Sumner: Slavery in the United States and Slavery Essay

Submitted By brianita333
Words: 1711
Pages: 7
Open Document
The caning of Senator Charles Sumner of Massachusetts by Representative Preston Brooks of South Carolina demonstrated the growing sectional conflict of the 1850s and foreshadowed the violence on the battlefield between armies of the North and the South.
The Compromise of 1850
Conflict over slavery in the territories began in the1840s, and by the end of the decade, had risen to a crisis point. Compromise was still possible, however, because the second party system was built on nationally-based parties with a vested interest in maintaining peace. Additionally, though sectionalism existed, the North and South were not as divided as they would become.
The Problem of Slavery in the Mexican Cession
The Constitution gave the federal government the right to abolish the international slave trade, but no power to regulate or destroy the institution of slavery where it already existed. Additionally, the Constitution said nothing about the status of slavery in future states. Because Congress controlled the process of admittance, it could regulate the extension of slavery before a territory became a state and had done so in the Missouri Compromise of 1820. So long as both the free North and the slave South had some opportunities for expansion, compromise was possible.
The Wilmot Proviso Launches the Free-Soil Movement
The Wilmot Proviso of 1846 was proposed to ban African Americans, whether slave or free, from any territory acquired from the Mexican War. This blend of racist and antislavery sentiment appealed to many Northerners anxious to preserve new lands for free Whites. Although the House initially approved the Proviso, the Senate defeated it. In these Congressional votes, politicians broke down along sectional rather than party lines. This sectional divide was mirrored in state and local reactions to the Proviso as well, providing an ominous foreshadowing of the conflict to come.
Squatter Sovereignty and the Election of 1848
By the time of the election in 1848, the status of slavery in the Mexican cession was still unresolved. There were four positions on the issue. The two extremes were represented by the Wilmot Proviso and absolute federal protection of slavery in the territories. The two middle-ground positions were a proposal to extend the Missouri Compromise line, and a new approach—popular sovereignty—that would leave the question of slavery in a territory to the actual settlers. In the election, Whig Zachary Taylor, avoiding a stand on the issue but promising no executive interference with congressional legislation, defeated two challengers: Democrat Lewis Cass who urged “popular sovereignty,” and Free-Soiler Martin Van Buren who favored the Wilmot Proviso.
Taylor Takes Charge
Taking immediate action, President Taylor proposed admitting California and New Mexico directly as states, bypassing territorial status and the arguments over slavery in Congress. The possibility that only free states would emerge from the Mexican cession provoked intense southern resistance and talk of secession.
Forging a Compromise
Although Taylor resisted compromise until his death, his successor, Millard Fillmore, supported a series of resolutions known as the Compromise of 1850. After heated debate, members of Congress, who voted on the measures separately, agreed to admit California as a free state, organize the territories of New Mexico and Utah on the basis of popular sovereignty, retract the borders of Texas in return for assumption of the state’s debt, and abolish the slave trade in the District of Columbia. The most controversial provision created a strong Fugitive Slave Law, denying suspected runaways any rights of self-defense, and requiring northerners to enforce slavery. As it had over the Wilmot Proviso, Congress at first broke down along sectional rather than party lines. By 1852, both parties endorsed the compromise, rendering them indistinct on the slavery issue.
Political Upheaval 1852-1856
The Compromise of 1850 may
Show More

Related Documents: Sumner: Slavery in the United States and Slavery Essay

Civil War Causes

main cause of the American Civil War was slavery, and whether it was a necessity to the economy or if it was morally wrong. Events leading up to the Civil War would follow under the categories of political; Lincoln/Douglas, The Nullification Crisis, and the Kansas/Nebraska Act. Economical; northern industrialization vs. southern cotton kingdom, tariffs and taxes, and the Whiskey Rebellion. And social; Uncle Tom’s Cabin, Dred Scott case, and the caning of Sumner. Economically, the southerners were far…

