Essay about Rubbish society

Submitted By 416381137
Words: 1459
Pages: 6
Open Document
Essay Plan
Intro
The challenge of rubbish
Definitions
Theory – Thompson
Scope
Thompson’s theory from 1979
Categories
Transient
Zero value
Durable
Examples
Stevengraphs
Modern examples
Based on demand and supply
Modern relevance
Increases is standard of living in West means even more relevant
Prevalence of disposable items
Principle does not apply to all items, e.g. gold/bricks.
Modern art and junk art
Thompson still relevant
Wider relevance
To less economically developed countries? Yes, but fewer items with zero value, more with greater transient value
Some exceptions if society not based on supply and demand, e.g. Buddhist monks
To historical societies? Yes, but proportions of items in each category changes over time
Thompson still relevant
Impact of recent greater emphasis on recycling
Greater awareness of the environmental impact of consumerism, including of disposing of items, leading to greater emphasis on recycling or re-use
Re-use of items which would have had zero value giving them transient value
The ‘break-even’ point, impact of recycling must not be greater than the impact of disposing and replacing
Thompson still relevant
Conclusion
Rubbish has been one of man’s enduring challenges
Challenge has increased as society has become more consumer orientated
Thompson’s theory widely valid, with some exceptions, but provides a useful analytical framework.

Rubbish is the invisible part of consumption (Making Social Lives, 2009, p103). Rubbish has always been produced by humans, both historically and in our modern society. It is an inevitable product of our consumer society. However, there are different views to the ways we value, or disvalue, waste. The term ‘rubbish’ has more than one meaning. The Oxford English Dictionary defines rubbish as: “waste material; refuse or litter”; or “material that is considered unimportant or valueless” (oxforddictionaries.com). To describe something as “valueless” also requires a definition of the term value. It can refer to how useful something is, or the extent to which something is regarded worthwhile, or the extent to which it can command a price. It can also refer to the ‘norm’ or principle of what is right and wrong (Making Social Lives, 2009, p104). Items can also hold sentimental value to individuals; while they hold no monetary value it may be treasured by one person. Thompson (1979) provided a theory to explain the ways in which rubbish is valued. This essay will explore the worth of rubbish, examining one of the main western theories, and test its validity to different societies and societies over time.
In his book ‘Rubbish Theory: The Creation and Destruction of Value’ (1979), Thompson looked at how objects can pass through three categories of rubbish: transient, zero value; and durable (Making Social Lives, 2009, p122). The transient category included items that were produced for ordinary use, such as clothing or mobile phones, whose value would fall over time. Items that nobody wants, such as broken technology products, worn out clothes or wrappers, have zero-value. Items that increase in value over time, such as works of art, Thompson viewed as durable. Thompson used the example of Stevengraphs (made by Thomas Stevens) to prove his theory. The modestly prices woven pictures provide Stevens with a livelihood in the late 1800s (having transient value), but became very unpopular in the middle of the 20th Century, with zero value. However they increased in value significantly in the 1960-70s, eventually selling as collectors’ items, gaining durable value (Making Social Lives, 2009, p124). Thompson argued his theory could be applied to any consumer society, as long as demand and supply was present. In terms of the Stevengraphs, suddenly something in limited supply was wanted by collectors, and so the value increased.
Thompson lived in a modern western society, and his theory was based on relatively modern evidence. His
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Rubbish society

Ways in Which Rubbish Can Be Said to Have Value in a Consumer Society Essay

This assignment will aim to outline the ways in which rubbish can be said to have value in a consumer society. It will attempt to outline all the various ways value is taken in one form or another from refuse which will include; the ecological value by reducing the space taken up in landfill sites, the value of profit in reducing Local Authority Costs by the selling of recyclable rubbish, the value of conserving natural resources when recycling paper, glass, plastic, clothing and IT equipment.…

