Roe V. Wade: The Oral Argument For Abortion

Words: 540

Pages: 3

Open Document

The abortion debates began in 1973, when Roe v. Wade created an upheaval nationwide. Many states openly defined Roe while others, such as Pennsylvania, sought to circumvent Roe by imposing procedural hurdles upon women seeking abortions. The oral argument for Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992) began on 22 April 1992 with Kathryn Kolbert representing Planned Parenthood of Southern Pennsylvania. Kolbert argued that the provisions in the Pennsylvania Abortion Control Act of 1982 violated the decision made in Roe v. Wade that the right to an abortion was fundamental. If the fundamental right to abortion were to be removed, women would be forced to back alleys to receive abortions which would be detrimental to the women’s life and health. She also …show more content…
The act was comprised of four provisions that restricted the fundamental right a woman had to obtaining an abortion. The four provisions included spousal notification, information disclosure, a twenty-four-hour waiting period, and parental consent for minors. It was also a requirement that all Pennsylvania abortion clinics report themselves to the state. These provisions were challenged by several abortion clinics and physicians. The U.S. District Court of Eastern Pennsylvania declared all the provisions to be unconstitutional when a suit was brought forward by five abortion clinics and a physician before the provisions went into effect. However, the State Court of Appeals reversed this decision claiming that all provisions except the spousal notification were indeed constitutional. Planned Parenthood of Southern Pennsylvania then appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. Nonetheless, they decided that the bulk of the Pennsylvania law was constitutional. The Court first declared that a women’s decision to get an abortion was protected from state interference by the Constitution’s Due Process Clause. The Court also rejected parts of Roe,

Roe V. Wade Case Study

Roe v. Wade I chose my second case, Roe v. Wade because it is one of the most referenced cases that I know in regards to abortion and the rights of women. The Constitutional question was… Do women have a right to terminate her pregnancy by abortion? The case actually had three appellants. Jane Roe was a pregnant unmarried Texas woman that wanted to terminate her pregnancy via abortion. The other complainants were a married couple, John and Mary Doe, also from Texas. At the time, Texas law only allowed…

Words 1676 - Pages 7

Abortion and Current Government Affairs Essay

Should legislation continue supporting the trimester system for abortion? Right now in current government affairs, the three trimester of abortion is separated in three different levels of abortion. In the first trimester, the woman can have a choice between surgical abortions or an oral pill that terminates the pregnancy. The two medical procedures that are used in the first trimester are called Methotrexate (MTX) which is used during the first seven weeks and the other procedure is called mifepristone…

Words 1427 - Pages 6

Furman V. Georgia

4. (20 points). Describe the facts, rulings and reasoning of the Supreme Court decisions in Furman v. Georgia and Gregg v. Georgia respecting whether or not the imposition of the death penalty is a “cruel and unusual punishment” in violation of the Eighth Amendment Furman V Georgia, was a Supreme Court decision that had to do with the requirement for a degree of consistency in the application of the death penalty. In this case a man woke up in the middle of the night to find a burglar named William…

Words 1504 - Pages 7

The Right To Life Essay

Abortion: The Right To Life Professor Zuluaga November 15th, 2012 By: Katelyn Davis Katelyn Davis November 12th, 2012 English 101- Professor Zuluaga Research Paper- First Draft Abortion: The Right To Life Abortion has undoubtedly become to a controversial social issue that's affecting our society today. It is without surprise that most American citizens feel that abortion…

Words 1816 - Pages 8

Samuel Alito Supreme Court Justice Paper Moot Court

Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization). He argues against the viability line, highlighting the fact that a woman who is not yet at “viability” nonetheless wants to end her pregnancy both before and after the line has been crossed. So, is it truly unconstitutional that the State determines the line on a state-by-state basis instead of having one accepted line for the entirety of the nation? Furthermore, Alito questions the Respondents in Dobbs regarding common law, stressing that abortion is not…

Words 2886 - Pages 12

Santo wk5 Abortion Arguement Essay

An Abortion Argument Monica Santo PHI 103 Instructor Cornell Horn September 30, 2013 An Abortion Argument Abortion is a hot issue in the United States today. Abortion is currently legal in all 50 states however; some states have a 20-week ban law. This law bans all abortions after 20 weeks of a woman’s last menstrual period and only allows for exceptions in cases where a woman’s life is threatened. Folks on both sides of the isle on the abortion issue are extremely passionate about their views…

Words 1554 - Pages 7

Bowers V. Hardwick Case Study

There will be two cases reviewed in this paper to obtain a better understanding of the what caused the U.S Supreme Court to abandon the rule of stare decisis in the Lawrence v. Texas and Bowers v. Hardwick cases. It has been said that societal factors may have been the primary contributor to the decision that were made in the courts at the time (U.S. Supreme Court, n.d). The act that were being argued within the courts were highly frowned upon during the era. So was the U.S Supreme Court decision…

Words 1446 - Pages 6

13th Amendment Dbq

freedmen and employers were to be addressed only by the local courts (Fleischman, 106). Decades after the ratification of the Fourteenth Amendment, a case regarding racial segregation and inequality was finally heard in the Supreme Court. In Plessy v. Ferguson (1896), Plessy—a man who was 1/8 black — argued that that the Separate Car Act that required him to sit in a sperate railway car was a violation of the 14th Amendment (under the Equal Protection Clause), which prohibits “restrictive legislation…

Words 1532 - Pages 7

Clarence Thomas Research Paper

Justice Clarence Thomas, a quiet role model within the American legal system, having served on the Supreme Court since his appointment by George H.W. Bush, in 1991, in the United States. Often, he is regarded as one of the most mysterious justices as he takes a more conservative approach during cases. Thomas' impact on constitutional interpretation and legal precedent echoed through the highest court in the land. Beyond his judicial duties, Thomas' personal journey and his bond to originalism have…

Words 2756 - Pages 12

Analysis Of Supreme Court Cases

CRIMINOLOGY 13 CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS FALL SEMESTER, 2014 COURSE SYLLABUS CLASS SECTIONS Section Number Days/Times Room 29760 MWF; 8:00 – 8:50 OAB 271 29761 T – Th; 8:00 – 9:20 OAB 271 COURSE DESCRIPTION This course will focus on the analysis and evaluation of notable Supreme Court cases, together with an examination of the logic and interpretive reasoning used by its justices in making constitutional judgments. Emphasis will be placed on the historic protection of individual…

Words 7388 - Pages 30