Sample essay

Submitted By alswp0404
Words: 1578
Pages: 7
Open Document
Jarad Bush
Professor Gath
Phi 1005
11/26/2013
Socrates on the Moral Authority of the State
In the Crito, Socrates makes some surprisingly strong claims about the moral authority of the state, which might even seem to be inconsistent both with another fundamental claim he makes in the Crito and with certain claims he makes in the Apology. I shall argue that although these claims seem to be in some tension with each other, the crucial claims about the authority of the state in the Crito can plausibly be interpreted in such a way as to remove any real inconsistency with the other claims.
The first, rather striking claim about the moral authority of the state occurs at 51b of the Crito. Socrates argues that, because of the state's role as a provider of security, education, and various important social institutions (such as marriage), the citizens of the state are its "offspring and servants"; and from this he concludes that citizens are subordinate to the state and its laws to such an extent that if a citizen ever disagrees with the state's laws or orders, he "must either persuade it or obey its orders," even if the latter amounts to suffering death. The implication for his own case is clear: Socrates had tried to persuade the court of his innocence and of the injustice of his execution (as detailed in the Apology), but he had failed; therefore, he argues, he must now obey the court and accept his death sentence--even though he still thinks that he is in the right on this matter.
The second, closely related claim, comes only a few paragraphs later, in 51e and 52. Socrates there argues that by virtue of remaining in the state, a citizen enters into an implied contract with it to obey its commands. More precisely, the claim is again that a citizen who has a disagreement with the state must either persuade it that it is wrong, or else obey it. In the voice of the personified laws: "either persuade us or do what we say" (52a). The implication, again, is that if one fails to persuade the state to change its mind, for whatever reason, then one must obey its orders. A citizen has no moral right to continue to resist the state, even if he is convinced that he is in the right and the state is in the wrong.
Now as mentioned above, these claims seem directly opposed to certain other claims Socrates makes. Most importantly, earlier in the Crito itself, Socrates had stressed that "one must never do wrong" (49b). Indeed, this serves as the driving principle behind the rest of his argument in the Crito. But is this really consistent with maintaining that one must always obey the state, if one fails to persuade it that something it orders is wrong? The obvious objection is that the state might well order one to do something wrong--e.g. because one of its laws is an unjust one, as Jim Crow laws were. In that case, Socrates' claim that one should never do anything wrong would entail refusing to do what the state orders--even if one is unsuccessful in persuading the state that it is wrong. Thus, Socrates' claim that one should never do wrong seems inconsistent with his claim that one must always obey the final orders of the state.
Secondly, it might be objected that Socrates' view of the moral authority of the state is inconsistent both with what he did when ordered by the Thirty to capture Leon of Salamis for execution, and with what he says he'd do if ordered by the state to cease practicing philosophy (both from the Apology). When the Thirty ordered him to capture Leon, he refused, on the grounds that this would have been wrong (unjust and impious). (Apology, 32c-d) This seems to be a recognition that one is morally obligated or at least permitted to disobey the state when what it commands is wrong--even if one fails to persuade it of its wrongness. And similarly, Socrates makes clear that he would disobey the state and continue philosophizing if it were to order him to stop--again, on the grounds that it would be wrong for him to stop
Show More

Related Documents: Sample essay

Sample Essay

China’s of Growth Path from a Global Standpoint: Friend of Foe? Over four decades after China ended her self-sufficiency autarky policies, the country still finds relatively small acceptance on the major international threats. While most OECD countries have relatively friendly or dependent ties on China because of its growing economic importance, many countries still have conflict with China over various issues, such as territorial disputes, intellectual property rights, and outsourcing of employments…

Words 2945 - Pages 12

Essay on Resume Sample

INDIA MYERS 3943 Cutler Donahoe Way, Cumming, GA 30040 Home: 770 906 2476 / Cell: 678 549 5224 / Email: indiamyers89@gmail.com Honest and ethical professional, skilled and managing all front-office and administrative duties, while communicating effectively with internal personnel and external organizations, seeking to combine experience with robust medical education through rewarding opportunities with a progressive healthcare organization. • Thrive in fast-paced environments, possessing…

