There is an argument to be made that Avery was singled out and treated unfairly in both cases. In the sexual assault case, Penny Beernsten described her attacker and Judy Dvorak suggested that it sounded like Steven Avery. A composite sketch was drawn of Steven Avery by Gene Kusche from an old mugshot of Avery. Of course Beernsten chose Avery out of the line because the police subconsciously told exactly who the attacker was. In the murder case the only suspect the police ever looked into was Steven Avery and most of the evidence against Avery was uncovered by Manitowoc county police who were unsupervised when most of the evidence was found. Once Steven Avery got out of prison for the sexual assault he had a bullseye on his back from the police. It is plausible that the police arrested Avery for the murder in hope that it would cover up their previous blunder by showing that he really was a criminal. (Making a