Should The Federal Government Have Too Much Power

Words: 1752
Pages: 8
Open Document
Since the dawn of the United States and its constitution less than 250 years ago there has been question as to who should have more power, the states or the federal government. As the country was established as an escape from a tyrannical monarchy where the central government and king held all the power, the people were hesitant to allot any power away from the states. But over time, conflict such as the Civil War and it’s resolution changed the paradigm creating something new entirely. Progressively the proverbial pendulum of power has swung from a position of state strength to a reigning federal power that now is supreme today. This change in power over time has cultivated a unbalanced state and federal system that has granted too much power …show more content…
Under the Articles, the federal government only had power to declare war, appoint military officers, sign treaties, make alliances, appoint foreign ambassadors, and handle relations with Indians. With no power at all to tax its people as well as imports and exports, this system of central government quickly proved useless altogether. A complete overhaul was necessary and happened, establishing the United States Constitution we have today. So then how much power does the federal government need in order to properly do its job? Some is necessary, but too much infringes on the rights of the individual states. So, as stated within the 10th amendment, “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to the people.“ thus keeping the power balance as it should …show more content…
There are some great benefits to them having some power as opposed to none at all. While the states holding on to most powers is crucial, the federal government having some is also very beneficial as they are able to handle larger, bigger picture issues that the states couldn’t themselves. In order to have the funding referenced in the last paragraph we need the powerful federal government for raising money when necessary and paying for things like schools, interstates, and national defense. The vast public lands throughout the middle and western United States are managed by the Bureau of Land Management, the U.S. Forest Service, the United States National Park Service, the Bureau of Reclamation, and the Fish and Wildlife Service which are all entities of the federal government under the department of the interior. Without these organizations, this land and it’s resources would go unmanaged as the individual states wouldn’t have the resources and the wilderness areas cross between states so jurisdiction would be a problem as well. Additionally, a powerful federal government is largely important in protecting the country from invasion and pursuing peace efforts around the world, managing internal conflicts within the nation, and its keeps powers well diffused between branches of government. Power for the federal government does have its place but only where it is laid
Show More

Related Documents: Should The Federal Government Have Too Much Power

Articles Of Confederation Dbq Essay

the colonies from Britain was a dispute on how America should be governed. The founding fathers scrambled to create a groundwork for the new country. While the Articles of Confederation was still in place, it was weak and many argued it was not suitable for the country. It gave too little power to the federal government. Federalists argued that a new constitution should be made, this time stressing the importance of a strong central government. The antifederalists opposed this notion, arguing that…

Words 1046 - Pages 5

Federal Government Research Paper

Somehow, everybody always wonders what power should the Federal government and the States have? This question is the biggest problems in our country during that time when Founding Fathers were creating a government for the United States. A lot of conversations today have been revolving around the relationships between the federal government and states. The article of Confederation, 1777 – 1781, was our first constitution that was completed after the article declared independence from Great Britain…

Words 1100 - Pages 5

Madison's Federalist 10: A Milestone Achievement In American Political Theory

Madison’s Federalist 10 is considered a milestone achievement in American political theory because it discusses the control the government should have over its country’s citizens. Madison also explains that the government itself should be regulated because if it isn’t, the government may fall victim to its own power and become too restrictive. Madison stated that the government should be made up of a group of individuals who were appointed to represent their varying factions. And he also argued that a strong…

Words 1439 - Pages 6

Similarities Between Federalist And Anti Federalists

Constitution should be ratified had some good points on both sides. This debate’s “winner” were the Federalists and the Constitution was ratified, as last. Its importance lies on the stability it gave to the country, which was able to grow stronger as one and with ideals of equality and liberty spread across it. Anti-Federalists were not necessarily against federalism. They were against the ratification of the Constitution for believing that it gave too much power to the government and so, took…

Words 599 - Pages 3

Constitutional Convention Essay

the United States government of today. Without the Constitutional Convention the United States could to this day still be operating under the Article of Confederation which continuously proved to be inadequate in managing the conflicts among the states and gave the federal government absolutely no taxing powers for its money. With the news of Daniel Shays and his rebellion spreading throughout the nation many leaders saw this as a time to take action. Shay’s Rebellion may have met with military…

Words 903 - Pages 4

Federalism: Supreme Court of the United States and United States Essay

States, it was obvious to many that a system combining both federalism and representative democracy was needed. The people were too widely dispersed, and the country’s transportation and communication systems too primitive to be governed solely from a central location. Although today both communication and transportation are highly advanced, America still maintains a federal system. The driving force behind that system is our increasingly expanding diversity. The United States ranks fourth in the world…

Words 857 - Pages 4

Hw Reading Quiz 3 Essay

Barbara Boone Reading Quiz #3 Give Me Liberty ! TextBook Questions chapter 6 1) The Revolution put out public debates about political and social struggles that enlarged the site of freedom and challenged inherited structures of power within America. they didnt want what wasknown as the principle of hereditary aristocracy. Inequality was known as fundamental and mentality of the colonial social order. the seperated from britain and came up with the declaration of independance. The Declaration…

Words 1134 - Pages 5

Cooperative Federalism Research Paper

The argument against the power the states hold and the power of the federal government has been going on since before the founding of America. If the states and the federal government did not have the right amount of power it could be a really bad situation for the nation, this is why federalism in our government is so important. Federalism is when a government's power is divided amongst central and lower levels of government. Throughout the history of the United States, there has been different…

Words 1154 - Pages 5

The Pros And Cons Of The Anti-Federalists

give more power to the states. As an Anti-Federalist, I agree with the constitution but the bill of rights that was added later on is indeed essential. The bill of rights is a huge part in our personal rights that we are allowed to have, day after day. I don't know what our country would be like if we didn’t have these rights in place. The anti-federalists, despite their name, weren’t against the federalists. As stated in the quote “…the new Constitution, the President and Senate have all the executive…

Words 631 - Pages 3

How Did The Constitution Guard Against Tyranny

more power than all of the others? Tyranny is a form of control in which only one or a few people are in complete control. The constitution guarded against tyranny in several ways which were federalism, separation of powers, checks and balances and how the constitution treated representation of big states and small states. The first guard against tyranny was Federalism which means that states have “reserved powers” that the Federal government cannot control. In the United States, states have the…

Words 824 - Pages 4