Standardized Education's Effects on Learning Essay

Submitted By thespian14
Words: 2555
Pages: 11
Open Document
Megan Shaw
Mrs. Stephanie Wood
English IV
9 October 2013
Improving Educational Achievement
Standardized testing is meant to evaluate how well students are learning in their schools, and how well their schools are preparing them for graduation and careers after high school, but without the right kinds of tests, and a thorough understanding of their proper uses, we may do more harm than good to public education in America.Some students have test anxiety, some have certain learning disabilities, not all students speak English as their first language, and some students (not just the artistic ones) learn visually or audibly.Requiring students to pass a standardized test to receive a high school diploma is a part of today’s public education; however, itdoes not improve the academic achievement of our students due to important abilities and skills left unrecognized and untested by standardization’s narrow curriculum, such as a desire for the arts. Students being subjected to standardized testing receive the benefits of being competent in mathematics and English, and graduating high school with the basic skills deemed necessary to acquire work in today’s business environment. In Massachusetts, high-stakes testing was a quick solution to “education by zip code,” the practice of supporting students based on where they live, and students graduating without viable business skills. The MCAS (Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System) was started in 1998 and was to be administered to students in grades four, eight, 10, and 12; the 10th and 12th grade tests would have to be passed in order to graduate high school. At first, failure rates were very high, but David Driscoll, commissioner ofeducation in Massachusetts, says that failure rates were only so high (50% in math and 1/3 in English) because schools told students that the test did not count, therefore the test was “blown off.”Driscoll argues in favor of high-stakes testing and explains why he believes the MCAS is a fair and valid test. This state-wide standardized test focuses on math and English, and the Board of Education states that these basics are enough the establish competency. In 2001, it was made law that if students do not pass the final MCAS administered their senior year of high school with a minimum score of 220; they will not be allowed to graduate. A student named Madeline Valera took the test in 10th grade and scored a 216. She took it again in 12th grade and barely made a 220. PBS interviewed her about her experience with the MCAS and she said, “This test is not testing what I’m good at. I’m artistic. I have these talents, and it doesn’t recognize that. It looks at what I’m not and ignores what I am.” When informed of this interview, David Driscoll responded, “We’re not trying to test someone’s artistic ability, nor are we saying someone who passes the test meets the graduation requirements (of their school). We call it ‘competency determination.’ They could have a whole series of talents otherwise”(“Testing. Teaching.Learning?”).
With comments like these coming from many state education commissioners, controversy arose. Standardization shows how students have learned specific concepts and skills, but they often focus on the schools’ accomplishments, leaving some researchers wondering is the tests truly show how and if the students are learning. Standardized test usage often encourages a narrowed curriculum and outdated methods of instruction that often leave students in the dust. The test is the same for every student who takes it, but not all students are the same. A student’s performance on a test is affected by more than just what they do and do not know. Focusing on these basics of math and English is meant to prepare students for the real world by establishing competency, yet they sometimes fail students who may excel in a history, science, or foreign language. But is testing on just math and English giving a wide enough view of a student?
Show More

Related Documents: Standardized Education's Effects on Learning Essay

Standardized Testing Affecting America

Standardized Testing: How it’s Affecting American Education The United States is falling lower in education ranks while other countries are climbing, and there is a potential contributing factor: excessive standardized testing. America is ranked 17th in science and 24th in math (reading was exempt due to a printing error) out of 57 other countries. (Wilde) Although the United States is in the middle of the group and not the lower end, as large and diverse as the country is, one would think that…

Words 1641 - Pages 7

Haley DavisEnglish 1301 TTAP 930November 10 Essays

TO THE TEST: IS HARMING KIDS Hammering test preparations into the brains of children can only cause more harm than good, leaving many with nothing more than a migraine headache to deal with. Teaching to the test, solely focuses on preparing for standardized tests, and its pressures of passing such a test. When a district decides on a test, the curriculum, and what is critical for the students to achieve, they are taking instruction out of the hands of the teachers and students, and putting it into…

Words 2069 - Pages 9

Essay The Dichotomy of Outcomes Between Short Term and Long Term Effects of Retained Students

The Dichotomy of Outcomes Between Short Term and Long Term Effects of Retained Students Amanda West University of Texas at Dallas The Dichotomy of Outcomes Between Short Term and Long Term Effects on Retained Students A mother’s first instinctual reaction to learning that a child will repeat a grade is usually negative in nature. Naturally, a web of questions arises in relation to the overall well-being of the child. How will my child cope socially, emotionally, academically over…

Words 4245 - Pages 17

Essay on No Child Left Behind Thesis

No Child Left Behind 1 Running head: NO CHILD LEFT BEHIND The Impact of the No Child Left Behind Act on the K-8 Setting Kara Robertson A Senior Thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for graduation in the Honors Program Liberty University Fall 2009 No Child Left Behind 2 Acceptance of Senior Honors Thesis This Senior Honors Thesis is accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for graduation from the Honors Program of Liberty University…

Words 8350 - Pages 34

The Importance Of School Students For Instructional Studies

UNDERSTANDING HOW U.S. SECONDARY SCHOOLS SORT STUDENTS FOR INSTRUCTIONAL PURPOSES: ARE ALL STUDENTS BEING SERVED EQUALLY? AUTHOR ANYSIA MAYER was a doctoral candidate at the University of California, Davis – School of Education. ABSTRACT This article reviews the current research literature on how secondary schools sort students for instructional purposes. Current sorting practices are based on early American philosophies of schooling where the goal of school was to provide students with…

Words 7624 - Pages 31

Essay on Conceptual Framework

1 Grand Canyon University College of Education Conceptual Framework Grand Canyon University College of Education 3300 W. Camelback Road Phoenix, AZ 85017 Dr. Kimberly A. LaPrade Dean College of Education Conceptual Framework © 2011. Grand Canyon University. All Rights Reserved. February 1, 2011 2 Table of Contents Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................... 2 List of Tables…

Words 9594 - Pages 39