Stopping Arizona's Anti-Immigration Law

Submitted By Lobobanos21
Words: 741
Pages: 3
Open Document
Arizonas law

"Stopping Arizona's Anti-Immigration Law." Editorial. The New York Times (April 30, 2010) http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/30/opinion/30fri1.html This New York Times article outlines the author's perspective on Arizona's new immigration law. The author questions the beliefs in which this country was founded upon saying, “Is our core belief still the welcome and assimilation of newcomers?” This article is suggesting that it is time for the federal government step in and put an end to “poison” of a law instead of “mildly criticize” it. The author of this article outlines a three step plan that he or she think the President should enforce against the new immigration law. He/she starts out by saying the government needs to defend civil rights, stop Arizona cold and take back immigration policy. The article elaborates on these steps. The author admits that “these steps are no substitutes for immigration reform” and knows that this list is not a quick solution but it could work. Says the “federal government must react forcefully to the Arizona statute” and is most definitely arguing in favor of immigrants.
"Editorial: Arizona immigration bill misguided and dangerous" The Stanford Daily 4/29/2010 http://www.stanforddaily.com/2010/04/29/editorial-arizona-immigration-bill-misguided-and-dangerous/ This editorial says that America is in agreement about the fact that we need some new immigration policies, but goes on to say that S.B. 1070 goes too far. The Author believes that the bill gives too much power to local law officials and that it "contains no clear guidelines for identifying those without proper documentation." This article points out that this bill not only effects illegal immigrants, but also American citizens, since local law officials do not know if they are questioning citizens or illegal immigrants. This, the article sees, is a violation of our rights. The bill, they claim, is vague and unclear as to what will be counted as "reasonable suspicion" because it is against the law to make that decision based on ethnicity alone. Ethnicity, the article states, is obviously the number one criteria for "reasonable suspicion", though this is unconstitutional, and ignoring this fact is dangerous. Also, state police are not granted permission to enforce immigration policy, though this is what the bill states and what the local police are asked to do. (Michael Buckley) Stevenson, M. (11 November 2010). Study: 100,000 Hispanics leave Arizona after immigration law debated. MSNBC. Retrieved From: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/40141843/ns/us_news-immigration_a_nation_divided/#.T4LuT5iXDap This was an article reported from the Associated Press in November 2010, months after the bill was introduced which created much controversy in the public spotlight. This says a study shows that 100,000 or more immigrants have fled Arizona in response to this law to go to states with much more conservative or immigrant friendly states, such as New Mexico or
Show More

Related Documents: Stopping Arizona's Anti-Immigration Law

Hrm 531 Essay

Mytty-Klein Team Reflection: Principles and Strategies Principles and strategies that applies for a small, medium and large organization is what Team A had to discuss this week for each of our chosen business to be compliant with state and country laws while starting their businesses or expanding to a new state or country. We collectively analyzed three businesses that were exploring different possibilities for expanding operation in Texas, Arizona and India, however, none of us chose to write about…

Words 871 - Pages 4

The New Arizona Immigration Law Essay

Arizona Immigration Law The Constitution of The United States was built on the purpose to provide rights and protection for all citizens as well as instructions on how the government should administrate the people. The United States has faced a great challenge in determining the precise necessities of its inhabitants when it comes to illegal immigration. Consequently, politicians whose strategies emphasize on battling illegal immigration have in the past received much public support from American…

Words 996 - Pages 4

Essay on Scarf: Immigration and Law

Contemporary Proposal A seemingly controversial topic over the course of American history has been immigration and the formation of the laws for the issue. Throughout our country’s history, if one wasn’t an American born citizen, they were then considered an immigrant. Over the years certain measures or laws were made to restrict or reduce the number of immigrants allowed into the Continental U.S.A. Only until Ellis Island open in 1892 were immigrants allowed to flow into America and granted…

Words 1267 - Pages 6

An Analysis Of The State Of Arizona

Arizona without proper documentation; police officers were given the unprecedented power to make warrantless arrests on those suspected of having committed a crime, at some point or another, that would constitute grounds for deportation; and lastly, law enforcement officials were given the discretion to stop any individual based on the mere suspicion that they were an illegal immigrant (Howe). In June of 2012, the Supreme Court ruled that the only original stipulation of the bill that met constitutional…

Words 2348 - Pages 10

Essay History: Immigration to the United States and Federal Government Retain

individual by virtue of citizenship, especially the fundamental freedoms and privileges guaranteed by the 13th and 14th Amendments to the U.S. Constitution and by subsequent acts of Congress, including civil liberties, due process, equal protection of the laws, and freedom from discrimination. Although civil rights are defined and reserved to Americans by virtue of citizenship, we run a great risk of chaos and unrest as a nation if states have the power to legislate over immigration issues. It is very…

Words 551 - Pages 3

Essay on Immigration: Illegal Immigration and Immigrants

illegal immigration." (New York Times, 2010) The Arizona immigration law, also known as SB1070, is a law stating that if a person fails to provide the proper documentation showing that they are a legal alien they are convicted of a misdemeanor. This law also allows law enforcement officials to ask any suspicious person for documentation papers after any lawful contact. I strongly agree with the SB1070 law for many reasons. Arizona putting a stop to immigration helps decrease…

Words 1128 - Pages 5

Persuasive Essay On Tent City Jail

Tent city, a jail ran by the notorious Sheriff Joe Arpaio. A man who believes true rehabilitation comes from the physical abuse of being in Arizona’s hot climate, while simultaneously being humiliated in numerous ways. Arpaio has reportedly marched his inmates through downtown Phoenix in their striped uniforms and pink garments, and has even offered jail tours in which the inmates are put on display (Lee). This jail is comprised of outdoor tents located in the outskirts of Phoenix, Arizona where…

Words 548 - Pages 3

Comparing Two Stories

money, or to provide stories that are easy to cover, sometimes we are forced to reassess the accuracy of a news story conveyed by journalists and broadcasters. With that being said, two stories that need to be reassessed for accuracy are Arizona’s Immigration Laws – involving SB170 and the September 11th attacks in 2001. For example, the tragic attacks on the WTC along with the Pentagon attacks on September 11, 2001, were quite the most devastated attacks in United States history. Meanwhile, following…

Words 1170 - Pages 5

Banning Ethnic Studies

Arizona’s Educational Superintendent John Huppenthal gave the Tucson district sixty days to cancel their controversial courses in ethnic studies or face a loss of up to fifteen million dollars annually in state funding. With an already lean educational budget…

Words 716 - Pages 3

Analytical Paper

parents. The main concern for this issue is the parent’s choice of not having their child enrolled in the ELL program the school has in place and parents’ rights for inadequate ELL services. This paper looks at court cases, school policies, and federal laws that relate to students being placed in an ELL program without the consultation or input from their parents. Some people believe schools are overzealous when placing students in ELL programs. Parents feel that oftentimes, schools are discriminating…

Words 2158 - Pages 9