Words 1161 - Pages 5

Outline why rubbish not worthless Essay

Essay Plan – Outline the argument that rubbish is not worthless. Introduction: • What is rubbish? • What is ‘value’? – The notion of value Main Body: Paragraph 1: • Consumer Society – What is consumer society? • Wastefulness – How much waste is thrown away each year in the UK? • Affluence – The rising affluence in the UK Paragraph 2: • Thompson’s Theory – The three different categories of objects or ‘rubbish’ and what they are • Stevengraphs – How Stevengraphs had risen and…

Words 1277 - Pages 6

Rubbish Has No Value Essay

TMA02: “Rubbish has no value “ In this essay i want to discuss and analyse rubbish and it’s value. Rubbish has been described as something with no value, however value is a complex term and does not complete a clear picture of rubbish. To define rubbish clearly I want to discuss the relationship between rising affluence and consumer society and how they have produced more rubbish. Also what rubbish means to different people and who are the winners and losers in the mass generation of rubbish. I…

Words 1351 - Pages 6

Recycling and Pg Essay

that rubbish is not worthless Introduction Describe briefly what rubbish is and the meaning of the word value Write a bit about consumer society Reference to Contemporary UK society and ‘consumer society’ defining who we are by what we buy and how we use the things we buy rather than what we do for a living differentiation between industrial and consumer society Main Body Talk about the main correlation and effect affluence has on consumer society? mention the amount of rubbish increasing…

Words 1431 - Pages 6

My Essay

Outline the argument that rubbish is not worthless This essay will outline the argument behind why objects perceived to be valueless, are still very much worth something in today’s society. This will be outlined in a number of ways regarding things that have been stated within books read. The essay will consist of Background information given from making social lives, and the ideas and concepts used within that information. It will also outline why people perceive rubbish as valueless and also touch…

Words 1032 - Pages 5

Social Sustainability Essay

down on Earth. To first sight, it’s easy to mistaking the buildings for what we think it is, but looking closer, it was made out of trash, boxes of rubbish laying on top of each other. In this film, the only moving creatures on Earth were Wall-E who was a robot and his cockroach friend. Wall-E, after hundreds of years, still continuing to clean up rubbish, he made skyscrapers out of trash, the film had an air shot of it as if it was an accomplishment but it was ironic and critical and painful to watch…

Words 890 - Pages 4

Recycling and China Essay

tricycle with a sign around the neighbourhood.In contrast, before garbage truck pick up rubbish family in Australia will classify it into three different bins which for paper ,glasses and other rubbish respectively .Every 2 or 3 months, council will deliver booklet in the Australia household's letter box, collecting staff like garden rubbish, and old furniture etc. Chinese people always sell the part of the rubbish which they think is valuable and discard the rest while Australian will classify all…

Words 723 - Pages 3

Explore the claim that consumer society is always a ‘throw-away’ society. Essay

Explore the claim that consumer society is always a ‘throw-away’ society. This essay aims to address the claim that consumer society is always a ‘throw-away’ society by firstly defining what a consumer society is, who are considered members of it and their reasons for consuming. Following this it will give examples of the types of things that are consumed and thrown away, the reasons and methods used for doing so and the affect that this has on the environment, before finally examining the claim…

Words 1301 - Pages 6

Essay on Outline Who Are the Winners and Losers in a Consumer Society.

TMA02 - Assignment Plan Assignment question: Outline who are the winners and losers in a consumer society. ‘Outline’ – my understanding of this is to summarise/define the winners and losers in a consumer society, focussing on identifying who they are and not why they are. Intro; Describe what I am going to do – keep it short and refer to the question that is being asked, I could start by pointing out who are the winners and losers in general and then building on them in the following…

Words 2394 - Pages 10

Power of Persuasion Essay

beers whilst watching the Chelsea match, you suggest ‘it’d be great if you could quickly run the rubbish out, please’. The modal auxiliary ‘could’ softens the hidden imperative as he knows you’ve never actually directly asked him. Yet in hiding the order you’ve managed to manipulate him and once again he’s outside in the freezing cold, shivering, putting the rubbish in the bins. Like the rest of society, you’ve simply learnt to use language to influence and control. Because you added ‘please’ it creates…

Words 1040 - Pages 5