Analysis Of Scotland And The Creation Of The Sterling Zone

Submitted By bcollns2
Words: 1965
Pages: 8
Open Document
Analysis of Scotland and the Creation of a “Sterling Zone”
The referendum that is scheduled to be put to a vote on September 18th of this year is a very historic one but with it comes the major questions of what Scotland will do with its independence and more specifically what currency will it operate with. The currency issue has been a hot button topic in the political and economic world as both sides argue adamantly about it. Many believe that if Scotland is able to maintain using the pound that the referendum will pass easier as Scottish citizens will feel safer with their countries young economy if it was backed by the historically strong currency of the United Kingdom (UK) but there is opposition to allowing Scotland to remain in the “Sterling Zone” for fear of the risks that would come along with two independent countries entering into a currency union. This report will discuss the costs and benefits for both countries in entering a currency union and the criteria for entering an optimal currency area along with how well the two countries meet those criteria.
Aside from the political implications of keeping the pound, there are many benefits that go along with entering into a currency union. One of these benefits that Scotland desires from this union is to keep the effective central bank that exists currently with the Bank of England; this would be a major benefit to Scotland’s economy because the Bank of England has a history of producing and maintaining a strong currency. Along with an effective central bank, having the same currency would eliminate transaction costs, create price transparency, and alleviate the fear of exchange rate changes for businesses between the countries of Scotland and the UK. There would be an increase in the transaction costs of all of the businesses within Scotland and the UK if the currency were to change as they would need to constantly convert money and even possibly need to set up currency hedges in some cases causing the increase of costs for those business and lowering their net incomes causing the economies of the two countries to be damaged to a degree. These losses to both countries would obviously be eliminated if they were to join a currency union as there would exists no transaction costs of changing currency as there would only be the same currency across the board. Also price transparency would allow companies in both countries to have a better relationship and allow for existing partnerships to continue without the worry of prices or costs changing and with these relationships being continued the economies. Being a part of a currency union would decrease the uncertainty of future exchange rates between countries as with any independent currency of Scotland there would be a fear of drastic changes in the exchange rate when making contracts or conducting deals between businesses in either country. Finally, the last benefit of adopting the pound is that Scotland would be using an internationally recognized currency and the businesses within the country would have an easier time dealing on the ever increasing international market with an established currency like the pound as opposed to a new currency of Scotland’s own.
While there exist many benefits in joining a currency union, they mainly benefit Scotland in the arrangement because they are a smaller economy than that of the UK while the costs of creating a currency union rests largely on the shoulders of the UK causing the current government to oppose the creation of this union. The main cost of maintaining a currency union is the threat of asymmetric shock. This, as Sir Nicholas Macpherson the Permanent Secretary for Her Majesty’s Treasury stated, causes an asymmetry between the two countries meaning that “the continuing UK would be at risk of providing taxpayer support to the Scottish financial sector and sovereign. An independent Scottish state would not face the same risk as it is inconceivable that a small economy
Show More

Related Documents: Analysis Of Scotland And The Creation Of The Sterling Zone

No Country For Old Money

No country for old money If Scotland gains independence it will need a new currency and a new central bank Sep 13th 2014 | From the print edition WHEN it comes to money and banking, no country has a richer history than Scotland. It was a Scot, David Hume, who in a 1748 essay set out the first coherent theory of the links between money, inflation and growth. And it is a Scottish idea, the joint-stock bank that, starting in the mid-1800s, became the backbone of global finance. Yet Scotland’s monetary…

Words 1022 - Pages 5

Scottish Independence

The Scottish government's leader First Minister Alex Salmond is strongly against this union (Scotland's union with the UK). He claims that it no longer meets its purpose. Almond believes that an independent state of Scotland would definitely be one of the richest and strongest countries since its depending on its oil wealth. However, Prime Minister David Cameron states that the UK is one of the world's most successful countries on various domains; politically, socially and economically. The key…

Words 550 - Pages 3

Persuasive Essay On Scottish Independence

that the margin on this vote was so slim has proven to scare the spectators who have been watching this decision. The complications of a “yes” vote on Scottish independence expand to far beyond just the United Kingdom. Talk of independence between Scotland and the U.K. is being carefully watched by the rest of Europe, wherein regions of different countries are expressing the same push for independence. Ramifications of such a precedent of exodus will flow into…

Words 865 - Pages 4

How Did Scotland Made

How Scotland was made In 82 AD this land was firstly invaded by the romans after fighting against different tribes of Scotland including Picts (painted masses) that time and romans built Hadrian wall there. Romans left Scottish land in 500AD and Scots, Angles and Picts begin ruling their respective kingdoms. On 563 AD Christianity finally spreads in monks of Scotland. In 693 AD Picts king defeated the Angles and Picts unite with the Scots under Picts king Kenneth McAlpin and Picts lost their identity…

Words 803 - Pages 4

an inspector calls Essay

Should Scotland become independent? Since the SNP was formed in 1936 it has had a dream that Scotland should be independent from the rest of the UK – an idea which has been scoffed at by many for years since. However, this dream has recently become a much more realistic probability since the SNP won a minority government in 2007 and went on to win a majority in the Scottish Parliament in 2012. During this time they have put forward an approximate time in 2014 for the country to decide it’s state…

Words 1516 - Pages 7

European Union and Member Countries Essay example

to which the Benefits of UK Membership in the European Union Outweigh the Costs DEMURI BAGDAVADZE UFP ECNOMICS 20.04.15 Introduction European Union compromises of twenty eight members states mainly from the Europe continent. It was formed after world war (II) with its main intention to help the nations escape the nationalisms which was consuming their growth of the economy .The major nations which dominates the union include United Kingdom which is under the leadership of…

Words 2080 - Pages 9

The History Of The United Kingdom

Labour Party. Much of the Labour Party?s support comes from labor unions, known as trade unions. The Conservative Party (lead by John Major) stems from the Tory Party, which commenced in the late 1600?s. The Labour Party (lead by Tony Blair) began in 1900. Other parties like the Liberal Democrats (Jeremy Ashdown) are minute in comparison to the Conservative or Labour parties. There are a few nationalist parties in Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales (Scottish National Party, lead by Alex Salmond) that…

Words 4222 - Pages 17

What Are The Events In James Shapiro's The Year Of Lear

occurred during that year that gave Shakespeare inspiration to write his tragedies. Shapiro was successful in demonstrating how events like the unification of England and Scotland by King James, the outbreak of the plague, the gunpowder plot and equivocation shaped Shakespeare’s works during the year 1606. King James VI of Scotland rose to power in April 1603. The previous ruler, Queen Elizabeth I had no children, therefore, he would succeed as King James I of England. King James…

Words 1128 - Pages 5

Single Market Benefits

Europe on the move It’s a better life How the EU’s single market benefits you European Commission Published in all the official languages of the European Union: Danish, Dutch, English, Finnish, French, German, Greek, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish and Swedish. European Commission Directorate General Press and Communication Publications B-1049 Brussel/Bruxelles Manuscript completed in August 2002. Cover: EKA Cover lay-out: EC-EAC Cataloguing data can be found at the end of this publication…

Words 7208 - Pages 29

Sst 1 Task 1 Wgu Essay

A Look at the Modern Institutions of the World Western Governors University In this paper I will be discussing the characteristics of a modern nation-state, the European Union, and a couple of the foreign policies of the United States. By the end of this paper there should be an understanding of what makes a modern nation-state and also some examples of countries that are either a nation or state. To understand what a nation-state is, you must first understand what both a state and…

Words 2705 - Pages 11