The parents wanted it banned. They filed suit on delineation that the prayer overstepped their religious beliefs and religious practices for themselves, and their children. The parents then insisted that the prayer violated the federal constitutions first amendment that the state should not make any laws in regards to religious matters, which was also stated in the fourteenth amendment of the New York constitution.
The main issue before the court was in the establishment Claus of the first amendment, which was included also in New York’s state constitution in the fourteenth amendment and violation between church and state. Several legal questions were identified. Question one was whether the New York Regents had interfered with the free action of everybody’s religion. The prayer was found to be clear of aiming towards one specific religion since it was very vague. Majority claimed that the prayer being said upon the