memorable by judge Jean de Coras, Bertrande is innocent…

Words 1426 - Pages 6

The Return Of Martin Guerre Analysis

Holberg International Memorial Prize and National Humanities Medal, and been named Companion of the Order of Canada. Daniel Vigne is a French author and director. Born in Moulins, Allier, France, in 1942, he is best known for The Return of Martin Guerre (1982), One Woman or Two (1985) and Fatou la Malienne…

Words 1951 - Pages 8

Essay Book Report 1

Civilizations 1102 9 September 2010 Book Report 1: The Return of Martin Guerre In the book, The Return of Martin Guerre, Sanxi Daguerre moves his family to Artigat because he was the heir to his father’s land. He and his family start their lives and later have a son by the name of Martin. Martin later gets married to his wife Bertrande. He and his wife live with the struggle of not being able to have children, but soon his wife bears him a son. At this time, Martin fleas the city of Artigat and disappears. His…

Words 1306 - Pages 6

Persepolis: Fraud and Graphic Novel Essay

read a book called The Return of Martin Guerre and a graphic novel, Persepolis. They both dealt with this issue of fulfilling society’s needs or wants. In The Return of Martin Guerre and Persepolis characters are confined to society's expectations of how they present themselves and how they are allowed to behave. I will include more details in this letter! In the book, The Return of Martin Guerre a man pretends to be Martin Guerre while the real Martin is at war. He returns to their town and everyone…

Words 417 - Pages 2

The Great Cat Massacre Summary

well as the written sources to look at various aspects of life and class in pre-revolutionary France. Each new chapter focused on a higher social class with fewer people being represented. Similar to the case of Natalie Zemon Davis’s The Return of Martin Guerre, Darnton believed it was possible to use folktales, events, and other written artifacts to “read” and understand the psychology of the people of France during the pre-revolutionary…

Words 1130 - Pages 5

Essay on Theater: Musical Theatre and American Composer

info)- setting, character history/relationship, character names, costumes, background 3. Conflict- “plot holds suspenseonly when it holds alternatives and choices” a. Inciting incedent od pragmatic question b. Tipping point or crisis- point of no return c. Climax- greatest tension d. Denouement/ falling action- how story ends, wrap-up e. Criticism Acting Internal vs External Stanislavski- father of realistic acting, started Moscow Art Theater, associated with Chekhov, realistic acting Zadacha-…

Words 4139 - Pages 17