Words 399 - Pages 2

Case Sample A Essay

Employment-At-Will Case Case Example A: Elaine has sued Jerry because Jerry fired her. Elaine was on the job for two months.The job offer letter that Jerry had sent her mentioned the great career opportunities at the company and stated that her annual salary would be $30,000. The company is an employment‐at‐will employer. Elaine was given no reason for the termination. After the termination, Jerry hired a man named Kramer, who had less job experience and education than Elaine, for the position…

Words 918 - Pages 4

Essay on Exam Sample

BFA103 Accounting & Financial Decision Making (SOU) Semester 5, 2012 Examination Information for ORDINARY, DEFERRED AND SUPPLEMENTARY EXAMINATIONS Time Allowed: THREE (3) hours + 15 minutes reading time (you are permitted to write during reading time) Instructions: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. There are SIX (6) questions to be marked out of a total 100 marks. Some questions have more than one part. Answer ALL questions. You may answer the questions in any…

Words 837 - Pages 4

Writing Sample Essay

The book “Fifty Shades of Grey, by E.L. James,” is the first book of its kind to reach popular culture. Although there are a lot of stimulating fiction novels that exist, one has to ask what was it that caused this series to hit top-seller all around the world and turn out to be a sensational hit? Many people in the world and critics claim to say that the book was incompetently written and is a literary disaster, however it’s fame, success, and popularity cannot be overlooked. With the media calling…

Words 402 - Pages 2

Essay on Sample Chart

Exhibit 1 Total Health Expenditure per Capita, U.S. and Selected Countries, 2008 Source: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (2010), “OECD Health Data”, OECD Health Statistics (database). doi: 10.1787/data-00350-en (Accessed on 14 February 2011).Notes: Data from Australia and Japan are 2007 data. Figures for Belgium, Canada, Netherlands, Norway and Switzerland, are OECD estimates. Numbers are PPP adjusted. This picture shows a Pareto Chart; a bar graph with the bars arranged…

Words 374 - Pages 2

Sample Project Essay

Literature Review 5 Perceived Investment in Employee’s Development 5 Turnover Intention 6 Organization Citizenship Behaviour 6 Work Efforts and Work Quality 7 Perceived supervisor support 7 Affective Commitment 8 Methodology 8 procedures 8 participants and sample proportion 8 Measures 9 Analysis and Results 10 Discussion 15 References 17 Abstract The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship between perceived investment in employees’ development, perceived supervisor support, work effort…

Words 4922 - Pages 20

Sample Test Essay

SAMERIT SYSTEM SERVICES - SAMPLE ELIGIBILITY WORKER I - ITEMS READING AND UNDERSTANDING WRITTEN MATERIALS DIRECTIONS:Read each question carefully. Select the best answer and darken the proper space on the answer sheet. 1. Through advertising, manufacturers exercise a high degree of control over consumers’desires. However, the manufacturer assumes enormous risks in attempting to predict what consumers will want and in producing goods in quantity and distributing them in advance of final selection…

Words 1072 - Pages 5

253 Sample Essay

AFIN 253 Financial Management Name: QIN LIU ID:42670314 Question The dividend discount model tells us that the value of a firm is equal to the present value of its expected dividend payments. Does this mean that these firms are worth nothing? Discuss with reference to academic research and theory. Answer 723 words It does not mean the firms are worth nothing when firms have never paid dividends and have no intention…

Words 1124 - Pages 5

Writing Sample Essay

DUKE ENERGY PLANT PRESS BRIEFING WILLOUGHBY MAYOR TALKING POINTS WELCOME&INTRODUCTION Welcome to our new Duke Energy Plant Press Briefing. We are pleasured to welcome our distinguished guests, outstanding reporters from local and national media, parents, potential employees and others. In n the next few minutes, I will introduce the plan for a new Duke Energy nuclear power plant. Then we will discuss safety concerns among nuclear power. My Name is Honorable Amber Taylor, the mayor of Willoughby…

Words 470 - Pages 2