Words 704 - Pages 3

Dbq Mexican War

sizing almost equal to the United States. Mexico’s northern land was in need of settlers, so they began welcoming American settlers to the land. Eventually, in 1836, Texas declared independence from Mexico and twice applied over a course of nine years to be annexed by the United States. When James Polk became president in 1844, he annexed Texas, being a large believer in Manifest Destiny, or the god-given right to expand the…

Words 1091 - Pages 5

Ordinance Of Freedom DBQ

Secondly, the United States disobeyed Mexican laws and practiced slavery in Mexico even though it was illegal. For example,” Mexico, on achieving her independence from the Spanish Crown. decreed the abolition of human slavery within her dominions, embracing the province of Texas.”(Doc D) This shows that after Mexico became an independent state, they abolished the practice of slavery in the Mexican Ordinance of Freedom. Afterward, Mexico claimed Texas to be a part of Mexico and they allowed Americans…

Words 293 - Pages 2

Causes of the Civil War Essay

Conner Ties Shrunk 3 12/3/14 Causes of the Civil War Essay The United States of America had just finished the Mexican American War which ended with battle of Chapultepec. After this American victory Mexico signed the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo and with that gained a huge chunk of land, but with that land came decisions. Many people would believe that after fighting a war against a common enemy the country would unified together even greater. However it was far from unified and on the verge…

Words 745 - Pages 3

Cause Of The Civil War Essay

had opposing views upon slavery and states’ rights. It resulted in bloodshed and bad vibes between the divided country. The three most important events that started the Civil War was Missouri’s Statehood, the Beating of Senator Sumner, and the Election of 1860. The first cause of the Civil War was Missouri’s Statehood. A small portion of Missouri was below the 36, 30 line that divided the country so that the government could decide which states were free or slave states. Although, most of Missouri…

Words 428 - Pages 2

What Caused The Civil War

What Caused the Civil War? The controversies that sparked the Civil War had been in view since the United States was born. The three most extrusive causes of the Civil war were, the concern of slavery, because Southerners though it was a necessary evil and the north did not think it was necessary. Southerners were also claiming to be unreasonably treated through unfair taxation, states’ rights, and once again, the issue of slavery, and the final spark was John Brown’s raid, this was the moment when the Southerners realized they were not to trust anyone…

Words 995 - Pages 4

Essay On Mexican American War

their slaves. Mexico had already abolished slavery but we brought and kept them anyway. Mexico was not happy with this and America was mad at Mexico for not allowing them to hold slaves (Sumner, 329). American citizens deliberately defied and ignored Mexico’s laws. Americans would bring slave and signed the contract but would not adhere to the laws of Mexico but would take the land and have slaves (Sumner, 329). “Decreed the abolition of slavery.” (Sumner, 329) This means that slaves will not be allowed…

Words 709 - Pages 3

Was The Mexican War Justified Essay

Was the Mexican War justified? In the mid 1800’s, the United States of America was a relatively new country, eager to expand its land. America had already bought the Louisiana Purchase, and was looking for more suitable land to settle into. America’s reason for increasing its land was Manifest Destiny. Manifest Destiny was a belief that it was God’s plan for America to expand its territory across the continent to the Pacific Ocean, and spread democracy. Once Mexico declared itself independent…

Words 1205 - Pages 5

Essay on Slavery in America and the Bleeding Kansas Crisis

The United States is known for compromises between the North and the South. Until 1861, the U.S. tried to make peace between the two regions especially in the question of slavery. Sectional tension between the North and the South was reduced for a short period of time because of certain political compromises, like the Missouri Compromise, but the actions of the federal government increased sectional tensions too because of the failure of the Kansas-Nebraska Act and the Dred Scott Case. Sectional…

Words 2876 - Pages 12

Civil War Abolition

abolition of slavery. The Civil War had a plethora of inciting factors, many of which were influenced and driven by the institution of slavery, but complete abolition was never considered at first. Many northerners were dismayed with the South’s expansion of slavery and feared that they would have complete political control over the country. Southerners believed that the North had absolute control over the government by oppressing the South’s way of life, by opposing their expansion. While slavery was the…

Words 1526 - Pages 7