Essay on Summary: Evolution and Molecular Biology

Submitted By napol11
Words: 1206
Pages: 5
Open Document
“Theory Structure and Theory Change in Contemporary Molecular Biology”
Sylvia Culp and Philip Kitcher

Abstract
Traditional approaches to theory structure and theory change in science do not farewell when confronted with the practice of certain fields of science. We offer an account of contemporary practice in molecular biology designed to address two questions: Is theory change in this area of science gradual or saltatory? What is the relation between molecular biology and the fields of traditional biology? Our main focus is a recent episode in molecular biology, the discovery of enzymatic RNA. We argue that our reconstruction of this episode shows that traditional approaches to theory structure and theory change need considerable refinement if they are to be defended as generally applicable.

Outline
1. Introduction
2. Practices in Contemporary Molecular Biology
3. The Discovery of Enzymatic RNA
4. Understanding the Change
5. Derivative Revolutions and Reductionism Revisited

1. Despite a plethora of critiques of what used to be known, quite aptly, as the 'received view' of scientific theories, contemporary debates about inter-theoretic relations and about theory change are still often conducted as if scientific theories could be unproblematically identified as deductively closed sets of sentences. In our judgment, the attempt to find some small number of general laws that can serve as the axioms of the scientific theory under study has proved especially baneful in the biological sciences. Even where axiomatization has been achieved-as in the careful studies of Mary Williams on the theory of natural selection [1970, 1973]-there are serious questions as to whether the axiomatization captures what is central to the theory as biologists actually understand it, use it, and develop it. Indeed, we believe that the continued smouldering problems about the 'triviality' or 'unfalsifiability' of neo-Darwinism are, in large measure, the product of thinking that there has to be some principle(or principles)of great generality that formulate the core of the theory of evolution by natural selection (see Kitcher [1982], pp. 55-60). Similarly,in the debates about the reduction of classical genetics to molecular biology, the macro-level theory has been essentially divorced from what geneticists have been doing since approximately 1915 (let alone 1953) by proposing that classical genetics can be identified with the logical consequences of Mendel's laws (or minor adjustments of those laws). If any scientific theory worthy of the name is a deductively closed set of sentences whose axioms include generalizations that range over all the entities in the domain of the theory, then it seems that either biology has no theories or what theories it has are both trivial and irrelevant to the thinking and activity of almost all contemporary biologists.
Nor are things much better if we abandon the syntactic conception of theories in favor of its chief rival, the so-called 'semantic view of theories', according to which a theory is a class of models. Although this approach is valuable in differentiatinga theory from its formulations (Suppe [1972]), in clarifying the relation between theory and observation (Van Fraassen[1980]), and in reconstructing parts of important biological theories (Lloyd [1984], Lloyd [forthcoming]), we believe that it encounters problems that are parallel to those besetting the older conception when it seeks to treat theories at a high level of generality. The task of specifying the class of models that is Darwinian evolutionary theory or the class of models that is classical genetics gives us no more adequate a picture of these biological disciplines than does the task of specifying the axioms of these theories-and for the obvious reason that the new-style specifications of sets of models look remarkably like the old-style axioms (see Beatty [1980] and Giere [1979] for examples).Proponents of the semantic view have
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Summary: Evolution and Molecular Biology

Sex-Linked Traits Through Meiosis and How It Relates to Genetics. Essay

|Principles of Biology | Copyright © 2011, 2010, 2008 by University of Phoenix. All rights reserved. Course Description This course is designed to introduce…

Words 1614 - Pages 7

Essay on particle theory

what will be the long-term fate of newly emerged pathogens? Part of the challenge is that emergence, by nature, transcends scientific disciplines, occurring as the product of human behavior, environmental change, population, cellular and molecular biology, and evolution. Solutions therefore demand innovative pairing of theory and fundamental science with applied research and evidence-based policy-making. My doctoral research used viral infections of bats to answer fundamental questions about pathogen…

Words 2028 - Pages 9

Healthcare: Clinical Text Analysis

The system was designed to extract structure and automatically encode clinical information in textual reports of patients such as radiology reports, discharge summaries, visit notes, electrocardiography, echocardiography, and pathology notes [19]. MedLEE has been used to detect patients with suspected tuberculosis, breast cancer, stroke, and community acquired Pneumonia from texts [20]. MedLEE has been shown to…

Words 1127 - Pages 5

American Alligator Observation

low. The alligator digs holes that retain water during dry periods. This mechanism is also a popular and vital habitat for survival of other animals located in that biome. The American Alligator is an interesting species when studying evolutionary biology because of their physical experience, such as body armor, and their…

Words 717 - Pages 3

Molecular Evidence Of HIV-1 Transmission In A Criminal Case

Molecular evidence of HIV-1 transmission in a criminal case Michael L. Metzker*†, David P. Mindell‡, Xiao-Mei Liu*§, Roger G. Ptak¶ʈ, Richard A. Gibbs*, and David M. Hillis** *Department of Molecular and Human Genetics, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX 77030; ‡Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology and Museum of Zoology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109-1079; ¶School of Dentistry, Biologic and Materials Sciences, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109; and **Section…

Words 5777 - Pages 24

Essay on _x000C_Apoptosis: Programmed Cell Death

Programmed cell death 2 m Apoptosis of a human white blood cell. Dr H. Gutierrez Cell biology: Week 9, Nov 2012 Apoptosis during the metamorphosis of a tadpole into a frog As a tadpole changes into a frog, the cells in the tadpole tail are induced to undergo apoptosis; as a consequence, the tail is lost. All the changes that occur during metamorphosis, including the induction of apoptosis in the tail, are stimulated by an increase in thyroid hormone in the blood. Figure 11.22…

Words 2145 - Pages 9

Biol 2401 Ch 1 notes Essay

techniques is called gross anatomy 3. Microscopic structural study is called histology a.. Histopathology, the histology of diseased tissue b. Cytology, the study of cellular structure and function c. Ultrastructure, the study of fine detail down to the molecular level B. Physiology – The study of function; often divided into subdisciplines. Comparative physiology is used to understand human physiology without human experimentation or to observe evolutionary trends between species II. The Origins of Biomedical…

Words 2209 - Pages 9

Traditions and Encounters: Rome Notes Essay

If I asked you to find a definition for “science” you would probably find something similar to the listing above. As biology majors, you will spend the next several years learning “science” (definition 2) so you can practice “science” (definition 3) as a career. An important aspect of all the sciences is the application of the scientific method. Observations are made, questions are asked, hypotheses are developed, experiments are performed, data are collected, and conclusions are drawn. These…

Words 3083 - Pages 13

Summary of Prevail and Transcend Scenario in Radical Evolution Essay

Summary of Prevail and Transcend Scenario In chapter six of Radical Evolution, author Joel Garreau shows through various interviews and examples that even though technology may be rising on an exponentially increasing Curve, humans may still be able to change the effects of technological advance in unpredictable ways. Deemed the Prevail scenario, it is also characterized by humans slowing down once-viewed inevitable change viewed as negative and speeding up positive change. Another great theme…

Words 1441 - Pages 6

Molecular Cell Biology

Molecular Cell Biology Table of Contents: Section a (the Cell Wall): page 3 Section b (cell membrane): page 4 Section c (endoplasmic reticulum): page 5 Section d (mitochondria): page 6 Section e (chloroplast): page 7 Section f (ribosomes): page 8 Section g (golgi body or the golgi apparatus): page 9-10 Section h (lysozomes): page 11-13 Section i (vacuoles and vesicles): page 14-16 Section j (nucleus and nucleolus): page 17-21…

Words 6074 - Pages 25