York himself originated from the anti-war pacifist side. However, during the course of the film, especially in the promotion scene, he found himself in the position of debating whether war is sometimes necessary in order to serve the people of the States. He then comes to peace with the idea of war and accepted the promotion to corporal. Birdwell’s article specifically highlighted the fact that the actual Alvin York wanted the movie to focus more on education and faith rather than the war sequences. However, over the production period, in response to the political situation