Sexual Rehabilitation In Prison Essay

Words: 1241
Pages: 5
Open Document
Several years ago, a professor of mine was on jury duty during a sexual assault case. He explained that the man on trial had been assaulting his fourteen-year-old niece periodically for several years. However, the court revealed that the defendant had been similarly abused by a family member at that same approximate age. This raises an important mitigating question. What should be done with an attacker who was also a victim? And should a guilty verdict of a prison sentence include treatment?
While this case is horrific in every way, it is sadly very common for aggressors to have experienced trauma during their development (Widem 189). Is it reasonable to consider, that perhaps if the defendant had received help, the violence he enacted upon his niece could have been avoided. Is he not a victim in his own right, who at the age of fourteen was himself, and from that point forward, not given the necessary resources to cope and repair healthily?
With the …show more content…
Ho, a consultant forensic psychiatrist and clinical research lead at Secure Mental Health Services in England (SEPT), claims that sexual rehabilitation in prison has not been proven to be effective. He believes the public is under a false impression and deserves to know there is no evidence of a decrease in likelihood of recurrence upon prison release. Ho explains that while there is some overlap between sexual disorders and crime, this is not a complete overlap, and raises the question of whether “sex offending is even a disorder in need of treatment.” As a physician he raises the question about whether it is fair to implement treatment or to reassure the public of treatment’s effectiveness without proven efficacy. He claims that “most treatment programs follow a syllabus that will be the basis for which parole boards evaluate whether sex offenders may qualify for early release”, and makes the case that “physicians have a duty to weigh in on this practice of treating” without “robust research” (BMJ
Show More

Related Documents: Sexual Rehabilitation In Prison Essay

Max: Prison and north American Prison Essay

American Prison System and the novel Rita Hayworth and the Shawshank Redemption. A prison is an institution for the confinement of persons convicted of criminal offenses. Nelson Mandela once said “When a man is denied the right to live the life he believes in, he has no choice but to become an outlaw.” The prison system has been a way to keep violent criminals away from society and should also help to reform convicts and enable them to reintegrate into society. It may be true that prisons exist for…

Words 2170 - Pages 9

Persuasive Essay On Rehabilitation Vs. Punishment

In this essay I chose to talk about Rehabilitation Vs. Punishment. I personally have a fair bias view towards helping the criminal. I feel that people are truly good, but that some people, a small percentage, have some sort of chemical balance wrong in their head that makes them, evil. I feel everyone should be helped instead of punished, but some should still be imprisioned depending on if they stole something compared to murdering someone on purpose. In this essay I will talk about a number of…

Words 869 - Pages 4

Justice In Criminal Justice

Most of the time this results in prison sentencing. But when the only action is to lock people up, it doesn’t require that the individual act in a certain way, or change. Instead, it excuses the offender from answering for what they have done or punishes them in a way that does not consider…

Words 706 - Pages 3

Crime and Fact Checker Essay

the different types of property crimes committed by offenders. Define the concept of white-collar crime. Discuss the reasons why people may embezzle, or steal from their employers, or commit fraud. Describe and distinguish the various kinds of sexual offenses recognized by the American criminal justice system. Describe and distinguish the various kinds of substance abuse offenses recognized by the American criminal justice system. Identify the key roles and functions of the police in the criminal…

Words 1441 - Pages 6

Criminology Notes Essay

The Demonic Era recap -two main paths that can lead you to the devil? Temptation (choice), possession -5 trials -Patriarchal society Modern Day ‘Witch Hunts?’ -A witch hunt occurs any time a group of people persecutes another group unfairly, usually blaming that other group for larger problems, form of a socially constructed problem -e.g. expansion of AIDS blaming on homosexuals, blaming unemployment rates on immigration -early 1900s Chinese immigrants come to Canada to work on the railroads…

Words 8665 - Pages 35

Essay Notes for Exam 1

the duty of law was to make people into good human beings and good citizens Paternalism Government has power over the people Coercive Nature of Law Deterrence Prevent future crimes of the law Retribution Punishing violators of the law Rehabilitation Difference between: Legislation Applied/ interpreted enforced Moral Individual/State Metaphysical/ontological (interpretation) What is law? Political How the rule of law should be organized (democratic society) The role of liberty-…

Words 4671 - Pages 19

Sociology: Crime and Official Crime Figures Essay

specific society. | Functionalism | An approach that seeks to explain the existence of social structures by the roles they perform in or for society. | Indictable offences | Serious crimes, where if a person is found guilty they are likely to go to prison. | Institutional racism | Where the structure and practises of an organisation such as the police, lead to a group being discriminated. | Lad-ette | A young woman who behaves in a crude manner and engages in heavy drinking sessions. | Marxist…

Words 8348 - Pages 34

Essay on First Amendment to the United States Constitution and u . s . Supreme Court

church and prohibited harassment based on religious differences. 1787-1788 Originally published in New York newspapers as The Federalist and widely reprinted in newspapers throughout the U.S., The Federalist Papers are a unique collection of 85 essays written by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison and John Jay urging ratification of the Constitution. In Federalist No. 84, Alexander Hamilton writes on the subject of the liberty of the press, declaring that “the liberty of the press shall be inviolably…

Words 7937 - Pages 32