Role of Magistrates & Jury in England & Wales Essay

Words: 1956
Pages: 8
Open Document
This essay will discuss the role of the magistrate and jury in the English and Welsh legal decision-making process. It will assess both the advantages and disadvantages of both mechanisms and give an opinion on the contribution they make in the process.
The role of a lay magistrate is one that is at the core of the legal system in England & Wales. They help maintain the foundation of the criminal justice system and deal with approximately 98% of all criminal matters. The sheer volume of cases that they deal with has helped earned them the title of the workhorses of the criminal justice system.
A magistrate forms part of the judiciary however they are unique in the sense that they do not get paid. Even though magistrates do not …show more content…
The legal decision making system of England & Wales also utilises a jury. A jury is used when a case it out of the magistrates jurisdiction. Juries are an integral part of the legal system, a mechanism that is envied around the world to cite just one opinion, that of Dr Burkhard Schafer, professor at the University of Edinburgh.
The modern jury’s role is to make decision of guilt or innocence of a defendant in court (or liability of a defendant in civil matters). A jury consists of 12 members of the public, chosen at random from the areas surrounding the court. They are expected be impartial and make decisions based on evidence brought before them, although on rare occasions the jury has gone against evidence and made a decision based on what they thought was morally right, as cased in the acquittal of Clive Ponting in 1985.
In the past they have been seen to be treated unfairly as shown in Bushell’s Case (1670) Vaugh 135: Freem KB1 however as society has developed more importance has been placed on the allowance of fair and lengthy deliberation as cased in R v McKenna [1960] 1 QB 411 ‘a jury shall deliberate in complete freedom’.
The judge gives the direction to the jury on the relevant law, which the jury has to apply to the facts of the case in order to reach a verdict. If it is a criminal case and the jury has given a verdict of guilty, then the judge will
Show More

Related Documents: Role of Magistrates & Jury in England & Wales Essay

Magistrates In Youth Court Cases

Magistrates may also sit in the Crown Court with a judge to hear appeals from magistrates’ courts against conviction or sentence and proceedings on committal to the Crown Court for sentence. Moreover, they are also specially trained to sit in youth courts, where procedures are slightly more informal than in adult criminal courts, for example, magistrates will deliberately talk directly to young defendants, rather than always through their legal representatives. In criminal cases the youth court can…

Words 1218 - Pages 5

Essay on Courts: Jury and United States

judicial system may not be always perfect it is fair to all individuals who have to come before it in any capacity; whereas in other countries like Great Brittan or Wales where there judicial hierarchy is much more complex, you might not find their systems or polices as fortunate as ours in the United States. For example, in Wales their magistrate must stay 15 miles from the courthouse and they are unpaid volunteers who may or may not have any legal background, so when it comes to getting justice or injustice…

Words 3416 - Pages 14

The British origins of common law Essay

The British origins of common law The common-law system first developed in England and is therefore often referred to as ‘English common law’. Upon colonisation by the British, Australia adopted a common-law legal system. Other countries using this system include Great Britain, Canada, New Zealand and the United States of America. Common law can be best described as a collection of legal principles and rules that is derived from the decisions of judges in higher courts. However, the term ‘common…

Words 2321 - Pages 10

Case Study On Law

The(reception(of(English(law(into(New(South(Wales(in(1828(means:( % % a.%Copies%of%the%relevant%statute%books%were%sent%to%the%New%South%Wales%Parliament;% % % b.%Only%the%rules%specified%by%the%United%Kingdom%Parliament%as%appropriate%to%a%conquered%colony%were%to%apply%to% New%South%Wales;% % % c.%English%common%law%and%equity%and%English%statutes,%if%suitable%to%conditions%in%New%South%Wales,%were%to%apply%to% New%South%Wales;% % % d.%The%English%court%system%was%introduced%in%New%South%Wales;% % % (b)%and%(d)%above…

Words 4004 - Pages 17

Essay about The Role of the CPS within the English and Welsh Legal System

Discuss the role of the CPS within the English and Welsh legal system. JAMES DOLPHIN T305 The CPS (Crown Prosecution Service) is responsible for prosecuting all criminal cases. This can be found under the Prosecution of Offences act 1985. The CPS was established in 1985 but it was in 1970 during the justice report that there were problems found within the police services when it came to prosecuting criminals. The police were found of being bias due to ethnic minority backgrounds and gave unfair…

Words 1438 - Pages 6

Basic Legal Concepts

1. Basic Legal Concepts * Meaning of Law Law: A set of rules, imposed on all members of a community, which are officially recognised, binding and enforceable by persons or organisations such as the police and court. * Customs, Rules and Law * Customs: * Established patterns of behaviour among people in a society or group. * Depends on culture, religion and history. * Customary Law: Customs that have become laws. E.g. Australian Torres Strait Islander Laws, English and…

Words 7588 - Pages 31

Essay about Law and Law Review

|Carleton University |Department of Law and Legal Studies | Course Outline |Course: | |LAWS & HIST 3305 C & V – Crime and State in History | | | | | |Term:…

Words 7571 - Pages 31

Essay about Legal Studies Notes

PART A:: THE LEGAL SYSTEM TOPIC 1: BASIC LEGAL NOTIONS o Anarchy, custom, rules, law, fairness, equality + justice, values and ethics Anarchy: The situation that exists in a society that does not have laws or state rule Custom: The collective habits, or traditions, that have been developed by a society over a long period of time Rules: The authoritative regulation of behaviour Fairness: The legitimate and proper conduct in the performance of an act or duty Equality: Suggests that everyone…

Words 6720 - Pages 27

Business Law Notes

Chapter one Business Law Law is a set of rules, enforceable by the courts, which regulate the government of the state and governs the relationship between the state and its citizens and between one citizen and another. There are various ways in which the law may be classified; the most important are: * Public and private law * A) Public law is concerned with the relationship between the state and its citizens. Specialised areas are: 1. Constitutional law is concerned with the workings…

Words 34659 - Pages 139