In The Awakening and Story of an Hour both protagonists escape the world that has them trapped by committing suicide, whereas Mamzelle’s liberation consisted of a moment of regret after her house was left empty of the effusiveness brought by her neighbor’s children. Xang concludes her essay by stating that had Louise lived she would not have been allowed to exert her newfound freedom. The social constraints that kept her tied to her husband against her will would still be there, even if Mr. Mallard had actually died. The same can be said for Edna Pontelleir. She had to die in order to truly become free, otherwise she would have been at the mercy of her rich and powerful husband. Following that logic, by the end of the story Mamzelle is still tied to the system that had driven her to choose a life of solitude over the idea of marriage and its