Essay on Social Contract and Harmonious Social Living

Submitted By shitho
Words: 837
Pages: 4
Open Document
Your captors inform you that they are offering Smith the same deal; but they do not let you talk with him. Assuming that you are a rational egoist, which of the options presented in the deal should you choose (in other words, which option is it in our own interests to choose?)? The answer is that you should confess, because you will be better off confessing than not confessing whether Smith confesses or not (in other words, the left column result is better than the right in either row). Supposing that Smith is rational (and self-interested) too, though, he will confess as well. So you will both get five years – not a very good result.
If the situation were changed so that you could communicate with Smith and reach an agreement about what to do (and if we assume that the agreement would be enforced somehow, so you can be confident that it will be kept), then it would be rational to agree that neither of you will confess. In that case, you would each be released after only one year. Obviously this is a better result than if you both confessed.
The conclusion social contractarians draw from the dilemma is that we are better off if we cooperate, adopting an (enforced) agreement or social contract, than we would be if we acted as “independent egoists” (in other words, as people who pursue their own interests without cooperation or agreement). The prisoner’s dilemma is a very artificial situation, of course; but there are many real situations that are similar in the sense that independent egoism will produce worse results than accepting a social contract. Suppose, for example, that two timber or logging companies operate in the forests of a particular region; but the forests are shrinking at an alarming rate as a result. If the companies act as competing independent egoists cutting down as many trees as they can, they may destroy the forests and, therefore, their businesses. Alternatively, however, they might adopt a social contract (and enforcement procedures) requiring them to limit the number of trees they can harvest in a given period of time, plant new trees, etc. – an agreement which would be mutually beneficial, leaving both companies better off than they would be without it.
Free Riders
When a society adopts a social contract, some members of the society may of course break the contract. Someone might try to cut in line (in traffic, at a movie theater, etc.) rather than going to the back of the line, for instance – taking advantage of other people’s obedience to the “first come, first served” rule to get ahead of them. A person who breaks contracts in this way is a “free rider”. Free riders do sometimes gain an advantage over those who obey contracts, particularly when sanctions are mild or contracts are not regularly enforced. Overall, though, social contractarians maintain that we are much better off having and obeying contracts than we are without them.
Evaluation of the Social Contract Theory
Rachels suggests that one strength of the social contract theory is that it gives us a plausible answer to the question “Why should we obey moral rules?”: we should obey them because doing so is beneficial to us, since they facilitate harmonious social living. He also suggests that the theory provides a plausible
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Social Contract and Harmonious Social Living

Exploitative Child Labor In The United States

According to the article, “Child Labor: An Overview”, from the website International Initiative on Exploitative Child Labor (IIECL) “over 211 million children between the ages of five and fourteen are employed in some form of wages worldwide”. Child labor is the employment of kids under the age determined by the law that interferes in their childhood and attending of school regularly. The employment of children is a very controversial topic around the world. For many people, they see child labor…

Words 719 - Pages 3

Essay Leighton Holdings Entry to China

Maintaining harmonious relationships with neighbours. Based on the identified issues, some recommendations are provided for Leighton Holdings to expand its business in China: * Make the right connections in China and hold implementation plan workshops and follow-up sessions with Chinese team members to establish and maintain trust and respect at the start of the project; * Develop a clear and appropriate plan and well defined a project’s scope and design before agreements or contracts are signed…

Words 2807 - Pages 12

To what extent were social relations in the nineteenth-century countryside defined by a system of patronage and deference? Essay

"major institutions of rural society: housing, education, the church, the law". Yet when considering how far this system determined the social relations of the time it is important to consider the variable factors (and varying ways in which it was implemented in different villages/counties) which contributed to the impact patronage and deference had upon the social make-up of rural England. Was it the defining influence or was that dependent on the attitudes of the working class and liberal, authoritarian…

Words 1649 - Pages 7

The Impact Of The RIM Company To Enter The Chinese Market Development And Business Industry

Introduction Assignment part 1, I analyzed RIM the development and performance of the past decade, to study the market environment of the company at the same time draw what factors may influence the course of future development RIM. This report will analyze the impact of the RIM company to enter the Chinese market development and business environment for him, and at the same time given a RIM market planning. RIM is a large multinational communications equipment, his products in many areas are…

Words 2154 - Pages 9

HMT1000 Research Essay

the East. Islam sought to unite all Arabs as it rejected secularism and Arab and Islamic civilization were considered one and the same (Sindi, n.d.). Whilst the Arab/Islamic empires were responsible for creating many of the political, economic, social and scientific advances adopted by those in the West, their influence is often ignored and goes unacknowledged by the very societies they helped create (Sindi, n.d.). The beginning of western thinking is thought to be derivative of ancient Greece…

Words 2164 - Pages 9

Theories Of The World-Systematic Perspectives In Identifying Patterns Of How Things Work

identifying patterns of how things work. Theories build upon one another. Interpretive frameworks intended to impose order on a phenomena. Theory and research go hand in hand. Social theory is unusual because it’s not obvious but once pointed out it’s blatant. We view things as second nature. The theorists wrote about the social world that envelops us and frames various beliefs and behaviors. “The discovery of society.” There is a coherence and order in the way society works that matters. September…

Words 7937 - Pages 32

Essay idk what to write

Gov’t designed to protect natural rights – Right of Revolution if fails to do so Power comes from the consent of the people Rousseau (The Social Contract) – Civilization corrupted natural goodness, born free and equal, no nobility Best gov’t: direct democracy – freely formed by people Give up some freedom for common good (utilitarianism) Social contract: agreement between free individuals and gov’t Montesquieu (On the Spirit of Laws) – Separation of powers based on British gov’t (three branches)…

Words 5417 - Pages 22

Imposing Labour Standards Essay

A STUDY OF THE DEBATE SURROUNDING IMPOSING LABOUR STANDARDS ON DEVELOPING COUNTRIES: ARE METHODS EMPLOYED EFFECTIVE? Group Members: Alana Black Lorna Carey June Northcote Allison Robertson CONTENTS PAGE Background 3 Aims & Objectives 3 Scope & Limitations 3 INTRODUCTION 4 1 THE DEBATE: CONFLICTING STAKEHOLDER VIEWS 4 2. METHODS FOR IMPLEMENTATION & CONTROL 10 3. WEIGHING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS EMPLOYED 13 4. CONCLUSIONS…

Words 6967 - Pages 28

Parenting And Caring Notes Essay

arrangements. Pregnancy unplanned Unplanned pregnancies often cause difficulties for parents in managing the altered structure of their family and the changes associated with the biological structure, emotional needs and social relationships of both parents. The emotional, economic and social problems associated with unplanned pregnancies may lead to family hardships and strains that are difficult to overcome. Unplanned pregnancies leave women with choices, including adoption, abortion or keeping the child…

Words 7549 - Pages 31

Employee Relations Essay

MPM722: HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT ASSIGNMENT EMPLOYEE RELATIONS BAIBHAB MAHAPATRA DEAKIN STUDENT ID: 214311899 LECTURER: JOHN MOLINEUX Word Count: 3483 (excluding cover page, tables/figures, references and appendices) INTRODUCTION: In earlier days, Employee Relations, or Industrial Relations as it was known then, was largely concerned with the management and worker relationship and the role of regulator mechanism in order to resolve any industrial dispute that arose. K.Aswathappa…

Words 3970 - Pages 16